It’s Razor. Robertson New All Blacks coach.
-
@Chris-B said in It’s Razor. Robertson New All Blacks coach.:
@Bones said in It’s Razor. Robertson New All Blacks coach.:
@Victor-Meldrew said in It’s Razor. Robertson New All Blacks coach.:
The issue is expectation. Robertson has been so hyped-up on social media (and on here) that anything less than outstanding success pretty quickly is going to attract criticism.
Free pass if there's injuries though, as no other team has those.
You think the Crusaders haven't had injuries in the past five years?
Quite the opposite, that's my point. Super coach has only underperformed this year due to injury. Would've taken out every team otherwise.
Poor guy.
-
Razor should not be immune to criticism, his assistant choices could've been better, well hey at least Smith's returning (in a significantly reduced capacity) even if it's a nominal role more than anything, I suspect he won't even be present in All Blacks camp, sounds as if he's just continuing his retirement as usual & is going to answer Razor's phone calls on the odd occasion, lol, such a pointless nothing role, Scott Johnson's previous position at Rugby Australia comes to mind..
-
@Victor-Meldrew
Disagree, majority on here are realists. Not going to be easy to replace Whitelock, Retallick, Smith, Mounga.
Us die hards just want logical planning and selection on a steady upward curve. No more scatter plots! -
@BerniesCorner said in It’s Razor. Robertson New All Blacks coach.:
Disagree, majority on here are realists. Not going to be easy to replace Whitelock, Retallick, Smith, Mounga.
-
Where is the Razor criticism?
There’s some concern around the performance of his assistants but I haven’t seen anyone dissing him.
I have always said he is extremely good at navigating a campaign.
My only question is whether that will translate to a “win every game” international environment -
@Crucial that's fair, I do have reservations about his assistants, Ryan & Hansen are talented coaches & very highly regarded, the other two I remain uneasy about. The other issue I have is Hansen should be leading the attack strategy/GP as he's doing currently for Crusaders, int. level defense coach ought to be specialist in the area.
-
This post is deleted!
-
@Crucial said in It’s Razor. Robertson New All Blacks coach.:
I have to wonder about Razors assistant selections with some of the evidence we are seeing in Super
Holland and his terrible sub calls and Rangi with his kicking tactics
Early touch from Perofeta in his own half and he puts the same short cross field bomb low percentage kick that we have seen BB doing. Obviously a coached thing and if it’s not directly coming from Rangi then he should be stopping it.
The subbing of Roigard at 60 for Booth continues. Roigards importance to the Canes at the moment is equal to Ardie. He’s not flagging fitness wise so keep him on.When Henry was appointed in 2004 he brought Smith and Hansen - two of his equals as head coaches with him, in addition to Byrne and Cron.
Would anyone consider MacDonald and Holland anywhere as respected & successful as Smith and Hansen?
No, they have not won anything of note, Ta$man were patchy & inconsistent during his tenure and significantly improved after he left, they were better under Kieran Keane IMO and clearly under Goodman/Dermody.
-
Wasn't thinking of the '15 ABs, but immediate pre-Foster. We were putting 50+ points on the Boks in '17.
I doubt he'll be given any more time than Foster - he should be though and NZR need to clear in their support. The issue is the given truth and expectation that Robertson is absolutely, definitely certain to restore the ABs to their rightful place and will build back from the clear disaster that everyone knows is Foster.
Changes and shifts in world rugby, injuries and quality of players won't have any impact apparently..
-
I disagree, he will be given time. Foster was never the right choice, he should never have been chosen - he was not a choice of anyone apart from an inward-looking idiotic NZR. Foster had no credit to fall back on, as an assistant, maybe, but he has never been successful when in charge. So he had no credit to trade for time. Razor has credit as a successful head coach AND the fact most people know you can't go from worst to best in a season. Foster was part of the previous 'hung on too long' unsuccessful regime, Razor will be given some time to succeed. Foster had already spent that as successor in chief when he took the public front seat in 2018-19
-
@Victor-Meldrew said in It’s Razor. Robertson New All Blacks coach.:
Robertson is absolutely, definitely certain to restore the ABs to their rightful place
Yeah, what is the ABs' rightful place in this day and age (also considering the players available)? There will be some very unrealistic expectations that the ABs will be back at the top in no time, without questioning whether that's where they really belong in 2024.
@Machpants said in It’s Razor. Robertson New All Blacks coach.:
I disagree, he will be given time.
That will depend on who you ask.
-
@Stargazer said in It’s Razor. Robertson New All Blacks coach.:
@Victor-Meldrew said in It’s Razor. Robertson New All Blacks coach.:
@Machpants said in It’s Razor. Robertson New All Blacks coach.:
I disagree, he will be given time.
That will depend on who you ask.
I mean the general media and the majority of supporters that have a brain
-
@Crucial said in It’s Razor. Robertson New All Blacks coach.:
Where is the Razor criticism?
Not being funny, but why should there be any criticism?
He hasn't had one of his AB teams run onto a field yet and we won't know if his choice of Assistants was a good/bad one until after a few games.
-
@Machpants said in It’s Razor. Robertson New All Blacks coach.:
@Stargazer said in It’s Razor. Robertson New All Blacks coach.:
@Victor-Meldrew said in It’s Razor. Robertson New All Blacks coach.:
@Machpants said in It’s Razor. Robertson New All Blacks coach.:
I disagree, he will be given time.
That will depend on who you ask.
I mean the general media and the majority of supporters that have a brain
If Robertson loses the Eden Park record, the Bledisloe or to Scotland (quite probable as other nations improve ), it wouldn't be long before even the general media and the majority of supporters that have a brain start criticizing and comparing unfavourably to Foster.
-
Probably right, but it is not going to happen
EDIT except for Eden Park record, that is nothing, it's going to go at some point. Fuck, even the Bled we've lost it before. But he will not lose to Scotland. That sort of 'never to get back' record loss is a Foster speciality
-
@kiwi_expat said in It’s Razor. Robertson New All Blacks coach.:
No, they have not won anything of note, Ta$man were patchy & inconsistent during his tenure and significantly improved after he left, they were better under Kieran Keane IMO and clearly under Goodman/Dermody.
That's not really true.
Under Keane Ta$man finished 9th, 13th, 14th, 10th, 8th, 2nd, 3rd.
Under Leon 2nd, 2nd, 3rd - losing to Canterbury each time.
Got gypped in his last season when Hansen gave Canterbury Joe Moody for the semi-final to nullify our scrum advantage.
Ta$man was on an upward trajectory with Keane and Leon, continued under Leon - Goodman and Dermody finished it off, but all the key pieces were already in place.
-
-
-
