All Blacks v France Test #2
-
Ngatai got a YC for this one, and IIRC Gardner says his landing has affected colour of the card, the fact he has done a full somersault saved Ngatai a red.
-
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks v France Test #2:
@nepia Fall was never getting that before BB, peripheral vision helps alot, how did he avoid other players but not be aware of where BB was if he couldnt pull out?
I have no issue with the RC as it was dangerous, however as I said earlier, in an incident like that, I feel that FRance get to send a replacement on after 10/20 mins, but that guy is out of the game.
IMO, RC for the rest of the game should be for punches, kicks, gouges etc, these are different and as such should be treated differently and he will now likely be punished further when he fronts up to the judiciary.
Otherwise as it turned out last night, the French guy was punished, as were the rest of both teams and the millions that chose to watch it.
That's an interesting idea worth pursuing. Right now it's 10 minutes or game. Maybe something Inbetween? 20 minutes.
-
@rancid-schnitzel said in All Blacks v France Test #2:
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks v France Test #2:
@nepia Fall was never getting that before BB, peripheral vision helps alot, how did he avoid other players but not be aware of where BB was if he couldnt pull out?
I have no issue with the RC as it was dangerous, however as I said earlier, in an incident like that, I feel that FRance get to send a replacement on after 10/20 mins, but that guy is out of the game.
IMO, RC for the rest of the game should be for punches, kicks, gouges etc, these are different and as such should be treated differently and he will now likely be punished further when he fronts up to the judiciary.
Otherwise as it turned out last night, the French guy was punished, as were the rest of both teams and the millions that chose to watch it.
That's an interesting idea worth pursuing. Right now it's 10 minutes or game. Maybe something Inbetween? 20 minutes.
Ten minutes for the player but then he has to be subbed off for the rest of the game. Moriarty's actions this morning should still be a straight red.
-
I wonder what the injury data is for leaping collisions is.
Does the data identify that the landings are an area that needs urgent attention? A strong history of serious spinal injuries?
If it's a high risk situation then only red would be reasonable, but to a cynic like me, the random landing deciding the colour of a card looks like window dressing.Then again, legislate heavily for aerial contests and you lose a thrilling feature of the game.
Wonder what the grass roots injury data is for aerial contests?
To be fair though the behaviour modification in contested kicks over the last 5 years appears to have been improving, albeit a few instances like yesterday.
Hate 14 vs 15
-
Went to the game and watched the replay last night. Looked waaay tidier onscreen compared to watching live, where it was disjointed and a pretty average watch. Some good periods but those felt few and far between. RC pretty much killed the vibe in the stadium.
Felt like we thought it'd be easy to crack them afterwards but France amped up and our accuracy and patience went to shit.
Don't blame the ref but am liking these ideas of taking the player off and allowing a replacement after 20min. So there is a clear punishment, but we don't totally ruin the contest.
Deliberate foul play should still get the status quo though. -
@paekakboyz said in All Blacks v France Test #2:
Looked waaay tidier onscreen compared to watching live
My god it must have been truly appalling at the ground then!
-
@snowy it was some ragged ass shit bro. Probably the worst live AB performance I've seen. Kept waiting for us to kick up a few gears but it just never happened.
-
@paekakboyz said in All Blacks v France Test #2:
@snowy it was some ragged ass shit bro. Probably the worst live AB performance I've seen. Kept waiting for us to kick up a few gears but it just never happened.
I think social media told a massive story. Usually I get inundated with selfies from people at the game, last night I got none!
-
-
@bones said in All Blacks v France Test #2:
Haven't read the thread only just watched the game. Really nice of them to dedicate it to Shields with it being at the tin and him getting his first start. Toaster hands all around.
Yep was just thinking that after I watched England and Shields get mullered.
Right now Aus doesn't look that crash-hot either.Reckon come RWC time 40% of this current AB team won't be there, and the main challenge will come from the Boks.
-
@shadowtrooper so they're going to drop 6-7 starters and 3-4 off the bench? Who?
-
@paekakboyz said in All Blacks v France Test #2:
Went to the game and watched the replay last night. Looked waaay tidier onscreen compared to watching live, where it was disjointed and a pretty average watch. Some good periods but those felt few and far between. RC pretty much killed the vibe in the stadium.
Felt like we thought it'd be easy to crack them afterwards but France amped up and our accuracy and patience went to shit.
Don't blame the ref but am liking these ideas of taking the player off and allowing a replacement after 20min. So there is a clear punishment, but we don't totally ruin the contest.
Deliberate foul play should still get the status quo though.It was pretty morgue like after the red card, eh. Was actually bored, highlight was moody try.
-
@taniwharugby I agree with you that red card should be reserved for kicks and punches etc.
But, I think people are forgetting the speed of rugby game - if you're running tracking a ball that you think you're getting to there may only be a split second before you realise that you're not going to make it. I think it can come down to luck, then it's luck again depending on how a guy lands whether you go off for 10 minutes or for the whole match. Then there's the jump forwarders (not saying BB did this but it happens) who cut out the space but are actually the ones causing the danger, yet it's always the lower jumper/on the ground guy who gets sanctioned.
-
You can't ban jumping for the ball, but you could ban leaping while on the run. Two guys jumping side by side only hurt each other if an ankleor knee is twisted on landing or one guy deliberately pulls at the other.
It's not that Barrett is high that causes the problem, but at that speed there's a huge path along which any contact is going to tip him.
Either that or the defender needs to be given priority to catch before an attacker.
-
-
@booboo said in All Blacks v France Test #2:
@donsteppa said in All Blacks v France Test #2:
Arse throw from Harris
Where's Aumua?
Too early for that boy
-
@bones Right I think the Squire/Fifita experiment is over, Harris, Whitelock L are not AB quality.
Others have been put on notice - Crotty, TJ,P Ardie and even Scott Barrett all need to wkae themselves up. Fifita. Crotty and Squire seem to spend most of their time down injured anyway. And BFA just looks... well, OLD.
We have Read, BBBR, SBW still to return and maybe an injection of new blood from the saviour Frizell (I jest) and Aumua (Taylor was in his infancy at RWC 2015) will help,
Seriously though, we need more GRAFTERS, workhorses and unsung heroes prepared to roll their sleeves up and do the dirty work, We seem to have too many faffing around *Ardies I'm looking at you) ready to grab glory rather than getting in amongst it. -
-
@shadowtrooper said in All Blacks v France Test #2:
@bones Right I think the Squire/Fifita experiment is over, Harris, Whitelock L are not AB quality.
Others have been put on notice - Crotty, TJ,P Ardie and even Scott Barrett all need to wkae themselves up. Fifita. Crotty and Squire seem to spend most of their time down injured anyway. And BFA just looks... well, OLD.
We have Read, BBBR, SBW still to return and maybe an injection of new blood from the saviour Frizell (I jest) and Aumua (Taylor was in his infancy at RWC 2015) will help,
Seriously though, we need more GRAFTERS, workhorses and unsung heroes prepared to roll their sleeves up and do the dirty work, We seem to have too many faffing around *Ardies I'm looking at you) ready to grab glory rather than getting in amongst it.You think they'll drop them both?
-
@act-crusader said in All Blacks v France Test #2:
@booboo said in All Blacks v France Test #2:
@donsteppa said in All Blacks v France Test #2:
Arse throw from Harris
Where's Aumua?
Too early for that boy
Aumua has been injured otherwise there is little doubt he would be in the squad.
Stuff
