Interesting, if incomplete read.
Nick Bishop’s replies in the Comments Section are very illuminating!
He comes across as someone obsessed with numbers not nuance.
It’s pretty obvious to anyone with a modicum of rugby IQ (the new buzz phrase) that the ‘two tier’ appearance of the 6N is a direct result of the player base and funding at the club/regional level.
The top three teams finished stronger because the fall off from their starting to finishing players was not as dramatic as the bottom three teams both in terms of ability and experience.
Wales winning the 6N is arguably a bigger achievement than an England, France, or Ireland winning the Grand Slam. I would have included Italy and Scotland in this but as shit as Wales has been the past 2-3 seasons the other two aren’t winning it any time soon.
One thing which wasn’t mentioned/analysed is the impact not competing at the lineout has made to to the game.
Why any defending team inside their own 22 would give the attacking team an uncontested opportunity to win the ball, set up a maul, and more often than not score a try baffles me
Check that, why wouldn’t you compete at every lineout regardless of field position?