All Black Coach - Ian Foster
-
@mofitzy_ said in All Black Coach - Ian Foster:
Completely wishful thinking but perhaps they want a caretaker coach until other coaches become available. Of course, if he does well then he keeps the job, so it should be win win.
The key is not just the head coach but the coaching team. Joseph and Brown are a great team but Joseph without Brown not so good
The other aspect is coaches who can understand and get the best from players from very different backgrounds etc. For example I hope they have one at least non white coach or selector.
If Foster can get a team of quality assistant coaches who gel together it could be a great outcome. Plumtree if he is involved would be a great start
-
@No-Quarter said in All Black Coach - Ian Foster:
I recall everyone on here being stoked with the team we selected in Perth...
It was a decent team. I don't think the players were the problem.
The Fern, collectively, had been banging on about how poor our game plans had been since the Lions series.
I maintain that we were right -- it was in the coaching box that we failed, not the players on the pitch.
@ACT-Crusader said in All Black Coach - Ian Foster:
Conversely there were high expectations heading into 2000 after the Wayne Smith appointment and things didn’t really pan out that well....
Wayne Smith is the first guy I would put on any coaching list. He's absolutely brilliant.
Our assessment of his ability was correct except one rather key flaw -- he isn't a head coach.
-
@mofitzy_ said in All Black Coach - Ian Foster:
Completely wishful thinking but perhaps they want a caretaker coach until other coaches become available. Of course, if he does well then he keeps the job, so it should be win win.
Under-qualified succession candidates like Foster seem to always get the gig over younger upstarts in instances like this because it is simultaneously harder to turn them down (part of the furniture, sympathy, connections), but easier to fire them in the future (you had your chance, we gave you the benefit of the doubt etc).
It's the wrong way of making decisions and the antithesis of what NZ Rugby is at it's strongest; a meritocracy.
-
-
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Black Coach - Ian Foster:
Nothing wrong with boring if you're winning...
plenty moaned about rugby being boring a few years back...team picks itself, we win too much...
be interesting to see what changes they make to the playing 23
-
@voodoo said in All Black Coach - Ian Foster:
@booboo Hanson was something like 79% over the last 3yrs I think
Hasen should really be viewed as the first cycle with McCaw/Carter/Smith/Nonu and the second cycle without. Much like Hart he was a 95% coach in the first half of his tenure and effectively sub 70% against tier one sides in the second stanza.
The percentage thing is pretty much a misnomer anyway unless you are comparing full cycle to full cycle the ~10% difference between Smith and Mitchell is that Smith had two 3N and one EOYT vs two EOYT, two 3N and a RWC.
-
@rotated said in All Black Coach - Ian Foster:
@voodoo said in All Black Coach - Ian Foster:
@booboo Hanson was something like 79% over the last 3yrs I think
Hasen should really be viewed as the first cycle with McCaw/Carter/Smith/Nonu and the second cycle without. Much like Hart he was a 95% coach in the first half of his tenure and effectively sub 70% against tier one sides in the second stanza.
The percentage thing is pretty much a misnomer anyway unless you are comparing full cycle to full cycle the ~10% difference between Smith and Mitchell is that Smith had two 3N and one EOYT vs two EOYT, two 3N and a RWC.
And Aussie in one of their best ever cycles.
-
Admiting that they didn;t get it right, basically.
-
Can anyone recall an AB coach unwanted as universally as Foster? Deans/Wylie/Hart was all provincial bullshit, Mitchell was wasn't hated until well into the journey.
-
@Crazy-Horse guess he can only exceed expectations...surely?
-
@Crazy-Horse Mains in 1992 was fun times on usenet.
-
@Bovidae internet? I was still sending smoke signals back then.
-
@Crazy-Horse I had corrected my post for accuracy. Usenet newsgroups were all the go then (e.g., r.s.r.u).
-
@taniwharugby definitely half empty. That way I can make myself feel better with a 'told you so' when I am right.
-
@Bovidae said in All Black Coach - Ian Foster:
@Crazy-Horse I had corrected my post for accuracy. Usenet newsgroups were all the go then (e.g., r.s.r.u).
What a car crash that place turned into. To think that lunatic morrissey breen was probably responsible for its decline.
-
-
