All Blacks 2021
-
@antipodean said in All Blacks 2021:
@dan54 '"He was quite a step above both Mitch [Mitchell] and Gatty [Gatland] at that particular time, from my experiences.'
That's hardly a glowing endorsement.
The contracting issue is a fair point, but none of which addresses the fact we're playing yesterday's gameplan.
Mate read my post, it's Plumtree's opinion only, though I suspect he has more experience than you and I.
I see you have conveniently missed the fact he has said the best he has worked with, and that includes Schmidt and Joseph I believe, but you have cherry picked Gatland and Mitchell to prove a point? Neither who I am a particular fan of, but both have pretty good resumes'
-
@dan54 said in All Blacks 2021:
@antipodean said in All Blacks 2021:
@dan54 '"He was quite a step above both Mitch [Mitchell] and Gatty [Gatland] at that particular time, from my experiences.'
That's hardly a glowing endorsement.
The contracting issue is a fair point, but none of which addresses the fact we're playing yesterday's gameplan.
Mate read my post, it's Plumtree's opinion only, though I suspect he has more experience than you and I.
I see you have conveniently missed the fact he has said the best he has worked with, and that includes Schmidt and Joseph I believe, but you have cherry picked Gatland and Mitchell to prove a point? Neither who I am a particular fan of, but both have pretty good resumes'
My quote of Duane Monkley comes from the stuff article. And neither Mitch nor Gats strike me as tactically gifted.
Plumtree's quote is about culture.
Perhaps read your own post.
-
Sometimes I wonder whether Dan54 and Victor Meldrew are some of Ian's relations, as I haven't come across such unwaveringly dedicated and loyal apologists of Fozzie on this forum, nor anywhere else (obviously, with the exception of old mate Shag Hansen..) In many ways, I can't help but admire their persistence and ability to not allow external viewpoints to influence their positions.
-
@kiwi_expat said in All Blacks 2021:
unwaveringly dedicated and loyal apologists
Just because people disagree with lazy Fozzie bashing, doesn't make them apologists.
-
@bones said in All Blacks 2021:
@kiwi_expat said in All Blacks 2021:
unwaveringly dedicated and loyal apologists
Just because people disagree with lazy Fozzie bashing, doesn't make them apologists.
It’s Fun sometimes Fozzie bashing.
-
@chris said in All Blacks 2021:
@bones said in All Blacks 2021:
@kiwi_expat said in All Blacks 2021:
unwaveringly dedicated and loyal apologists
Just because people disagree with lazy Fozzie bashing, doesn't make them apologists.
It’s Fun sometimes Fozzie bashing.
What are you, Razor's mum?
-
@bones said in All Blacks 2021:
@chris said in All Blacks 2021:
@bones said in All Blacks 2021:
@kiwi_expat said in All Blacks 2021:
unwaveringly dedicated and loyal apologists
Just because people disagree with lazy Fozzie bashing, doesn't make them apologists.
It’s Fun sometimes Fozzie bashing.
What are you, Razor's mum?
No she likes Fozzie,he eats all her treats she makes.
-
@kiwi_expat said in All Blacks 2021:
Sometimes I wonder whether Dan54 and Victor Meldrew are some of Ian's relations, as I haven't come across such unwaveringly dedicated and loyal apologists of Fozzie on this forum
So anyone who disagrees with your argument that each and all of the AB's problems since 2016 are down to one man, and one man only, is an apologist for that bloke?
Sound logic.
-
@l_n_p said in All Blacks 2021:
Henry, Hansen, Smith, Eddie Jones all went through that. Schmidt too now. Failing is part of learning.
I'd love to see Scott Robertson as AB coach downstream but see prior international experience as hugely useful.
Ian Foster never coached overseas and he has walked into the All Black head coaching job. Why on earth would the far more successful Robertson need to coach overseas when Foster didn't? The sooner we discard this incredibly simplistic, black and white thinking the better... It's more about innovation and application.
If makes absolutely no sense to punish our elite players if they go overseas, by ruling them ineligible for the AB's, whilst simultaneously demanding that our elite coaches head overseas. Why give away our most precious intellectual capital for free? Once a coach leaves our shores they may never return. The argument that a quality coach needs a few mediocre years in charge of another test nation is stupid and dated, and was really only ever a 'thing' to ensure Graham Henry and Steve Hansen's tenures went unchallenged.
I don't believe that one needs to head offshore to learn more necessarily. Robertson strikes me as innovative and open to new approaches - someone who is constantly looking for ways to learn and improve. Look at examples like the Crusaders working with one of the NH teams to do a mock analysis of how they would approach playing each other to get insights they would otherwise miss, or him bringing O'Gara into the mix.
Getting out of the comfort zone can be equally achieved by how you approach things and valuing diversity in a coaching group as much as heading off-shore. A black and white approach is much too arbitrary I think...
-
@kiwi_expat said in All Blacks 2021:
Why give away our most precious intellectual capital for free? Once a coach leaves our shores they may never return.
I agree that giving away our precious IP is a key factor that NZ Rugby needs to look at and poss. do something about. Not too sure, though, how that fits with your argument that every single AB problem is solely down to Foster.
I don't believe that one needs to head offshore to learn more necessarily. Robertson strikes me as innovative and open to new approaches - someone who is constantly looking for ways to learn and improve. Look at examples like the Crusaders working with one of the NH teams to do a mock analysis of how they would approach playing each other to get insights they would otherwise miss, or him bringing O'Gara into the mix.
So your argument now is that giving away our precious IP is OK as long as it's done by Robertson and he hasn't left the country?
-
@asterik6 said in All Blacks 2021:
@kiwi_expat A friend of mine is an ex-Chiefs player and says he was f-ing useless. Basically the same stuff Devine is saying.
His coaching style hasn't changed from the 2004 Chiefs gameplan. Headless Chook Rugby 101.
Scant evidence to suggest Foster has improved or updated his coaching methods in 16/17 years..
-
@kiwi_expat said in All Blacks 2021:
Ian Foster never coached overseas and he has walked into the All Black head coaching job.
Bloody good point mate.
Shit, just another good reason for me to hate Foster. -
@kiwi_expat said in All Blacks 2021:
His coaching style hasn't changed from the 2004 Chiefs gameplan. Headless Chook Rugby 101.
One of the big criticisms of the AB's is their gameplan hasn't changed much since around 2014 and Foster has simply followed Hansen's gameplan since taking over - which is a very fair criticism and one I agree with.
But as you state that Foster's gameplan hasn't changed since 2004 and he's continued with it as AB Coach, aren't you effectively arguing that Foster's game plan was years ahead of it's time, was copied by Henry and Hansen & won us RWC2011 & RWC2015....?
-
@kiwi_expat said in All Blacks 2021:
Sometimes I wonder whether Dan54 and Victor Meldrew are some of Ian's relations, as I haven't come across such unwaveringly dedicated and loyal apologists of Fozzie on this forum, nor anywhere else (obviously, with the exception of old mate Shag Hansen..) In many ways, I can't help but admire their persistence and ability to not allow external viewpoints to influence their positions.
Wayne Smith quite rated Foster. Thought he'd really developed from his Chiefs days, too.
Foster is part of the problem, but he isn't the only problem. Our key issues are
-
Super is no longer a superior comp to NH comps. This is major - the dilution, shagging around with system, and drop in quality means that when NH picked up their game they went past us. I'd argue that Super quality directly correlates to international success (with a bit of a lag).
-
Governance/leadership
never thought I'd miss Steve Tew, but damn I miss Tew. The insanity of directly approaching Aussie Super, the appointment process for Foster that excluded credible candidates (due to timing and the perception of a closed shop), the early reappointment of Foster - it all points to poor governance. -
Foster
I was prepared to give him the benefit of the doubt. Hansen and Smith rated him and had him in the inner circle. However, the fear was that we'd see from the ABs what we saw from the Chiefs - poor/muddled selections, opaque game plans, regression in cohesion and skillsets, and a lack of forward dominance. It's played out that way - hence why so many folk are willing to put the boot in.
In fairness @kiwi_expat, Scott Robertson is not necessarily the answer either. He's had really good success, but in a limited environment. Coaching International is very differnet to coaching Super. I think he'd do a good job - but like players, it's not a lock that success transfers up a level.
-
-
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2021:
@kiwi_expat said in All Blacks 2021:
Sometimes I wonder whether Dan54 and Victor Meldrew are some of Ian's relations, as I haven't come across such unwaveringly dedicated and loyal apologists of Fozzie on this forum, nor anywhere else (obviously, with the exception of old mate Shag Hansen..) In many ways, I can't help but admire their persistence and ability to not allow external viewpoints to influence their positions.
Wayne Smith quite rated Foster. Thought he'd really developed from his Chiefs days, too.
Foster is part of the problem, but he isn't the only problem. Our key issues are
-
Super is no longer a superior comp to NH comps. This is major - the dilution, shagging around with system, and drop in quality means that when NH picked up their game they went past us. I'd argue that Super quality directly correlates to international success (with a bit of a lag).
-
Governance/leadership
never thought I'd miss Steve Tew, but damn I miss Tew. The insanity of directly approaching Aussie Super, the appointment process for Foster that excluded credible candidates (due to timing and the perception of a closed shop), the early reappointment of Foster - it all points to poor governance. -
Foster
I was prepared to give him the benefit of the doubt. Hansen and Smith rated him and had him in the inner circle. However, the fear was that we'd see from the ABs what we saw from the Chiefs - poor/muddled selections, opaque game plans, regression in cohesion and skillsets, and a lack of forward dominance. It's played out that way - hence why so many folk are willing to put the boot in.
In fairness @kiwi_expat, Scott Robertson is not necessarily the answer either. He's had really good success, but in a limited environment. Coaching International is very differnet to coaching Super. I think he'd do a good job - but like players, it's not a lock that success transfers up a level.
Pretty much agree with all of that.
I'd add there seems a culture issue around the team as which needs looking at as well - it seems part mental skills, part trusting your teammates and part dealing with pressure. We've lost the ability since 2015/6 to think and act at key points in a game and that has little to d with game-plan, tactics or forward dominance
-
-
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2021:
I'd add there seems a culture issue around the team as which needs looking at as well - it seems part mental skills, part trusting your teammates and part dealing with pressure. We've lost the ability since 2015/6 to think and act at key points in a game and that has little to d with game-plan, tactics or forward dominance
almost like losing generational players at the same time had a long lasting effect. McCaw, Carter, Nonu, Mealamu, Smith, Woodcock,
-
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2021:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2021:
I'd add there seems a culture issue around the team as which needs looking at as well - it seems part mental skills, part trusting your teammates and part dealing with pressure. We've lost the ability since 2015/6 to think and act at key points in a game and that has little to d with game-plan, tactics or forward dominance
almost like losing generational players at the same time had a long lasting effect. McCaw, Carter, Nonu, Mealamu, Smith, Woodcock,
Or the cultural/Enoka thinking stuff, which GH was a big fan of, being seen as less important. It takes a fair while to build that up once it's decayed.
-
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2021:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2021:
I'd add there seems a culture issue around the team as which needs looking at as well - it seems part mental skills, part trusting your teammates and part dealing with pressure. We've lost the ability since 2015/6 to think and act at key points in a game and that has little to d with game-plan, tactics or forward dominance
almost like losing generational players at the same time had a long lasting effect. McCaw, Carter, Nonu, Mealamu, Smith, Woodcock,
Or the cultural/Enoka thinking stuff, which GH was a big fan of, being seen as less important. It takes a fair while to build that up once it's decayed.
I think some of that is embedded as normal now but interesting to hear comments from Moana Pasifika players that they think they still aren't being coached to their best potential in the existing systems
-
@crucial said in All Blacks 2021:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2021:
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2021:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2021:
I'd add there seems a culture issue around the team as which needs looking at as well - it seems part mental skills, part trusting your teammates and part dealing with pressure. We've lost the ability since 2015/6 to think and act at key points in a game and that has little to d with game-plan, tactics or forward dominance
almost like losing generational players at the same time had a long lasting effect. McCaw, Carter, Nonu, Mealamu, Smith, Woodcock,
Or the cultural/Enoka thinking stuff, which GH was a big fan of, being seen as less important. It takes a fair while to build that up once it's decayed.
I think some of that is embedded as normal now but interesting to hear comments from Moana Pasifika players that they think they still aren't being coached to their best potential in the existing systems
I was thinking more on how the players react to pressure on the field and support and interact with other as well as the values they actually exhibit (and not just profess). rather than the coaching - though there's obviously a big connection
Mrs M knows a bit about this sort of stuff and thought some of the on-field body language when things weren't going well didn't look too healthy when she watched the last RWC with me.
IIRC there was a big player-led pow-wow about 15 years ago on this which was a watershed. Time for another?
