All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.
-
@Marty said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
@Rancid-Schnitzel said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
@Marty said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
@Chris-B. said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
@mariner4life said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
Thoughts on the All Blacks playing without a goal kicker?
Wondering about this.
Beaudy was pretty ordinary in the first part of the Super season. Came right in the ABs camp, but he seems to be regressing.
I wonder how long the coaches will put up with substandard goal kicking - eventually it will cost us a match, so he needs to sort it - otherwise he'll have to be relegated to super-sub status again.
General performance from Beaudy has me wondering again how effective he can be when his forwards are getting munched. I didn't see him trying to take control at any point. In fact after the game I realised I could barely remember seeing him.
They had 30 something percent possession in the first half. He barely had the ball enough to make an impression before he was hooked. When and where was he supposed to take control?
35% is not great but it's adequate. A more controlling performance from a Beauden Barrett would include, for example, taking on the line himself - something that has been his hallmark this season. Aaron Cruden had more direct influence on proceedings when he came on, though admittedly not always positive.
As mentioned, he only had the ball a handful of times in attack. It would be interesting to know at what stage him taking the ball to the line would have been a controlling performance or indeed called for under the circumstances.
Cruden came on and failed to find touch from a penalty and then sent a harmless kick into the 22. With much more possession and a tiring opponent of course he's going to be more involved.
BB totally deserves any criticism for his kicking, which could prove crucial in some of the typical arm-wrestles up north. It could even be argued that Lima S gets the nod if BB cant get at least 70%. But complaining that he didn't control the game enough when his team had 35% possession and he barely touched the ball in attack is absolutely ridiculous.
-
@da_grubster said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
Must admit, the herald clown mock up is in poor taste and not funny. Doesn't even make sense.
I can't remember seeing anything like that from them previously so seems a. It out of character.
Checks must have been pleased with it though. Gave him an excuse the attacke the ABs as opposed talking about his shortcomings.
Overall though the wobs played pretty well for majority of the game
I remember seeing the richie mcGrub thing last year and didnt like that , it reminded me of what the nrl media do around origin time, and thought nrl paper , probably influenced by that , cheap shots for a laugh, it works for them , but I thought leave it out of rugby ,
Then when i saw the clown thing on the sat arvo , I cringed , I thought we dont have to resort to this rubbish too , just preview the bloody game
-
@da_grubster said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
Must admit, the herald clown mock up is in poor taste and not funny. Doesn't even make sense.
I can't remember seeing anything like that from them previously so seems a. It out of character.
Checks must have been pleased with it though. Gave him an excuse the attacke the ABs as opposed talking about his shortcomings.
Overall though the wobs played pretty well for majority of the game
Apparently the artist is Australian. So it's probably an Australian thing to do I guess.
-
@mimic said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
@da_grubster said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
Must admit, the herald clown mock up is in poor taste and not funny. Doesn't even make sense.
I can't remember seeing anything like that from them previously so seems a. It out of character.
Checks must have been pleased with it though. Gave him an excuse the attacke the ABs as opposed talking about his shortcomings.
Overall though the wobs played pretty well for majority of the game
Apparently the artist is Australian. So it's probably an Australian thing to do I guess.
There have been so many take-overs or mergers of the media this year that I'm not even sure "our" media aren't Australian now as well.
-
@kiwiinmelb funny, I hadnt even seen it and I expect plenty others hadnt either, but now loads have...despite what Cheika says, the NZR cant control what the media print...oh wait, according to the article yesterday, they do control it...this NZR is a huge beast, what else does it control? The weather, the US Media, surely Hansen is gonna come out in favour of one of the candidates and his support will seal thier victory?
-
@mimic said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
@da_grubster said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
Must admit, the herald clown mock up is in poor taste and not funny. Doesn't even make sense.
I can't remember seeing anything like that from them previously so seems a. It out of character.
Checks must have been pleased with it though. Gave him an excuse the attacke the ABs as opposed talking about his shortcomings.
Overall though the wobs played pretty well for majority of the game
Apparently the artist is Australian. So it's probably an Australian thing to do I guess.
Even funnier, Cheika's cousin once dated the artist's sister lol
-
@da_grubster said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
Must admit, the herald clown mock up is in poor taste and not funny. Doesn't even make sense.
To me it looks like a Simpson's reference. Cheika looks like Rory B. Bellows, who is Krusty the Clown out of makeup, ergo Cheika the Clown.
-
Pity Cheika has chosen to whinge. His team selection was good: best balanced this year. They certainly had ABs under cosh, and had certain players not made stupid errors it would have been very tasty indeed. So plaudits to him and his team for coaching, but nil points for PR.
That said, best line from The Hustler was when Newman told, 'Show me a good loser and I'll show you a loser.'! -
I agree, Savea was pushed twice and the first time he was a lot closer to the runner-give that man a Speights.
-
Bloody hell the Bledisloe next year is going to be tasty...two games in Aus as well...
Wallabies looked pretty bloody good for most of that game but still came up short. Pretty pumped the All Blacks knocked off that 17 win marker and hope they kick on for a few more.
This whole disallowed try and the news paper cartoon (what a shit idea), seems to be really casting shadow over the series this year.
-
-
Christ, is Cheika for real? I've been reading the SMH and the Grauniad and all, and he's spat the dummy big time. What a petulant child. He seems to be calling the NZH a propaganda arm of the All Blacks, as though Hansen ordered a derogatory depiction to be published (and make no mistake, the clown thing is fucking awful and downright rude) and then planted the bguging story on the day of a test match. Then advising all and sundry that some grudge exists between the teams basically because one team beats the other one up all the time.
If so, this is embarrassing for him and his employers. You can't mask your team's failures by having a go at the foreign media. It smacks of paranoia.
Jeez, every team in test rugby not wearing black is only gunning for the silver medal at the moment. His boys basically put in a pretty solid performance, encouraging even, and surely Cheika might have just got a few things right tactically and selectorially last night.
But he wants to pull that shit?
-
@Crucial said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
@NTA said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
Now look for example at how Read dealt with being penalised for a bit of push and shove even though he was on the wrong end of the ref trying to stamp it out and it was the opposition instigating the majority of off the ball stuff. He just shut up, sucked it up, apologised to the team and told them what they were now going to do.
that's some pretty one-eyed stuff there crucial. read gave away a dumb, lack of discipline type penalty. painting anything out of that as positive, or as showing maturity or superior discipline is a bit too much of a stretch for me.
-
@reprobate said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
@Crucial said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
@NTA said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
Now look for example at how Read dealt with being penalised for a bit of push and shove even though he was on the wrong end of the ref trying to stamp it out and it was the opposition instigating the majority of off the ball stuff. He just shut up, sucked it up, apologised to the team and told them what they were now going to do.
that's some pretty one-eyed stuff there crucial. read gave away a dumb, lack of discipline type penalty. painting anything out of that as positive, or as showing maturity or superior discipline is a bit too much of a stretch for me.
I still haven't seen what exactly Read was meant to have done there but it was pretty stupid after the ref had warned him.
-
@Chris-B.
Barrett regressing ?
I have watched the Durban game two times and if you had done the same, you could have seen him tear the SA defence on his own on multiple occasions. He was involved and prominent in most of the tries.
I agree his kicking from the tee has regressed (maybe a question of confidence ?), but not his general play. -
@reprobate said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
@Crucial said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
@NTA said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
Now look for example at how Read dealt with being penalised for a bit of push and shove even though he was on the wrong end of the ref trying to stamp it out and it was the opposition instigating the majority of off the ball stuff. He just shut up, sucked it up, apologised to the team and told them what they were now going to do.
that's some pretty one-eyed stuff there crucial. read gave away a dumb, lack of discipline type penalty. painting anything out of that as positive, or as showing maturity or superior discipline is a bit too much of a stretch for me.
I was referring to how they handled the situation after doing something stupid. I thought there was a big contrast between how we reacted and how Straya reacted after decisions. My point was that kind of thing filters down from the coach as a behaviour
-
@Tregaskis said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
Christ, is Cheika for real? I've been reading the SMH and the Grauniad and all, and he's spat the dummy big time. What a petulant child. He seems to be calling the NZH a propaganda arm of the All Blacks, as though Hansen ordered a derogatory depiction to be published (and make no mistake, the clown thing is fucking awful and downright rude) and then planted the bguging story on the day of a test match. Then advising all and sundry that some grudge exists between the teams basically because one team beats the other one up all the time.
If so, this is embarrassing for him and his employers. You can't mask your team's failures by having a go at the foreign media. It smacks of paranoia.
Jeez, every team in test rugby not wearing black is only gunning for the silver medal at the moment. His boys basically put in a pretty solid performance, encouraging even, and surely Cheika might have just got a few things right tactically and selectorially last night.
But he wants to pull that shit?
I'm sure that if you reversed the two non-try incidents (ignore the forward pass one, even the players involved knew that was forward) you would see the same amount of moaning. Crusty would be complaining that a player was taken out in the chase and that a player was impeded in trying to get to the ball.
Shag mentioned straight away that he thought we got the rub of the green on one but not the other. -
@reprobate said in All Blacks v Wallabies at Eden Park.:
that was a try any day of the week as far as i'm concerned. just watched a replay to confirm my thoughts at the time. shit call.
It's a shit call because he ruled on the laws of the game and not on how reprobate's crystal ball deems an outcome? Righto...
