Possible All Blacks 2020
-
@Chris-B said in Possible All Blacks 2020:
At the end of the day, Hansen put our fate in the hands of a bunch of young backs.
... after preaching for 4 years the need for experience!
And actually, depowered the forward pack to get some height, but then didn't attack the England lineout. So. Frustrating.
-
@Chris-B said in Possible All Blacks 2020:
@mariner4life said in Possible All Blacks 2020:
@Chris-B said in Possible All Blacks 2020:
@mariner4life I'm not blaming them - but, I reckon if we'd had a more general level of calm then maybe that push doesn't happen.
nup, I'm not having that. SW is supposed to bring the calm. He's an experienced player who is also a captain. It's his job to rise above the storm and provide stability for the others to feed off, not the other way around.
I'll give you that, with hindsight, there was a distinct lack of leadership across the park. And that definitely had an effect. But i will not go so far as to forgive a leader for a boneheaded play.
Oh, I'm not forgiving Sam for that - but, I'm saying it might not have happened if we'd had more experienced heads on the field.
In 2011, for instance, McCaw noted somewhere that he started to lose his cool "blue" head and had to be reminded by someone to get back in that mindset. Our performance looked increasingly panicked and towards the end I looked at the players we had on the field and just thought, nup - these aren't the guys who are going to bring this home.
Actually, I've already forgiven Sam - but, based on that 2015 lineout steal, we owed him one!
Kieran Read always got a wild look in his eyes and started flapping his arms around when things weren't working. Great player, but won't go down as a great captain.
-
@Duluth said in Possible All Blacks 2020:
@No-Quarter said in Possible All Blacks 2020:
Bridge is not a player that can open up a tight test, he's really just a safe pair of hands.
An All Black winger should be able to beat players with footwork. He's a good player with plenty of speed who looks good on the end of a chain. I'm not convinced he has the skillset for tight spaces that other wingers have.
He is also really hesitant when it comes to backing himself on the outside. He cuts back in way too often.If his kicking game is good enough I think he would be a very good fullback. Unfortunately won't get the opportunity to play there at the Crusaders
Are you still talking about Bridge or have you switched to Caleb Ralph? 😉
-
@sparky if Cullen Grace can repeat his game from the weekend numerous times I think he is a good option in back row at 6. Jumper plus tough. Possibly a year to early though
-
@98blueandgold said in Possible All Blacks 2020:
@sparky if Cullen Grace can repeat his game from the weekend numerous times I think he is a good option in back row at 6. Jumper plus tough. Possibly a year to early though
i thought i read he is "only" 190cm? That's probably a touch short
although a good jumper can play "taller"
-
1.93 on the Crusaders site.. the other number is probably a stat from the u20's?
There are still sites that claim Papali'i is 95kg
-
@mariner4life Geez, then Luke Jacobson (191cm) better stay at home, too.
-
@Stargazer said in Possible All Blacks 2020:
@mariner4life Geez, then Luke Jacobson (191cm) better stay at home, too.
yes, at 6, he should. Especially dependent on who is at 8. If our tallest loose forward is 191 that's not good enough
I'm not sold on any of them, so don't try and divide it by team lines
-
@mariner4life I'm not interested in team lines or Grace (too young). It was a comment on his height (193cm).
I'd like to see Jacobson at 6 (possibly covering 8).
It's all about the combos. Who are the locks and how tall are they. Who are the other loosies and what's their height.
-
@Stargazer said in Possible All Blacks 2020:
@mariner4life I'm not interested in team lines or Grace (too young). It was a comment on his height (193cm).
I'd like to see Jacobson at 6 (possibly covering 8).
It's all about the combos. Who are the locks and how tall are they. Who are the other loosies and what's their height.
i agree. My thoughts are is, if 2 of our starting loosies are Cane and Savea (npt something i agree with) then 193 is too short
-
@mariner4life Shannon Frizell will be happy to read that.
-
@Stargazer said in Possible All Blacks 2020:
@mariner4life Shannon Frizell will be happy to read that.
the man, the myth.
how exactly does a go from teh bench to the squad? he never plays!
-
@mariner4life said in Possible All Blacks 2020:
@Chris-B said in Possible All Blacks 2020:
@mariner4life I'm not blaming them - but, I reckon if we'd had a more general level of calm then maybe that push doesn't happen.
nup, I'm not having that. SW is supposed to bring the calm. He's an experienced player who is also a captain. It's his job to rise above the storm and provide stability for the others to feed off, not the other way around.
I'll give you that, with hindsight, there was a distinct lack of leadership across the park. And that definitely had an effect. But i will not go so far as to forgive a leader for a boneheaded play.
This. That was completely unforgivable and that single act alone should rule him out of any captaincy discussions.
-
@Crucial having interviewed Jerome Kaino ,and Victor Vito was standing beside him ,there is no way in gods earth he is 1.96..is that the old 6’4 measurement..?, Vito is 6’2, Jerome is about an inch taller, I have picture of them standing together and there is hardly any difference ..
Much of the stats are very suspect, I have heard commentators , Ken Laban for example is shocking ..they add height and weight on to players , it does my head in ,Solomon Alaimalo is supposed to be 6’5, Solomon is 6’3, spoken to him many times and even joked about his height...
Julian Savea was another one who is 6’2 but I have commentators saying is the same height as a Jonah..
Israel Folau is listed at 6’3 on Wikipedia..,he is actually 6’5, and their is no way even Jerome or Solomon are taller than Israel.. -
I'm 187 and i wasn't tall in country football. i find it hard to believe these guys are a couple of cm taller then me.
-
I'd like to see a return to the JABS - would be a handy gauge on guys like Big Red, Sotutu, Miaele-Tu, Parkinson, Grace, Fakatava (if he ever takes the field) and ye - even Akira.
-
@mariner4life said in Possible All Blacks 2020:
@Stargazer said in Possible All Blacks 2020:
@mariner4life I'm not interested in team lines or Grace (too young). It was a comment on his height (193cm).
I'd like to see Jacobson at 6 (possibly covering 8).
It's all about the combos. Who are the locks and how tall are they. Who are the other loosies and what's their height.
i agree. My thoughts are is, if 2 of our starting loosies are Cane and Savea (npt something i agree with) then 193 is too short
Get on the #Mako boat, my man. All problems solved by winners!
