Springboks v All Blacks I
-
@stodders this seems right. Selection and grooming are the most underemphasized keys to a successful head coach.
Rassnaber got their initial calls largely right and then got lucky with Kriel’s injury at the RWC prodding them to their best squad.
Nienasmus on the other hand have not been as effective. @Billy-Webb and @SidBarret have highlighted the biggest call: Wiese v Louw/Roos. I’d start Louw with Roos on the bench in place of Moerat.
If Snyman wasn’t injured you’d pick him and let Roos hunger to improve. Basically get your best players in the squad and adapt your strategies. Moerat isn’t Snyman and Wiese is a third rate Waal Bartman.
Meanwhile Foster can’t work out that he needs to find a blindside who can carry in heavy traffic and a 2nd five who can create space. Thank god he didn’t have the nous to demand he be allowed to select Laumape and Luatua as Robinson drank his tea.
-
@Smuts said in Springboks v All Blacks I:
@stodders this seems right. Selection and grooming are the most underemphasized keys to a successful head coach.
Rassnaber got their initial calls largely right and then got lucky with Kriel’s injury at the RWC prodding them to their best squad.
Nienasmus on the other hand have not been as effective. @Billy-Webb and @SidBarret have highlighted the biggest call: Wiese v Louw/Roos. I’d start Louw with Roos on the bench in place of Moerat.
If Snyman wasn’t injured you’d pick him and let Roos hunger to improve. Basically get your best players in the squad and adapt your strategies. Moerat isn’t Snyman and Wiese is a third rate Waal Bartman.
Meanwhile Foster can’t work out that he needs to find a blindside who can carry in heavy traffic and a 2nd five who can create space. Thank god he didn’t have the nous to demand he be allowed to select Laumape and Luatua as Robinson drank his tea.
I think their thinking is that Vermeulen is going to get nursed to the next WC, so Roos or Louw are good players to have in camp, but not good enough yet to start. Vermeulen is a mighty player, but it is hell of a risk for player that will be 37 at the WC.
I know Roos got a lot of plaudits this year playing for WP, but I liked what I saw from Louw. He is raw power and very physical, which your coaching team like. Roos is a bit Skinstad-esque for me. A show pony :-).
You are lucky to have both of them. And to think, Marcel Coetzee can't even get a look in (he can cover all back row positions).
-
@Smuts said in Springboks v All Blacks I:
@stodders this seems right. Selection and grooming are the most underemphasized keys to a successful head coach.
Rassnaber got their initial calls largely right and then got lucky with Kriel’s injury at the RWC prodding them to their best squad.
Nienasmus on the other hand have not been as effective. @Billy-Webb and @SidBarret have highlighted the biggest call: Wiese v Louw/Roos. I’d start Louw with Roos on the bench in place of Moerat.
If Snyman wasn’t injured you’d pick him and let Roos hunger to improve. Basically get your best players in the squad and adapt your strategies. Moerat isn’t Snyman and Wiese is a third rate Waal Bartman.
Meanwhile Foster can’t work out that he needs to find a blindside who can carry in heavy traffic and a 2nd five who can create space. Thank god he didn’t have the nous to demand he be allowed to select Laumape and Luatua as Robinson drank his tea.
NZ won't be selecting overseas players until Hell begins to get cool. It isn't in the plan.
Havili is more a Mauger type player. I'm not sure that is a good thing as Barrett or Mo'unga at 10 results in a smallish 10/12 axis. If they are going with ball players at 10 and 12, you'd expect to see more manipulation of opposing defences to create gaps or weak shoulders that can be exploited. Like Ireland did.
Carter always spoke glowingly about playing with Nonu at 12. He was his get out ball if nothing was on in that phase. NZ would look very different if Kerevi was an AB. Or Tuilagi.
-
@Billy-Webb Ox and Thomas Tank is available. Myself would love to see Deon Fourie starting in 6. Roos from the bench. But then I am a one eyed WP supporter.
-
@canefan said in Springboks v All Blacks I:
@stodders said in Springboks v All Blacks I:
@Billy-Webb said in Springboks v All Blacks I:
@SidBarret said in Springboks v All Blacks I:
My issue with Nyakane is actually the opposite, i think he will do well in the scrums, but he offers much less around the park than Ox (is he injured?)
Nyakane had issues in Wales three and were conned early in the england game last year, but I don't think he'll be fooled as easily again and on proper pitch his brute power should win out.
As for Moerat - hes not Snyman, but if we are going with 6-2 bench (which i dont think we should) then he is right pick to keep the physical pressure on the All Blacks.
Fuck knows what Rasnaber sees in Wiese. He only has one dimension (carrier). So the squad contains five candidates for the no 8 jerseys each of whom is at least equal to Wiese as a carrier while bringing other skills to the team.
We desparately need Pollard to find form. If he plays well I am very confident that we'll win and win well, but I also have almost zero confidence that he'll do that so yeah, its a fifty fifty game.
Well, let's hope you're half right and I am half right when it comes to Nyakane in that he scrums better than I think, and he is better in the loose than you think Sid
Can't seem to find any news on Ox, but I have to assume he is injured?I am fine with the 6-2 concept, if we have the right players in the bombsquad. That means guys who can cover a range of positions - and be highly effective doing so. So entire front row - tick. Franco covers you for lock and blindside - tick. Not sure we need yet another lock given that onfield PSDT could also slot back in the second row. I would have liked to see Roos in place of Moerat but no doubt that is heavily influenced by Jasper's inclusion...
Kwagga actually gives you cover at 6, 8 and probably could do a job in the outside backs.
Agreed on Pollard. He needs to get his mojo fully back. I am (perhaps wishfully) thinking I saw some progress in the 3rd Wales test..?
The one point I didn't mention is Jaden Hendrikse. I like him, but his service is below par slow. He really needs to up that part of his game.
You sound like an AB supporter from several years ago nit picking at the odd selection, but deep down knowing that the majority of the best players available have been selected and if they play well will likely win.
The Boks are clear, outright favourites. Consistency in selection, everyone knows the game plan, combinations are tried and tested, playing at home in front of a raucous crowd. A win should be a formality
We are definitely underdogs
Worse than that. We are underpups.
-
Great preview from Nick Easter
Expert Witness: Nick Easter previews South Africa v New Zealand clash
Former England number eight Nick Easter previews the Rugby Championship clash between South Africa and New Zealand in Mbombela.
-
-
@No-Quarter yea me too....2....0 to our All Black's!!
-
@Steve said in Springboks v All Blacks I:
Laumape would be really handy right now.
If in doubt just shovel him some hospital ball slop.
Recycle.
Try again.
Ah. I guy who runs into a brick wall and was a failure in France where they like that sort of thing. Yip really handy. A stupid game plan is our biggest issue at present. This is not exactly screaming Einstein.
-
@BartMan BartMan!!!! It's been decades, how are you. Joan and I doing well......Mary ancient now
😀I'm, actually dreading the game tomorrow. Been a long time since I'm second guessing, coach, players and loss of a 3nd, 3rd, or 4th plan 🤔.
-
@Frye I agree that the jury is out and we will never know because he’s always injured. I don’t think he should even be on the tour until he has played on a consistent basis. He is becoming a Kahui where he could possibly be a solution if he was fit. When was the last time he played? I think it was the super rugby final.
-
@Billy-Tell stop posting from alt accounts fozzie. You’ve got enough on your plate trying to get some sort of cutting edge in your midfield.
-
Consider me corrected.
-
-
-
@BartMan yeah scrums are a concern, however the only positive I can see is there aren't a huge number of scrums in the game nowadays, lineouts are 3 or 4 times more likely, and up until the Irish series we had a decent lineout...
But like you say, a defensive scrum on our own line might be time to get another strong drink!
-
@Frye said in Springboks v All Blacks I:
Great preview from Nick Easter
Former England number eight Nick Easter previews the Rugby Championship clash between South Africa and New Zealand in Mbombela.
It was good up until he called the 2011 All Blacks an average team. They were easily the best team in the world and it was only the weight of history and an unprecedented injury crisis that kept everyone else in it.
-
