All Blacks vs Springboks I
-
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
yeah, my comment earlier was definitely not an attempt to say the current wingers weren't good, they in general are world class by most standards
No sorry, I can't let that pass. Rieko aside, they're good international class with future upside, no more.
World class for me means you'd make a world #1 23 or world #2 23 squad so six top wingers maximum.
Top six wings off the top of my head ... Anthony Watson, Louis Rees-Zammit, Rieko Ioane, Cheslin Kolbe, maybe Marika Koroibete, + 1 more (I would have said Jonny May a year ago).
Go on, give me your top 6 wings worldwide then ...
-
@l_n_p said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
yeah, my comment earlier was definitely not an attempt to say the current wingers weren't good, they in general are world class by most standards
No sorry, I can't let that pass. Rieko aside, they're good international class with future upside, no more.
World class for me means you'd make a world #1 23 or world #2 23 squad so six top wingers maximum.
Top six wings off the top of my head ... Anthony Watson, Louis Rees-Zammit, Rieko Ioane, Cheslin Kolbe, maybe Marika Koroibete, + 1 more (I would have said Jonny May a year ago).
Go on, give me your top 6 wings worldwide then ...
thats semantics on how you use the term world class...so you could have let it pass
my post was a reply to the comment our current wingers are scoring at a fantastic rate, Marika Koroibete for example has scored 14 in 35 according to google, so less than ours, i think even bridge would probably comfortably be in the conversations for several international teams, just because we have very high expectations doesnt mean theyre not good on a more global scale
-
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
@l_n_p said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
yeah, my comment earlier was definitely not an attempt to say the current wingers weren't good, they in general are world class by most standards
No sorry, I can't let that pass. Rieko aside, they're good international class with future upside, no more.
World class for me means you'd make a world #1 23 or world #2 23 squad so six top wingers maximum.
Top six wings off the top of my head ... Anthony Watson, Louis Rees-Zammit, Rieko Ioane, Cheslin Kolbe, maybe Marika Koroibete, + 1 more (I would have said Jonny May a year ago).
Go on, give me your top 6 wings worldwide then ...
thats semantics on how you use the term world class...so you could have let it pass
my post was a reply to the comment our current wingers are scoring at a fantastic rate, Marika Koroibete for example has scored 14 in 35 according to google, so less than ours, i think even bridge would probably comfortably be in the conversations for several international teams, just because we have very high expectations doesnt mean theyre not good on a more global scale
I know, I said sorry in advance ...
If you listen to Australian fans after any win, at least 50% of their side is world class
I'm harsh on how I view world-class but at least I define it, because the term gets thrown around like confetti.
Almost any AB who's good enough to get even 10-20 caps would probably start in at least half the top tier sides, that's pretty much a given for me at all times.
Does that make (say) Victor Vito or Steven Luatua or Adam Thompson world class? Not for me ...
-
@l_n_p said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
@l_n_p said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
yeah, my comment earlier was definitely not an attempt to say the current wingers weren't good, they in general are world class by most standards
No sorry, I can't let that pass. Rieko aside, they're good international class with future upside, no more.
World class for me means you'd make a world #1 23 or world #2 23 squad so six top wingers maximum.
Top six wings off the top of my head ... Anthony Watson, Louis Rees-Zammit, Rieko Ioane, Cheslin Kolbe, maybe Marika Koroibete, + 1 more (I would have said Jonny May a year ago).
Go on, give me your top 6 wings worldwide then ...
thats semantics on how you use the term world class...so you could have let it pass
my post was a reply to the comment our current wingers are scoring at a fantastic rate, Marika Koroibete for example has scored 14 in 35 according to google, so less than ours, i think even bridge would probably comfortably be in the conversations for several international teams, just because we have very high expectations doesnt mean theyre not good on a more global scale
I know, I said sorry in advance ...
If you listen to Australian fans after any win, at least 50% of their side is world class
I'm harsh on how I view world-class but at least I define it, because the term gets thrown around like confetti.
Almost any AB who's good enough to get even 10-20 caps would probably start in at least half the top tier sides, that's pretty much a given for me at all times.
Does that make (say) Victor Vito or Steven Luatua or Adam Thompson world class? Not for me ...
fair enough, im just the other side of the coin, we've been bless with several players that would walk into the GOAT category, i try not to judge the current guys too much just because theyre not stacking up to those GOATs
-
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
fair enough, im just the other side of the coin, we've been bless with several players that would walk into the GOAT category, i try not to judge the guys too much just because theyre not stacking up to those GOATs
I think we're aligned on how good a player even a ... relative to other ABs ... "average" AB is, in US corporate speak
Totally. In Europe, step back a bit and think how many goodish SR players (who were never even really close to AB selection) have carved out international careers. Wales, Ireland, Scotland especially. England less so, only Brad Shields for brief period comes to mind.
-
-
@l_n_p said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
yeah, my comment earlier was definitely not an attempt to say the current wingers weren't good, they in general are world class by most standards
No sorry, I can't let that pass. Rieko aside, they're good international class with future upside, no more.
World class for me means you'd make a world #1 23 or world #2 23 squad so six top wingers maximum.
Top six wings off the top of my head ... Anthony Watson, Louis Rees-Zammit, Rieko Ioane, Cheslin Kolbe, maybe Marika Koroibete, + 1 more (I would have said Jonny May a year ago).
Go on, give me your top 6 wings worldwide then ...
Rees-Zammit is potential only and has less of a test match body of work than Jordan.
Watson is terrible and the Boks proved that demoattably.
Cheslin, Rieko and probably Josh Adams in the order
-
-
@bones I won't argue it ... pick your 6, I did say mine were "top of the head".
But my point was more that if you take a view that "world class" is really the cream of the crop internationally (which I do), I'm not sure currently a NZ winger makes it, apart from Rieko.
For clarity, I'd say Retallick, Whitelock, Smith are undoubtably world class. Probably BB, certainly he has been, and on form like Pumas 2 he is worldclass ...
Akira and Paps look like they have potential to be world class pretty soon.
-
@l_n_p i actually thought of a better way to word my thoughts, world class being those good enough to play on the world stage, ie international rugby
Those standing head and shoulders above other international players i would refer to as world beaters or something similar
-
@kiwiwomble We need formal rules on this, standardized across rugby forums and boards.
A citing panel for misuse of terms ...
The aussies will ask for exemptions so more of their players can be "world beaters" ...
-
@l_n_p ...im sure getting agreement across the whole forum shouldn't be too hard.....
-
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
@l_n_p ...im sure getting agreement across the whole forum shouldn't be too hard.....
Well there are a whole lot of beaters on here.
-
@l_n_p said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
fair enough, im just the other side of the coin, we've been bless with several players that would walk into the GOAT category, i try not to judge the guys too much just because theyre not stacking up to those GOATs
I think we're aligned on how good a player even a ... relative to other ABs ... "average" AB is, in US corporate speak
Totally. In Europe, step back a bit and think how many goodish SR players (who were never even really close to AB selection) have carved out international careers. Wales, Ireland, Scotland especially. England less so, only Brad Shields for brief period comes to mind.
Willie Heinz ? Riki Flutey ?
-
@cgrant said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
@l_n_p said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
fair enough, im just the other side of the coin, we've been bless with several players that would walk into the GOAT category, i try not to judge the guys too much just because theyre not stacking up to those GOATs
I think we're aligned on how good a player even a ... relative to other ABs ... "average" AB is, in US corporate speak
Totally. In Europe, step back a bit and think how many goodish SR players (who were never even really close to AB selection) have carved out international careers. Wales, Ireland, Scotland especially. England less so, only Brad Shields for brief period comes to mind.
Willie Heinz ? Riki Flutey ?
Let's not forget Henry Paul, Thomas Waldrom.
-
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
@l_n_p ...im sure getting agreement across the whole forum shouldn't be too hard.....
Tbh I actually did a serious terminology-agreement exercise like this with a huge and very passionate international community on Twitter (not rugby related).
1 slide, with 20 definitions and supporting examples.
F*ck it was SO hard going at first because so many can take it personally ... understandably in the area I was doing it ... until they really see you're open and trying to improve communication and establish common understandings, then you'd start to get so much really thoughtful feedback.
Took months, god knows how many iterations ... retweet, get more inputs, repeat.
In short, thanks but not again. Don't let me stop you though ...
-
@bones said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
@cgrant said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
@l_n_p said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs Springboks I:
fair enough, im just the other side of the coin, we've been bless with several players that would walk into the GOAT category, i try not to judge the guys too much just because theyre not stacking up to those GOATs
I think we're aligned on how good a player even a ... relative to other ABs ... "average" AB is, in US corporate speak
Totally. In Europe, step back a bit and think how many goodish SR players (who were never even really close to AB selection) have carved out international careers. Wales, Ireland, Scotland especially. England less so, only Brad Shields for brief period comes to mind.
Willie Heinz ? Riki Flutey ?
Let's not forget Henry Paul, Thomas Waldrom.
I think you're re-inforcing @Kiwiwomble's point George Bridge could just walk into a lot of Tier 1 international sides. I mean think about it, Ireland have James Lowe playing for them now ...?
-
Jesus there some clueless comments here, not all of them, but these leapt out. More stuff to be up on the changing room walls 😜
This is not the same team that won the World Cup. Let's be very clear on that. They've lost a number of their players who have headed off overseas
SA freely pick from anywhere
And two years ago, they were playing a lot more open and expansive rugby than this team is showing us this year."
Obviously didn't watch the semi versus Wales
The fullback is fine; Willie le Roux is a very good player
Was
