Best of all time?
-
@Mackerzzzz said in Best of all time?:
Who's Andy ripley
Part of an England team that beat NZ in NZ & Sth Africa in Sth Africa. Also part of the 1974 Lions. Great player.
-
@Victor-Meldrew said in Best of all time?:
@Mackerzzzz said in Best of all time?:
Who's Andy ripley
Part of an England team that beat NZ in NZ & Sth Africa in Sth Africa. Also part of the 1974 Lions. Great player.
Also good in a very corny 70's/80's TV sports show called "Superstars". A very good all round athlete.
-
@Mackerzzzz said in Best of all time?:
@booboo said in Best of all time?:
PS I'm thinking picking Burger is the equivalent of picking Parisse ...
Dito previous coment. Have you actually watched him?
Actually, good call: No I haven't.
And there's a reason for that: coz he's really good at club level, and does not play tests.
I wonder if he's better than Gorgodze?
And for the record Michael Jones doesn't make my XV, because Kaino.
The best loose forward trio I've ever seen ... better than Whetton-Jones-Shelford, or Shaw-Mourie-Mexted, or Hill-Back-Dallaglio, or ... can't think of too many more combos who may be comparable ... is Kaino-McCaw-Read (2010 version ... ).
You'd have to be be fucking amazeballs to be better than 2010 Kaino, against the best teams in the world.
And Burger gets a mention coz he goes ok in club footy.
Yay.
Sorry (not really) but I think picking him is up there with picking Parisse so you're seen to be looking wider.
-
@Mackerzzzz said in Best of all time?:
@Nepia said in Best of all time?:
@Mackerzzzz said in Best of all time?:
1. T Woodcock (nz)
2. K Wood (ire)
3. O Brown (nz)
4. M Johnson (eng)
5. J Eales (aus)
6. J Burger (nam)
7. R McCaw (nz)
8. Z Brooke (nz)
9. G Edwards (wal)
10. D Carter (nz)
11. J Lomu (nz)
12. M Nonu (nz)
13. B O'Driscoll (ire)
14. D Campese (aus)
15. C Cullen (nz)16. O Du Rant (sa)
17. S Fitzpatrick (nz)
18. P Vickery (eng)
19. V Matfield (sa)
20. J Collins (nz)
21. F Du Preez (sa)
22. J Wilkinson (eng)
23. J Robinson (eng)This has to be a troll, MJ doesn't even make the bench and some dude from Namibia is in there.
Seems to have kicked off a thread though so that's all good.
Try watching jac burger and you will see why I added him. Who would you have over johnson?
We've all seen Burger. He's pretty good in a shit team, I'd say at least ten blokes across just the Tri nations teams who could outplay him with one hand tied behind their backs.
-
My best ‘ANZAC’ side of players in the pro era (and I’m not going all Fitzy)
1- T. Woodcock
2- S. Fitzpatrick
3- O. Brown
4- J. Eales
5- S. Whitelock
6- G. Smith
7- R. McCaw
8- Z. Brooke
9- G. Gregan
10- D. Carter
11- J. Lomu
12- T. Horan
13- M. Nonu
14- J. Rokocoko
15- C. Cullen16- K. Mealamu
17- C. Dowd
18- O. Franks
19- B. Retallick
20- M. Jones
21- J. Marshall
22- A. Mehrtens
23- M. BurkeWider squad: P. Kearns, C. Hayman, N. Sharp, K. Read, N. Farr-Jones, B. Barrett, D. Campese, D. Howlett
-
@Catogrande said in Best of all time?:
@Victor-Meldrew said in Best of all time?:
@Mackerzzzz said in Best of all time?:
Who's Andy ripley
Part of an England team that beat NZ in NZ & Sth Africa in Sth Africa. Also part of the 1974 Lions. Great player.
Also good in a very corny 70's/80's TV sports show called "Superstars". A very good all round athlete.
The England team of that period was outstanding. The likes of John Pullen & Bill Beaumont were some of England's best-ever players
-
@Bones said in Best of all time?:
@Mackerzzzz said in Best of all time?:
@Nepia said in Best of all time?:
@Mackerzzzz said in Best of all time?:
1. T Woodcock (nz)
2. K Wood (ire)
3. O Brown (nz)
4. M Johnson (eng)
5. J Eales (aus)
6. J Burger (nam)
7. R McCaw (nz)
8. Z Brooke (nz)
9. G Edwards (wal)
10. D Carter (nz)
11. J Lomu (nz)
12. M Nonu (nz)
13. B O'Driscoll (ire)
14. D Campese (aus)
15. C Cullen (nz)16. O Du Rant (sa)
17. S Fitzpatrick (nz)
18. P Vickery (eng)
19. V Matfield (sa)
20. J Collins (nz)
21. F Du Preez (sa)
22. J Wilkinson (eng)
23. J Robinson (eng)This has to be a troll, MJ doesn't even make the bench and some dude from Namibia is in there.
Seems to have kicked off a thread though so that's all good.
Try watching jac burger and you will see why I added him. Who would you have over johnson?
We've all seen Burger. He's pretty good in a shit team, I'd say at least ten blokes across just the Tri nations teams who could outplay him with one hand tied behind their backs.
He’s not even the best Burger to play in the 6 jersey
-
@Victor-Meldrew said in Best of all time?:
@Catogrande said in Best of all time?:
@Victor-Meldrew said in Best of all time?:
@Mackerzzzz said in Best of all time?:
Who's Andy ripley
Part of an England team that beat NZ in NZ & Sth Africa in Sth Africa. Also part of the 1974 Lions. Great player.
Also good in a very corny 70's/80's TV sports show called "Superstars". A very good all round athlete.
The England team of that period was outstanding. The likes of John Pullen & Bill Beaumont were some of England's best-ever players
Hmm. Not sure I quite agree. We did have some of our greats playing then, but also some pretty ordinary journeymen getting quite a few caps. Add in a revolving door selection policy, unfathomable coaching and in the main our team was shite for ten years or more. We had one or two stand out games but they were rare.
On the whole I’d say somewhat less than the sum of their parts.
-
@ACT-Crusader Larkham > Merhts.
-
@KiwiMurph said in Best of all time?:
@ACT-Crusader Larkham > Merhts.
I tend to agree with you - I know which one I would pay the most to see play. However Merhtens suited the All Blacks way of playing (at that time) much more so than Larkham would have, and of course vice-versa. In a similar way that Andrew suited England's way of playing in the 90's much more than Barnes, though most would say Barnes was the better player.
-
You're right. For some reason I thought England were really successful between 72-75, but their 5N's record was actually shite. Great results on tour though
-
@Catogrande said in Best of all time?:
@KiwiMurph said in Best of all time?:
@ACT-Crusader Larkham > Merhts.
I tend to agree with you - I know which one I would pay the most to see play. However Merhtens suited the All Blacks way of playing (at that time) much more so than Larkham would have, and of course vice-versa. In a similar way that Andrew suited England's way of playing in the 90's much more than Barnes, though most would say Barnes was the better player.
I can never forgive the great Bill McLaren for naming Rob Andrew as his all time greatest 10.
-
@Victor-Meldrew said in Best of all time?:
@Catogrande said in Best of all time?:
@KiwiMurph said in Best of all time?:
@ACT-Crusader Larkham > Merhts.
I tend to agree with you - I know which one I would pay the most to see play. However Merhtens suited the All Blacks way of playing (at that time) much more so than Larkham would have, and of course vice-versa. In a similar way that Andrew suited England's way of playing in the 90's much more than Barnes, though most would say Barnes was the better player.
I can never forgive the great Bill McLaren for naming Rob Andrew as his all time greatest 10.
Yeah that's a bit of a stretch. Andrew was actually a much better player than his England performances would suggest. The trouble with him though is that he is establishment through and through. He would happily play to a game plan that was negative, that was against many of our strengths and that was a world away of why he probably played rugby in the first place. That is why he got a shed load of caps and Stuart Barnes got a handful. It's probably also the reason that he got prestigious jobs within the RFU despite being singularly unsuitable for them.
-
@Catogrande said in Best of all time?:
@Victor-Meldrew said in Best of all time?:
@Catogrande said in Best of all time?:
@KiwiMurph said in Best of all time?:
@ACT-Crusader Larkham > Merhts.
I tend to agree with you - I know which one I would pay the most to see play. However Merhtens suited the All Blacks way of playing (at that time) much more so than Larkham would have, and of course vice-versa. In a similar way that Andrew suited England's way of playing in the 90's much more than Barnes, though most would say Barnes was the better player.
I can never forgive the great Bill McLaren for naming Rob Andrew as his all time greatest 10.
Yeah that's a bit of a stretch. Andrew was actually a much better player than his England performances would suggest. The trouble with him though is that he is establishment through and through. He would happily play to a game plan that was negative, that was against many of our strengths and that was a world away of why he probably played rugby in the first place. That is why he got a shed load of caps and Stuart Barnes got a handful. It's probably also the reason that he got prestigious jobs within the RFU despite being singularly unsuitable for them.
I always rated Rory Underwood for the simple reason he scored bags of tries outside of Guscott & Andrew.... Jeez, he was a great finisher.
-
S’funny but Rory rarely gets mentioned in the discussion about England’s greatest wingers, recency bias I guess, but he was a gun winger for sure.
-
@Catogrande said in Best of all time?:
S’funny but Rory rarely gets mentioned in the discussion about England’s greatest wingers, recency bias I guess, but he was a gun winger for sure.
Really, I'd have thought he'd be the first wing on the team sheet? Or Alexander Oblensky.
-
@Mackerzzzz said in Best of all time?:
@booboo said in Best of all time?:
PS I'm thinking picking Burger is the equivalent of picking Parisse ...
Dito previous coment. Have you actually watched him?
Was he a standout in the competitive club games? The sort of player everyone said his performances for the Bulls meant South Africa was missing out?
-
@ACT-Crusader said in Best of all time?:
@taniwharugby said in Best of all time?:
@ACT-Crusader I'd swap Ralph for Berryman.
You would, Mr North Auckland…😉
Love Stormin, but Ralph’s Saders record was pretty phenomenal in terms of longevity and try scoring.
Will Jordan over Gear and it's not close. Sevu over Vuni as well.
-
@Chris-B said in Best of all time?:
@ACT-Crusader said in Best of all time?:
@taniwharugby said in Best of all time?:
@ACT-Crusader I'd swap Ralph for Berryman.
You would, Mr North Auckland…😉
Love Stormin, but Ralph’s Saders record was pretty phenomenal in terms of longevity and try scoring.
Will Jordan over Gear and it's not close. Sevu over Vuni as well.
Gear’s strike rate for us was right up there, 30 tries. Jordan is on the right trajectory to get past that but not quite there yet.
-
@KiwiMurph said in Best of all time?:
@ACT-Crusader Larkham > Merhts.
Yeah, nah. Lomu, Cullen and Tana didn’t score all those tries without Mertz running that cutter 😎
