SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs
-
-
@Frank said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
@Chris said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
A few players would have either played their way out of the ABs yesterday ,or at the very least now have big question marks next to their names..
Brayden Lose for one.
Others?
Cameron was another who was promoted as an AB option. He showed (again) he's not even close. At best he a backup super rugby 1st
TJ might be another as a starting option. He was just not good enough. Even his defense badly let him down at times.
On the plus side
Numia was missed. PRS is not even close. The gap surprised me
Proctor was quality as was Aumua
Love did enough. Just
Barrett was poorish in the first half but really stepped up in the 2nd
Lakai was good again.Also, Flanders was a big improvement over Shields, And much better also then Iose,
-
@Frank said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
@Chris said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
A few players would have either played their way out of the ABs yesterday ,or at the very least now have big question marks next to their names..
Brayden Lose for one.
Others?
Rueben Love may have a question mark not his best last few weeks probably down to carrying that injury which may have hurt him.
Perenara not a great game.
Those stand out to me.
on the reverse side
Sititi pushed his case
D Mac,Lienart -Brown,Narawa,Finau all confirmed their case for selection.Proctor pushed his case again, Lakai even though his missed a couple of tackles is the same for me.
Amua was solid even Walker-Leware is worth a look, a big unit I thought in a losing side he went well.
-
@Chris said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
@Frank said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
@Chris said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
A few players would have either played their way out of the ABs yesterday ,or at the very least now have big question marks next to their names..
Brayden Lose for one.
Others?
Rueben Love may have a question mark not his best last few weeks probably down to carrying that injury which may have hurt him.
Perenara not a great game.
Those stand out to me.
on the reverse side
Sititi pushed his case
D Mac,Lienart -Brown,Narawa,Finau all confirmed their case for selection.Proctor pushed his case again, Lakai even though his missed a couple of tackles is the same for me.
Amua was solid even Walker-Leware is worth a look, a big unit I thought in a losing side he went well.
I forgot about IWL. He had a VG game
-
-
@ploughboy said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
ill against the grain and say Lakai played his way out four missed tackles and 3 turnovers conceded, talented kid just not ready yet.
You could be right if they only pick 5 LFs he may miss out.
-
@Chris said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
@Frank said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
@Chris said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
A few players would have either played their way out of the ABs yesterday ,or at the very least now have big question marks next to their names..
Brayden Lose for one.
Others?
Rueben Love may have a question mark not his best last few weeks probably down to carrying that injury which may have hurt him.
Perenara not a great game.
Those stand out to me.
on the reverse side
Sititi pushed his case
D Mac,Lienart -Brown,Narawa,Finau all confirmed their case for selection.Proctor pushed his case again, Lakai even though his missed a couple of tackles is the same for me.
Amua was solid even Walker-Leware is worth a look, a big unit I thought in a losing side he went well.
Yeah I have been watching Love closely the last few weeks and I am convinced his knee is bothering him quite a bit. He seems to have lost a little pace and if he goes on a run involving stepping or swerving he gets up hobbling. Shame for the young fella. If he does get picked it wouldn't surprise me to see him on the injury list initially.
-
None of the Canes covered themselves in glory yesterday, but one bad game does not make them bad players. I don't think a wise coach can ignore the entire body of work. Lakai and Love have time on their side. If they miss out so be it. Proctor has a stronger case
-
@Crazy-Horse said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
@Chris said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
@Frank said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
@Chris said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
A few players would have either played their way out of the ABs yesterday ,or at the very least now have big question marks next to their names..
Brayden Lose for one.
Others?
Rueben Love may have a question mark not his best last few weeks probably down to carrying that injury which may have hurt him.
Perenara not a great game.
Those stand out to me.
on the reverse side
Sititi pushed his case
D Mac,Lienart -Brown,Narawa,Finau all confirmed their case for selection.Proctor pushed his case again, Lakai even though his missed a couple of tackles is the same for me.
Amua was solid even Walker-Leware is worth a look, a big unit I thought in a losing side he went well.
Yeah I have been watching Love closely the last few weeks and I am convinced his knee is bothering him quite a bit. He seems to have lost a little pace and if he goes on a run involving stepping or swerving he gets up hobbling. Shame for the young fella. If he does get picked it wouldn't surprise me to see him on the injury list initially.
then it would be better he rests his knee than risk making it worse.
Knee injuries can be diabolical. -
@Chris said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
@Nepia said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
@Chris said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
A few players would have either played their way out of the ABs yesterday ,or at the very least now have big question marks next to their names..
By that reckoning have all the Crusaders played their way out of the ABs this season? After all they were unable to not choke in the round robin games and didn't make the big games.
No as they didn't choke in the finals again this year they are at the front of selections as always.
I admire you're honesty and the inherent bias within it. If @ACT-Crusader ever get hit by a bus it will be good to know you will be available to select the AB's each year and we don't have to resort to dusting off the ghost of Phooey.
-
@mariner4life Even then the Hurricanes were losing to the Brumbies.
-
@Tim said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
@mariner4life Even then the Hurricanes were losing to the Brumbies.
Probably, they are our bogey team after all.
-
Quite an odd game, the Chiefs didn't do a great deal to create opportunities but just fed off the canes mistakes and really capitalised on them.
Sititi, Nawara, Ratima and DMac were immense - ALB had another fine game.
The Canes got drawn into a kicking game with the Cheifs they were never going to win, tactical error there, they should have tucked the ball and ran it and try to build something out of their own half.
I could have stomached Finau's yellow had TJP been given the same but an utterly farcical call to not give TJP the yellow - there was no mitigation there aside from TJ being little - utterly ridiculous.
Thankfully it didn't influence the outcome of the game, Jacobsen's yellow was ridiculous also.
Chiefs defence was outstanding - they were really up for this game while the Canes seemed a little over-awed, Canes got behind early and just got flustered and couldn't pull it back.
It was an enjoyable watch despite the refs and TMO's best attempts to ruin the game.
-
Not doing a MOTM poll for the Semi Final?
-
@Duluth said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
Not doing a MOTM poll for the Semi Final?
Good question. Although I can't remember much about the game now. Who won?
-
@Duluth said in SF - Hurricanes vs Chiefs:
Not doing a MOTM poll for the Semi Final?
I completely forgot after the disappointment. I think it’s a little late now haha
