All Blacks 2021
-
@dan54 said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
Our paymakers in the backs are lacking some composure... they need to be reading situations better & executing more accurately.
Yeah, Foster made that point.
But what do you think is causing them to read situations so badly and executing more accurately? What do they need to do - apart from playing better - to improve the situation?
The coach can't think for the players out on the field - it's completely up to the playmakers to show some smarts/focus during a game... if a player keeps on making the same thoughtless errors they don't deserve to start, drop him & give someone else a crack.
Unless you have a coach who is devoid of idea's and doesn't trust his players enough.
One thing I have seen disappear under Foster and co is our ability to play heads up Rugby and play what is in front of us. It used to be one of our strengths.The ability to see or create space by giving the players the confidence to play what they see,Vision is missing, we miss a lot of attacking opportunities by not backing ourselves.Lack of confidence in the Coaches and game plan maybe.We are definitely not helped by having a coach that has very little insight - but it's also on the players to play thoughtful rugby... totally agree, we play at our best when we plays what's in front of us, especially with the fast paced game we have.
Do you not think we are losing the ability to play heads up rugby because our players skill level seems to of dropped over last 4-5 years. Watch super rugby these days and ask yourself when the last time we saw NZ teams play down the blinside and be able to execute 2-3 passes at speed and beat defenders with speed of pass etc even in the 5m tramline. Something I have been noticing since about 2017-18, our super teams seem a lot more structured, or predictable.
Yeah, fair points... the game isn't helped though with the breakdown becoming even more of a clusterfuck each season because they keep changing the laws there, also refs are letting all sides stand well offside way too much.
-
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@dan54 said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
Our paymakers in the backs are lacking some composure... they need to be reading situations better & executing more accurately.
Yeah, Foster made that point.
But what do you think is causing them to read situations so badly and executing more accurately? What do they need to do - apart from playing better - to improve the situation?
The coach can't think for the players out on the field - it's completely up to the playmakers to show some smarts/focus during a game... if a player keeps on making the same thoughtless errors they don't deserve to start, drop him & give someone else a crack.
Unless you have a coach who is devoid of idea's and doesn't trust his players enough.
One thing I have seen disappear under Foster and co is our ability to play heads up Rugby and play what is in front of us. It used to be one of our strengths.The ability to see or create space by giving the players the confidence to play what they see,Vision is missing, we miss a lot of attacking opportunities by not backing ourselves.Lack of confidence in the Coaches and game plan maybe.We are definitely not helped by having a coach that has very little insight - but it's also on the players to play thoughtful rugby... totally agree, we play at our best when we plays what's in front of us, especially with the fast paced game we have.
Do you not think we are losing the ability to play heads up rugby because our players skill level seems to of dropped over last 4-5 years. Watch super rugby these days and ask yourself when the last time we saw NZ teams play down the blinside and be able to execute 2-3 passes at speed and beat defenders with speed of pass etc even in the 5m tramline. Something I have been noticing since about 2017-18, our super teams seem a lot more structured, or predictable.
Yeah, fair points... the game isn't helped though with the breakdown becoming even more of a clusterfuck each season because they keep changing the laws there, also refs are letting all sides stand well offside way too much.
I think the rush defence (and very skinny offside laws being applied) really is what stops teams being able to play the game where you set up a ruck in midfield etc like we used to, as players are getting caught at or behind the gainline, which negates quick ball. I also believe it is why we getting the box kick so often from halfbacks, as biggest crime is passing to someone who will get knocked over behind gainline.
Well that's what I think is causing it anyway. -
@dan54 said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@dan54 said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
Our paymakers in the backs are lacking some composure... they need to be reading situations better & executing more accurately.
Yeah, Foster made that point.
But what do you think is causing them to read situations so badly and executing more accurately? What do they need to do - apart from playing better - to improve the situation?
The coach can't think for the players out on the field - it's completely up to the playmakers to show some smarts/focus during a game... if a player keeps on making the same thoughtless errors they don't deserve to start, drop him & give someone else a crack.
Unless you have a coach who is devoid of idea's and doesn't trust his players enough.
One thing I have seen disappear under Foster and co is our ability to play heads up Rugby and play what is in front of us. It used to be one of our strengths.The ability to see or create space by giving the players the confidence to play what they see,Vision is missing, we miss a lot of attacking opportunities by not backing ourselves.Lack of confidence in the Coaches and game plan maybe.We are definitely not helped by having a coach that has very little insight - but it's also on the players to play thoughtful rugby... totally agree, we play at our best when we plays what's in front of us, especially with the fast paced game we have.
Do you not think we are losing the ability to play heads up rugby because our players skill level seems to of dropped over last 4-5 years. Watch super rugby these days and ask yourself when the last time we saw NZ teams play down the blinside and be able to execute 2-3 passes at speed and beat defenders with speed of pass etc even in the 5m tramline. Something I have been noticing since about 2017-18, our super teams seem a lot more structured, or predictable.
Yeah, fair points... the game isn't helped though with the breakdown becoming even more of a clusterfuck each season because they keep changing the laws there, also refs are letting all sides stand well offside way too much.
I think the rush defence (and very skinny offside laws being applied) really is what stops teams being able to play the game where you set up a ruck in midfield etc like we used to, as players are getting caught at or behind the gainline, which negates quick ball. I also believe it is why we getting the box kick so often from halfbacks, as biggest crime is passing to someone who will get knocked over behind gainline.
Well that's what I think is causing it anyway.Didn't we start last year with refs changing to judging if the defence was 'clearly onside' rather than 'clearly offside'? That made a big difference in that defences had to halt for a split second.
As the year progressed this disappeared (possibly because it was a SH thing and we had NH refs?) and we didn't really change our attack because of the change.
Maybe it is time to make the 5 metre rule apply to rucks as well? -
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
Our paymakers in the backs are lacking some composure... they need to be reading situations better & executing more accurately.
Yeah, Foster made that point.
But what do you think is causing them to read situations so badly and executing more accurately? What do they need to do - apart from playing better - to improve the situation?
The coach can't think for the players out on the field - it's completely up to the playmakers to show some smarts/focus during a game...
Agreed. And I think it's down to the big gap between handling pressure at Super Rugby and Test levels. And that's probably been going on for some time and was masked by the likes of Conrad, Kev, Nonu, Carter, and even Cruden. A lot of the current players are brilliant but don't give you that rock-solid feeling under pressure they did. ALB & now Jordie being the exception - and Finlay Christie seemed to handle the pressure pretty well too
Perhaps we should put more emphasis on rounded players with mental toughness rather than whiz-bangery.
if a player keeps on making the same thoughtless errors they don't deserve to start, drop him & give someone else a crack.
But if the domestic Super Rugby produces the same sort of players with the same problems.....?
Reckon the gap isn't that big in terms of mental toughness between Super Rugby & international as there's a lot of international players involved in the Super Comp, but there certainly is a step up.
Yeah, doesn't matter how good a players skill sets are, if they don't have that mental toughness they're not going to perform well at international level... but our current playmakers do have the mental toughness & skill sets as they've shown plenty of times before, reckon BB is better suited as a 15 though, at times these players need to be dropped so it gives them a good shake up, making them refocus & wanting to get back into the starting team.
We have very good depth, if any of these Super Rugby players want to get selected in the AB squad they know they have to execute their skill sets accurately & have the mindset to handle the real pressure situations... this current coaching staff are clueless, so we need to select a good coaching that will then select the right players from our Super comp etc.
-
@dan54 said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@dan54 said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
Our paymakers in the backs are lacking some composure... they need to be reading situations better & executing more accurately.
Yeah, Foster made that point.
But what do you think is causing them to read situations so badly and executing more accurately? What do they need to do - apart from playing better - to improve the situation?
The coach can't think for the players out on the field - it's completely up to the playmakers to show some smarts/focus during a game... if a player keeps on making the same thoughtless errors they don't deserve to start, drop him & give someone else a crack.
Unless you have a coach who is devoid of idea's and doesn't trust his players enough.
One thing I have seen disappear under Foster and co is our ability to play heads up Rugby and play what is in front of us. It used to be one of our strengths.The ability to see or create space by giving the players the confidence to play what they see,Vision is missing, we miss a lot of attacking opportunities by not backing ourselves.Lack of confidence in the Coaches and game plan maybe.We are definitely not helped by having a coach that has very little insight - but it's also on the players to play thoughtful rugby... totally agree, we play at our best when we plays what's in front of us, especially with the fast paced game we have.
Do you not think we are losing the ability to play heads up rugby because our players skill level seems to of dropped over last 4-5 years. Watch super rugby these days and ask yourself when the last time we saw NZ teams play down the blinside and be able to execute 2-3 passes at speed and beat defenders with speed of pass etc even in the 5m tramline. Something I have been noticing since about 2017-18, our super teams seem a lot more structured, or predictable.
Yeah, fair points... the game isn't helped though with the breakdown becoming even more of a clusterfuck each season because they keep changing the laws there, also refs are letting all sides stand well offside way too much.
I think the rush defence (and very skinny offside laws being applied) really is what stops teams being able to play the game where you set up a ruck in midfield etc like we used to, as players are getting caught at or behind the gainline, which negates quick ball. I also believe it is why we getting the box kick so often from halfbacks, as biggest crime is passing to someone who will get knocked over behind gainline.
Well that's what I think is causing it anyway.Yeah, which is basically allowing too much offside play, all this nonsense is ruining the game.
-
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2021:
@reddog said in All Blacks 2021:
So maybe breaking up the pod and back to ruck and run.
Really interesting point
I may be wrong, but I think there was a period in the French Test (start of 2nd half?) when we did exactly that. Then the backs buggered things up, we lost momentum and went back to what we'd been doing for years.
yeah, after the break in the french game the forwards kept to close and we made great yards, i remember very quickly swinging back "here we come!"
thats the lead up to the "awesome" little play where were about 5 from their line...smith to Richie on the blind side...who steps back behind the ruck and passes to QT.....who then tries to step back behind richie to go back to the blind....who is already behind the ruck and gets flattened by some front rowers who have walked half a dozen steps upfield with quizzical looks on their faces trying to figure out what exactly these pretty boys were trying to do
-
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
@dan54 said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@dan54 said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
Our paymakers in the backs are lacking some composure... they need to be reading situations better & executing more accurately.
Yeah, Foster made that point.
But what do you think is causing them to read situations so badly and executing more accurately? What do they need to do - apart from playing better - to improve the situation?
The coach can't think for the players out on the field - it's completely up to the playmakers to show some smarts/focus during a game... if a player keeps on making the same thoughtless errors they don't deserve to start, drop him & give someone else a crack.
Unless you have a coach who is devoid of idea's and doesn't trust his players enough.
One thing I have seen disappear under Foster and co is our ability to play heads up Rugby and play what is in front of us. It used to be one of our strengths.The ability to see or create space by giving the players the confidence to play what they see,Vision is missing, we miss a lot of attacking opportunities by not backing ourselves.Lack of confidence in the Coaches and game plan maybe.We are definitely not helped by having a coach that has very little insight - but it's also on the players to play thoughtful rugby... totally agree, we play at our best when we plays what's in front of us, especially with the fast paced game we have.
Do you not think we are losing the ability to play heads up rugby because our players skill level seems to of dropped over last 4-5 years. Watch super rugby these days and ask yourself when the last time we saw NZ teams play down the blinside and be able to execute 2-3 passes at speed and beat defenders with speed of pass etc even in the 5m tramline. Something I have been noticing since about 2017-18, our super teams seem a lot more structured, or predictable.
Yeah, fair points... the game isn't helped though with the breakdown becoming even more of a clusterfuck each season because they keep changing the laws there, also refs are letting all sides stand well offside way too much.
I think the rush defence (and very skinny offside laws being applied) really is what stops teams being able to play the game where you set up a ruck in midfield etc like we used to, as players are getting caught at or behind the gainline, which negates quick ball. I also believe it is why we getting the box kick so often from halfbacks, as biggest crime is passing to someone who will get knocked over behind gainline.
Well that's what I think is causing it anyway.Didn't we start last year with refs changing to judging if the defence was 'clearly onside' rather than 'clearly offside'? That made a big difference in that defences had to halt for a split second.
As the year progressed this disappeared (possibly because it was a SH thing and we had NH refs?) and we didn't really change our attack because of the change.
Maybe it is time to make the 5 metre rule apply to rucks as well?That's right the refs were much stricter on the offside rule for a while, so we got much better quality rugby to watch, unfortunately the refs didn't apply that rule for that long... it's always up to the playmakers to adapt to any situation though.
Yeah, they should apply a 5 metre rule to rucks or at least make them stay back more - it's a refs job to consistently apply the offside rule in every game... always make me laugh when a ref has an absolute bloody howler, yet they are not very often punished for it by standing them down for a few weeks.
-
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
Maybe it is time to make the 5 metre rule apply to rucks as well?
You'll just have people crying that they aren't five metres back. The solution is to have competent officials, not keep changing the rules.
-
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
@dan54 said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@dan54 said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
Our paymakers in the backs are lacking some composure... they need to be reading situations better & executing more accurately.
Yeah, Foster made that point.
But what do you think is causing them to read situations so badly and executing more accurately? What do they need to do - apart from playing better - to improve the situation?
The coach can't think for the players out on the field - it's completely up to the playmakers to show some smarts/focus during a game... if a player keeps on making the same thoughtless errors they don't deserve to start, drop him & give someone else a crack.
Unless you have a coach who is devoid of idea's and doesn't trust his players enough.
One thing I have seen disappear under Foster and co is our ability to play heads up Rugby and play what is in front of us. It used to be one of our strengths.The ability to see or create space by giving the players the confidence to play what they see,Vision is missing, we miss a lot of attacking opportunities by not backing ourselves.Lack of confidence in the Coaches and game plan maybe.We are definitely not helped by having a coach that has very little insight - but it's also on the players to play thoughtful rugby... totally agree, we play at our best when we plays what's in front of us, especially with the fast paced game we have.
Do you not think we are losing the ability to play heads up rugby because our players skill level seems to of dropped over last 4-5 years. Watch super rugby these days and ask yourself when the last time we saw NZ teams play down the blinside and be able to execute 2-3 passes at speed and beat defenders with speed of pass etc even in the 5m tramline. Something I have been noticing since about 2017-18, our super teams seem a lot more structured, or predictable.
Yeah, fair points... the game isn't helped though with the breakdown becoming even more of a clusterfuck each season because they keep changing the laws there, also refs are letting all sides stand well offside way too much.
I think the rush defence (and very skinny offside laws being applied) really is what stops teams being able to play the game where you set up a ruck in midfield etc like we used to, as players are getting caught at or behind the gainline, which negates quick ball. I also believe it is why we getting the box kick so often from halfbacks, as biggest crime is passing to someone who will get knocked over behind gainline.
Well that's what I think is causing it anyway.Didn't we start last year with refs changing to judging if the defence was 'clearly onside' rather than 'clearly offside'? That made a big difference in that defences had to halt for a split second.
As the year progressed this disappeared (possibly because it was a SH thing and we had NH refs?) and we didn't really change our attack because of the change.
Maybe it is time to make the 5 metre rule apply to rucks as well?That's right the refs were much stricter on the offside rule for a while, so we got much better quality rugby to watch, unfortunately the refs didn't apply that rule for that long... it's always up to the playmakers to adapt to any situation though.
Yeah, they should apply a 5 metre rule to rucks or at least make them stay back more - it's a refs job to consistently apply the offside rule in every game... always make me laugh when a ref has an absolute bloody howler, yet they are not very often punished for it by standing them down for a few weeks.
I guess that the problem with a 5 metre rule at rucks is that it becomes difficult to rule on in a fast fluid situation so teams will push it as much as they can and we will get just as much inconsistency depending on the ref team.
I liked the 'clearly onside' method if applied strictly. Tell teams that if the AR can't see a clear gap behind the last foot you will be pinged.
While this will give us better ball in hand rugby there is still a need to teams to be better at exploiting space behind the D.
If a 10 can put the ball into space and make the D (and forwards) have to scramble back they eventually that pays off. You may have to cede possession a couple of times but applying pressure and forcing errors can be valuable. More valuable than recycling on the gain line until you kick it away. -
@antipodean said in All Blacks 2021:
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
Maybe it is time to make the 5 metre rule apply to rucks as well?
You'll just have people crying that they aren't five metres back. The solution is to have competent officials, not keep changing the rules.
Of course you want competent refs involved, the trouble is all the referees around the world are not refereeing properly when it comes to the offside rule, in fact bloody poorly.
Sometimes the rules need to be adjusted so the game flows better making it a better watch too, unfortunately the IRB keep adding new laws every years year, which just continues to overcomplicate the game even more. -
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@antipodean said in All Blacks 2021:
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
Maybe it is time to make the 5 metre rule apply to rucks as well?
You'll just have people crying that they aren't five metres back. The solution is to have competent officials, not keep changing the rules.
Of course you want competent refs involved, the trouble is all the referees around the world are not refereeing properly when it comes to the offside rule, in fact bloody poorly.
Sometimes the rules need to be adjusted so the game flows better making it a better watch too, unfortunately the IRB keep adding new laws every years year, which just continues to overcomplicate the game even more.Untrue.
It is the different competitions and ref groups that seem to alter interpretations (then lose focus ) and WR will also allow law trials in different areas.
To me the biggest 'problem' is interpretation of materiality between refs. It is left to opinion and 'feel' of the game.
Quite often refs will be totally aware of rushing outsides that are offside but interpret that as it is a long way from play there is no effect. Others will ping it. Some only call close of midfield overstepping, some only call it in the attacking zone.
In fact 'attacking zone' is also a bugbear of mine. For a team that can attack and create breaks from anywhere offside play from the defence is often ignored out wide right where they would like to send the ball.
That's also where a good captain will come in. -
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
@dan54 said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@dan54 said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
Our paymakers in the backs are lacking some composure... they need to be reading situations better & executing more accurately.
Yeah, Foster made that point.
But what do you think is causing them to read situations so badly and executing more accurately? What do they need to do - apart from playing better - to improve the situation?
The coach can't think for the players out on the field - it's completely up to the playmakers to show some smarts/focus during a game... if a player keeps on making the same thoughtless errors they don't deserve to start, drop him & give someone else a crack.
Unless you have a coach who is devoid of idea's and doesn't trust his players enough.
One thing I have seen disappear under Foster and co is our ability to play heads up Rugby and play what is in front of us. It used to be one of our strengths.The ability to see or create space by giving the players the confidence to play what they see,Vision is missing, we miss a lot of attacking opportunities by not backing ourselves.Lack of confidence in the Coaches and game plan maybe.We are definitely not helped by having a coach that has very little insight - but it's also on the players to play thoughtful rugby... totally agree, we play at our best when we plays what's in front of us, especially with the fast paced game we have.
Do you not think we are losing the ability to play heads up rugby because our players skill level seems to of dropped over last 4-5 years. Watch super rugby these days and ask yourself when the last time we saw NZ teams play down the blinside and be able to execute 2-3 passes at speed and beat defenders with speed of pass etc even in the 5m tramline. Something I have been noticing since about 2017-18, our super teams seem a lot more structured, or predictable.
Yeah, fair points... the game isn't helped though with the breakdown becoming even more of a clusterfuck each season because they keep changing the laws there, also refs are letting all sides stand well offside way too much.
I think the rush defence (and very skinny offside laws being applied) really is what stops teams being able to play the game where you set up a ruck in midfield etc like we used to, as players are getting caught at or behind the gainline, which negates quick ball. I also believe it is why we getting the box kick so often from halfbacks, as biggest crime is passing to someone who will get knocked over behind gainline.
Well that's what I think is causing it anyway.Didn't we start last year with refs changing to judging if the defence was 'clearly onside' rather than 'clearly offside'? That made a big difference in that defences had to halt for a split second.
As the year progressed this disappeared (possibly because it was a SH thing and we had NH refs?) and we didn't really change our attack because of the change.
Maybe it is time to make the 5 metre rule apply to rucks as well?That's right the refs were much stricter on the offside rule for a while, so we got much better quality rugby to watch, unfortunately the refs didn't apply that rule for that long... it's always up to the playmakers to adapt to any situation though.
Yeah, they should apply a 5 metre rule to rucks or at least make them stay back more - it's a refs job to consistently apply the offside rule in every game... always make me laugh when a ref has an absolute bloody howler, yet they are not very often punished for it by standing them down for a few weeks.
I guess that the problem with a 5 metre rule at rucks is that it becomes difficult to rule on in a fast fluid situation so teams will push it as much as they can and we will get just as much inconsistency depending on the ref team.
I liked the 'clearly onside' method if applied strictly. Tell teams that if the AR can't see a clear gap behind the last foot you will be pinged.
While this will give us better ball in hand rugby there is still a need to teams to be better at exploiting space behind the D.
If a 10 can put the ball into space and make the D (and forwards) have to scramble back they eventually that pays off. You may have to cede possession a couple of times but applying pressure and forcing errors can be valuable. More valuable than recycling on the gain line until you kick it away.Yeah, the 5 metre rule does become difficult to rule at ruck time, but the refs have to stop players coming in from the side of rucks, players get away with that far too much, it comes down to each ref doing their job properly.
Exactly, teams need to exploiting the ton of space behind these flat defences, no defence like to turn around & have to scramble back... yeah applying pressure & forcing errors play a huge part in winning a match.
-
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@antipodean said in All Blacks 2021:
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
Maybe it is time to make the 5 metre rule apply to rucks as well?
You'll just have people crying that they aren't five metres back. The solution is to have competent officials, not keep changing the rules.
Of course you want competent refs involved, the trouble is all the referees around the world are not refereeing properly when it comes to the offside rule, in fact bloody poorly.
Sometimes the rules need to be adjusted so the game flows better making it a better watch too, unfortunately the IRB keep adding new laws every years year, which just continues to overcomplicate the game even more.Untrue.
It is the different competitions and ref groups that seem to alter interpretations (then lose focus ) and WR will also allow law trials in different areas.
To me the biggest 'problem' is interpretation of materiality between refs. It is left to opinion and 'feel' of the game.
Quite often refs will be totally aware of rushing outsides that are offside but interpret that as it is a long way from play there is no effect. Others will ping it. Some only call close of midfield overstepping, some only call it in the attacking zone.
In fact 'attacking zone' is also a bugbear of mine. For a team that can attack and create breaks from anywhere offside play from the defence is often ignored out wide right where they would like to send the ball.
That's also where a good captain will come in.My point is the IRB tamper with the rules a lot so overcomplicate the game.
The breakdown area is open to a heap of interpretation, it's much easier for a ref to see if someone is offside or not though, they also have linemen's to assist them... never just about the captain on the field in terms of decision making, his leadership group contribute as well.
-
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@antipodean said in All Blacks 2021:
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
Maybe it is time to make the 5 metre rule apply to rucks as well?
You'll just have people crying that they aren't five metres back. The solution is to have competent officials, not keep changing the rules.
Of course you want competent refs involved, the trouble is all the referees around the world are not refereeing properly when it comes to the offside rule, in fact bloody poorly.
Sometimes the rules need to be adjusted so the game flows better making it a better watch too, unfortunately the IRB keep adding new laws every years year, which just continues to overcomplicate the game even more.Untrue.
It is the different competitions and ref groups that seem to alter interpretations (then lose focus ) and WR will also allow law trials in different areas.
To me the biggest 'problem' is interpretation of materiality between refs. It is left to opinion and 'feel' of the game.
Quite often refs will be totally aware of rushing outsides that are offside but interpret that as it is a long way from play there is no effect. Others will ping it. Some only call close of midfield overstepping, some only call it in the attacking zone.
In fact 'attacking zone' is also a bugbear of mine. For a team that can attack and create breaks from anywhere offside play from the defence is often ignored out wide right where they would like to send the ball.
That's also where a good captain will come in.My point is the IRB tamper with the rules a lot so overcomplicate the game.
The breakdown area is open to a heap of interpretation, it's much easier for a ref to see if someone is offside or not though, they also have linemen's to assist them... it's not just about the captain on the field in decision making, his leadership group contribute as well.
There are no linesmen. There are assistant refs and they are more interested in manufacturing incidents of foul play than patrolling the offside line
-
@canefan said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@antipodean said in All Blacks 2021:
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
Maybe it is time to make the 5 metre rule apply to rucks as well?
You'll just have people crying that they aren't five metres back. The solution is to have competent officials, not keep changing the rules.
Of course you want competent refs involved, the trouble is all the referees around the world are not refereeing properly when it comes to the offside rule, in fact bloody poorly.
Sometimes the rules need to be adjusted so the game flows better making it a better watch too, unfortunately the IRB keep adding new laws every years year, which just continues to overcomplicate the game even more.Untrue.
It is the different competitions and ref groups that seem to alter interpretations (then lose focus ) and WR will also allow law trials in different areas.
To me the biggest 'problem' is interpretation of materiality between refs. It is left to opinion and 'feel' of the game.
Quite often refs will be totally aware of rushing outsides that are offside but interpret that as it is a long way from play there is no effect. Others will ping it. Some only call close of midfield overstepping, some only call it in the attacking zone.
In fact 'attacking zone' is also a bugbear of mine. For a team that can attack and create breaks from anywhere offside play from the defence is often ignored out wide right where they would like to send the ball.
That's also where a good captain will come in.My point is the IRB tamper with the rules a lot so overcomplicate the game.
The breakdown area is open to a heap of interpretation, it's much easier for a ref to see if someone is offside or not though, they also have linemen's to assist them... it's not just about the captain on the field in decision making, his leadership group contribute as well.
There are no linesmen. There are assistant refs and they are more interested in manufacturing incidents of foul play than patrolling the offside line
Whatever you want to call them they still assist the ref... we know all the so called officials out on the field do a poor job.
-
ive said it before, i would love for the IRB to do the exercise of sticking some people in a room, write on the wall
- 15 players a side
- these are the dimensions of the field
- cant pass the ball forward
- we want scrums of 8 people each and line outs
...whats next?
if they went back to first principles would we end up with the same rules as we currently have or would we end up with a much more stream lined set of rules? would we find lost of the things we keep trying to "fix" by building on top of the existing rules could be handled much better by simplifying rather than complicating
-
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
this current coaching staff are clueless, so we need to select a good coaching that will then select the right players from our Super comp etc.
So just who are the players the clueless selectors missed last year. I saw only Tom Robinson and Caleb Clarke missing out, and both were taken out of the equation any way. They chose the best group available in my opinion, and had to have an extended squad to cover covid and miq complications and contingencies.
-
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@canefan said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzbloke said in All Blacks 2021:
@antipodean said in All Blacks 2021:
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
Maybe it is time to make the 5 metre rule apply to rucks as well?
You'll just have people crying that they aren't five metres back. The solution is to have competent officials, not keep changing the rules.
Of course you want competent refs involved, the trouble is all the referees around the world are not refereeing properly when it comes to the offside rule, in fact bloody poorly.
Sometimes the rules need to be adjusted so the game flows better making it a better watch too, unfortunately the IRB keep adding new laws every years year, which just continues to overcomplicate the game even more.Untrue.
It is the different competitions and ref groups that seem to alter interpretations (then lose focus ) and WR will also allow law trials in different areas.
To me the biggest 'problem' is interpretation of materiality between refs. It is left to opinion and 'feel' of the game.
Quite often refs will be totally aware of rushing outsides that are offside but interpret that as it is a long way from play there is no effect. Others will ping it. Some only call close of midfield overstepping, some only call it in the attacking zone.
In fact 'attacking zone' is also a bugbear of mine. For a team that can attack and create breaks from anywhere offside play from the defence is often ignored out wide right where they would like to send the ball.
That's also where a good captain will come in.My point is the IRB tamper with the rules a lot so overcomplicate the game.
The breakdown area is open to a heap of interpretation, it's much easier for a ref to see if someone is offside or not though, they also have linemen's to assist them... it's not just about the captain on the field in decision making, his leadership group contribute as well.
There are no linesmen. There are assistant refs and they are more interested in manufacturing incidents of foul play than patrolling the offside line
Whatever you want to call them they still assist the ref... we know all the so called officials out on the field do a poor job.
I disagree completely, I think in most cases the refs in rugby do a bloody good job. The spectators that watch the game in many cases are awful confused on the laws etc!
And sorry mate, I would hate the 5 metre back from a ruck etc to become law. If anyone wants attacking and defending teams kept 10m apart there is a game called league to follow.
-
@dan54 they're definitely doing a job i wouldn't want to do, thats why im mostly interesting in law without any need for interpretation or subjective decisions, make the rules as black and white as possible
-
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks 2021:
@dan54 they're definitely doing a job i wouldn't want to do, thats why im mostly interesting in law without any need for interpretation or subjective decisions, make the rules as black and white as possible
I suspect that may please some of us KW, but not a lot, I think when I have been at games etc I find in general most abuse of refs is from people who don't understand the most basic of laws, and (same as TV) can't get it through their heads that unless you are pretty well (or tv camera is)in line with a breakdown, you can't see who is offside anyway.. And many see a pile up and scream about offsides etc and don't realise a ruck hasn't even formed, etc.
