All Blacks 2022
-
@taniwharugby said in Foster:
this thread says there are loads more posts since I last logged in, but when I scan over them, it doesnt look like any new ones....
and it's taken 3k posts for you to realise this?
For all we get same ol same ol, this is still my preferred rugby forum. We may or may not agree on plenty but generally find it one of better ones I have been part of.
-
So midfield is a real concern.
We need to try Havili/Goodhue.
No No we need ALB back with Rieko
No with Goodhue
Let's try Tupaea/ALB or Tupaea/Goodhue
Nah Jordie /Goodhue is the answer
Shit this coaching lark is tougker than I thought ....
What’s George Moala up to ?
Frizell and Reece got selected so no reason he can’t as well.
Hell if you worried about Reece and Frizell you must of been spewing when Eric Rush as captaing our 7s!!!
You’ve lost me
-
As much as I am not a fan of Havili I can see the need to stick with this combo.
The one aspect I think sets Havili apart is his distribution ability. Much like Nonu, he's basically got the skills in that regard to put people into space excellently, like a very good 10. He just lacks the rest of the package unfortunately - but I really do think with experience he will certainly be able to bring that skill set to the fore (which will be very valuable), while "bolstering" his other talents to an adequate level.
It just might be a bit painful getting there...
-
-
@Machpants said in All Blacks 2022:
@Bones said in All Blacks 2022:
It just might be a bit painful getting there...
It already has!
That's what you think...
-
@Bones said in All Blacks 2022:
@Machpants said in All Blacks 2022:
@Bones said in All Blacks 2022:
It just might be a bit painful getting there...
It already has!
That's what you think...
Now I'm depressed
-
@Rancid-Schnitzel said in Foster:
@Victor-Meldrew said in Foster:
@Rancid-Schnitzel said in Foster:
I do not believe we can win the RWC with that midfield.
Well, not if it doesn't grow or get better - which is why I brought it up as an area for improvement. So what would we like to see Foster and co do to improve things?
Probably a complete pipe dream but IMHO the best combo is JB and Goodhue. I would love to see a backline of Smith, BB/RM, JB, Goodhue, Reiko, Clark, Jordan. That would be pretty. In terms of 10, I heart BB, but I heart the Allblacks more. I'd like to see both the 10s play under the "new regime" of a forward pack actually establishing go-forward before passing judgement.
In the forwards, I think we need at least 2 big munters starting in the back row. Ardie and Cane starting isn't optimal and one has to be benched. Nothing new there I guess.
Yeah the JB as a 12 can be put to bed at least for this RWC cycle. For this cycle, I think they will rotate between two combos: the current DH/RI combo and the safe and experienced ALB/JG combo as the alternative on a horses for courses basis
-
experienced ALB/JG comb
not sure there is a more overrated player on this forum than Jack Goodhue. He's played 19 tests and he's "experienced" now.
He hasn't played a test in coming up two years but should be the starting centre.
He's so big and powerful, yet is only 6'2 and 100 kegs
The wider social media universe is way worse for it, but to read some posts you would think we have prime Frank Bunce jut wasting away in the squad
-
@mariner4life said in Foster:
experienced ALB/JG comb
not sure there is a more overrated player on this forum than Jack Goodhue. He's played 19 tests and he's "experienced" now.
He hasn't played a test in coming up two years but should be the starting centre.
He's so big and powerful, yet is only 6'2 and 100 kegs
The wider social media universe is way worse for it, but to read some posts you would think we have prime Frank Bunce jut wasting away in the squad
That’s as big as a prime Umaga/Ieremia to be fair….or in the modern game Henshaw/De Allende give or take.
-
@mariner4life said in All Blacks 2022:
experienced ALB/JG comb
not sure there is a more overrated player on this forum than Jack Goodhue. He's played 19 tests and he's "experienced" now.
He hasn't played a test in coming up two years but should be the starting centre.
He's so big and powerful, yet is only 6'2 and 100 kegs
The wider social media universe is way worse for it, but to read some posts you would think we have prime Frank Bunce jut wasting away in the squad
This is the best endorsement of Goodhue you can get.
-
@mariner4life said in All Blacks 2022:
experienced ALB/JG comb
not sure there is a more overrated player on this forum than Jack Goodhue. He's played 19 tests and he's "experienced" now.
He hasn't played a test in coming up two years but should be the starting centre.
He's so big and powerful, yet is only 6'2 and 100 kegs
The wider social media universe is way worse for it, but to read some posts you would think we have prime Frank Bunce jut wasting away in the squad
THANK YOU!
Thought i was going mad, i'll also add those 19 test have been over 6 years...thats how injury prone he is
look at someone like ben smith, forgetting his first test, he didn't break into the AB properly until 2012 and last played in 2019....so in those 7 years he played 83 tests
yes, when he's fit he's in the conversation but surely we need to stop hanging our hopes on something so unpredictable and jack goodhue being able to string several games together for the AB's
-
@mariner4life dunno if I'd say over rated, more unfulfilled, due to his injuries and lack of game time.
Pre-Irish tour his name kept popping up due to his 'experience' but <20 tests is not massively experienced, sure he is a smarter, but limited player and probably plays more like a veteran, but doesnt detract form the fact he isnt.
-
@Kiwiwomble said in All Blacks 2022:
@mariner4life said in All Blacks 2022:
experienced ALB/JG comb
not sure there is a more overrated player on this forum than Jack Goodhue. He's played 19 tests and he's "experienced" now.
He hasn't played a test in coming up two years but should be the starting centre.
He's so big and powerful, yet is only 6'2 and 100 kegs
The wider social media universe is way worse for it, but to read some posts you would think we have prime Frank Bunce jut wasting away in the squad
THANK YOU!
Thought i was going mad, i'll also add those 19 test have been over 6 years...thats how injury prone he is
look at someone like ben smith, forgetting his first test, he didn't break into the AB properly until 2012 and last played in 2019....so in those 7 years he played 83 tests
yes, when he's fit he's in the conversation but surely we need to stop hanging our hopes on something so unpredictable and jack goodhue being able to string several games together for the AB's
I don't think anyone has referred to him as the second coming but when looking at 13s over the past few years he's, IMHO, easily been the best. But ultimately I agree that there's a good chance he won't even be an option going forward. But a man can dream. All I know is that he's miles better than Rieko, who is one of the world's best wingers but but a farking average 13.
-
@mariner4life tribalism
-
@MN5 said in All Blacks 2022:
So midfield is a real concern.
We need to try Havili/Goodhue.
No No we need ALB back with Rieko
No with Goodhue
Let's try Tupaea/ALB or Tupaea/Goodhue
Nah Jordie /Goodhue is the answer
Shit this coaching lark is tougker than I thought ....
What’s George Moala up to ?
Frizell and Reece got selected so no reason he can’t as well.
Hell if you worried about Reece and Frizell you must of been spewing when Eric Rush as captaing our 7s!!!
You’ve lost me
Ok if you don't know, I will leave it, like all things in past and I know he also regrets it anyway.
-
-
@dogmeat said in All Blacks 2022:
@mariner4life tribalism
Not really. I'm a Canes supporter who hasn't been in the South Island since the age of 5. Unlike some people here I don't give a fůck what Super team someone plays for. Ultimately it's about the Allblacks. And on that front all I can say is that even with his apparent lack of experience and enormous size, Goodhue is a better option at 13 than Rieko.
-
@Rancid-Schnitzel said in All Blacks 2022:
@dogmeat said in All Blacks 2022:
@mariner4life tribalism
Not really. I'm a Canes supporter who hasn't been in the South Island since the age of 5. Unlike some people here I don't give a fůck what Super team someone plays for. Ultimately it's about the Allblacks. And on that front all I can say is that even with his apparent lack of experience and enormous size, Goodhue is a better option at 13 than Rieko.
When he is fit, which isn't often these past few years, he's looked very, very slow at 13. And that's at Super Rugby level. That Bok centre would make him his bitch at Test level.
Pretty much only in the picture as a 12 now.
-
