Future Locks after RWC???
-
@Crucial said in Future Locks after RWC???:
@nzzp said in Future Locks after RWC???:
@mariner4life said in Future Locks after RWC???:
@broughie said in Future Locks after RWC???:
@Victor-Meldrew But he created the position he is in by his ineptitude as a coach. I am not sure why your continue to stick up for this guy just because he is what we have. Yes concerned about winning with this aged group because Foster was concerned more about his job. His focus should have been on blooding the next batch of players. He is in this situation of his own making.
lol this is a laughable take
his job is to win test matches. that's it. pick the best team and win
If Vaai had been coming off the bench and providing impact then i could entertain the suggestion he gets a start. But the fact is he comes off the bench and adds fuck all. Why would any coach then pick him?
Why would any coach pick him? Because they are trying to build depth in the squad to cover for injuries. You invest in players, easing them in. Same way that we get bolters to play T20 - to see how they go, expose them to the big time, and down the line prepare them for high pressure matches.
WE just don't hvae the 'easy' games as much any more to blood players, or the strength of team to allow weaker players game time.
Crikey. The shit that was being heaped upon the coaches for not winning and now you want to revisit that and say they should have been developing players over and above selecting the best option to win?
That's bizzarre.Not developing players in some areas has been a shit side effect of the losses and trying to create a stable selection platform to build off, I agree, but those were the cards we dealt ourselves
I was responding to the question about why any coach would pick a player specifically.
Foster's backed himself into a corner, where we've had the worst of both worlds. Playing a consistent team (builds combos), but still losing and not building depth as a result of the combo choices. I don't think he should necessarily have been playing second stringers - but we are running our first XV players into the ground and it's a high risk strategy.
We had an issue in 2019 by not landing on a 6 or midfield going into the RWC. We wound up with Savea at 6 in big games, as a 'suprise' type RWC choice, largely because we didn't have much of a choice at that point. There's a tension, and it's damn tough to do. Shows how spoiled we've been
-
@mariner4life said in Future Locks after RWC???:
@broughie said in Future Locks after RWC???:
@Victor-Meldrew But he created the position he is in by his ineptitude as a coach. I am not sure why your continue to stick up for this guy just because he is what we have. Yes concerned about winning with this aged group because Foster was concerned more about his job. His focus should have been on blooding the next batch of players. He is in this situation of his own making.
lol this is a laughable take
his job is to win test matches. that's it. pick the best team and win
If Vaai had been coming off the bench and providing impact then i could entertain the suggestion he gets a start. But the fact is he comes off the bench and adds fuck all. Why would any coach then pick him?
Well first of all he hasn’t been winning test matches. He’s lost more than won recently right or are we all good based on 2 wins in a row.? Fuckin excellent AB record from this chap.
And not trying to develop depth is laughable as well especially when some of our blokes will be using walkers soon. What’s the purpose of Vaai being there if your not going to use him? If he’s not good enough find someone else.
Have our locks been stand outs this year on a consistent basis? As consistent as our forward pack for years now. I think we both agree our pack has been on the decline for a while now starting with Hanson and continuing with Foster.
-
-
-
-
PPP getting no love in the thread but I think pre injury he was starting to play to match his size.
Also, on Vai'i, he's been fairly good in most of his matches for the ABs. He's just behind the two greats and Scooter in the pecking order.
I also can't see Dickson leap frogging Lord in the coaches rankings. They clearly rate him highly.
-
@Crazy-Horse said in Future Locks after RWC???:
@Bones said in Future Locks after RWC???:
@Crazy-Horse said in Future Locks after RWC???:
@Bovidae said in Future Locks after RWC???:
Josh Dickson would only be 28 in 2023.
I thought he was older than that. Seems like he has been around for ages.
Geez really? I only remember him for like 3 or 4 seasons.
edit: so yeah 5 years at the highlanders. Another Aussie though.
I wouldn't be surprised if my muddled brain has him confused with someone else from years ago. All the Highlander locks look the same to me.
i swear ive had this very discussion with someone on here recently and realised the landers have had a progression of samey "there or there abouts" locks
guys like donnelly, and tom franklin
@Bones said in Future Locks after RWC???:
@Crazy-Horse said in Future Locks after RWC???:
@Bovidae said in Future Locks after RWC???:
Josh Dickson would only be 28 in 2023.
I thought he was older than that. Seems like he has been around for ages.
Geez really? I only remember him for like 3 or 4 seasons.
edit: so yeah 5 years at the highlanders. Another Aussie though.
raised in NZ and went to Otago boys thought
-
@Nepia said in Future Locks after RWC???:
PPP getting no love in the thread but I think pre injury he was starting to play to match his size.
Also, on Vai'i, he's been fairly good in most of his matches for the ABs. He's just behind the two greats and Scooter in the pecking order.
I also can't see Dickson leap frogging Lord in the coaches rankings. They clearly rate him highly.
im a huge PPP fan, i think he often plays much better than he's often given credit for....but god it worries me how often we rely on the idea of guys coming back from injury...and not richie coming back after proving himself over several years...guys that have a few great games and a whole lot of "potential"
-
@Kiwiwomble How far is he from a return from injury?
-
@SBW1 https://www.rugbypass.com/news/all-blacks-prospect-pari-pari-parkinson-ruled-out-for-12-months/
12 month injury back in Nov 21
but strangely for this discussion i just saw this
they list PPP as incoming from france.....it is only the roar though
-
@Canes4life said in Future Locks after RWC???:
@KiwiMurph said in Future Locks after RWC???:
@Canes4life said in Future Locks after RWC???:
Justin Sangster from Bay of Plenty, Isaia Walker-Leawere from the Hawkes Bay
Wouldn't play for the Canes would they?
Of course, both have had great seasons provincially aswell as for the Canes. Walker-Leawere in particular brings plenty of size and mobility which is needed at international level.
They both have got to be starters for the Canes first. Unsure if this will happen.
-
Canes have 9 loose forwards. Too many. And Lakai must be included somehow. Just poor planning if they haven't room for him
-
@Kiwiwomble LOL, there are/were so many NZ players off-contract and there have been so few announcements, that I think the Roar is just writing down this year's squads, plus and minus players who have signed or announced they are leaving. All the uncertain players seem to have been named as being in the squad, which simply isn't what is known just yet.
-
@Kiwiwomble said in Future Locks after RWC???:
@Winger what? who?
Lakai. Future Canes lock. Might be too tall though
-
@Winger ...and why was that addressed to me? apologies if im missing the obvious here
@Stargazer maybe he had a holiday in europe and theyre just counting that
-
@Kiwiwomble How likely are we to see any players coming from overseas or returning Kiwis. Would be awesome to see Will Heinz at halfback for the Crusaders, he has been awesome for Canterbury.
