All Black pack
-
@nzzp said in All Black pack:
@Chris said in All Black pack:
@nzzp said in All Black pack:
The crappy game plan and selections are on him,
This is Foster right through from his Chiefs days.
And he is coaching and selecting the AB's ,seems to me not the right choice and nothing will change while he is there.I agree.
But - the problems go deeper than just Foster. As @Victor-Meldrew keeps pointing out, new coaches will still have to deal with the cattle.
This would should have been cauterised after Irealnd 3,a nd everyone would be moving forward. Someone used the word 'dithering' in another thread - sums up NZR beautifully.
I agree there is more than Foster as the problem, but for me its a great place to start.
We have to change the fixable now and that is Foster gone then sort the rest as we can. -
@nzzp said in All Black pack:
@Chris said in All Black pack:
@nzzp said in All Black pack:
The crappy game plan and selections are on him,
This is Foster right through from his Chiefs days.
And he is coaching and selecting the AB's ,seems to me not the right choice and nothing will change while he is there.I agree.
But - the problems go deeper than just Foster. As @Victor-Meldrew keeps pointing out, new coaches will still have to deal with the cattle.
This would should have been cauterised after Irealnd 3,a nd everyone would be moving forward. Someone used the word 'dithering' in another thread - sums up NZR beautifully.
It's totally not just foster, but he's exacerbating all our problems. Cos he's a nice bloke in a cut throat environment, a smiling buffoon who spouts platitudes, the most dangerous of leaders - one who can't see their own inadequacies
-
@nzzp said in All Black pack:
@Chris said in All Black pack:
How many more do we use everyone in SR Yet the one consistent in this is Foster and he stays.
I have another read on this, which is that Super is no longer preparing people for Test rugby. It used to - we had a conveyor belt of talent. Now, not so much ... the questions are different, and players that shine in Super just dno't easily transfer the form to Tests. I think part of this is due to the coaching exodus, just not preparing players or lifting quality well enough. Or playing SA sides regularly too (although that's my hill to die on).
That's not on Foster. The crappy game plan and selections are on him, but the lack of world class players are not. That said, I think some of those players could be there or thereabouts - bu tthey need the environment, prep and coaching to get there, as well as a coherent game plan.
I tend to agree. Could Rangi stop the Blues from having a final meltdown? Could he get BB playing the type of test rugby game that he needed to? He's a good coach. Our players think they are better than they are frankly, and some of our coaches buy into that.
-
@nzzp said in All Black pack:
@Chris said in All Black pack:
How many more do we use everyone in SR Yet the one consistent in this is Foster and he stays.
I have another read on this, which is that Super is no longer preparing people for Test rugby. It used to - we had a conveyor belt of talent. Now, not so much ... the questions are different, and players that shine in Super just dno't easily transfer the form to Tests. I think part of this is due to the coaching exodus, just not preparing players or lifting quality well enough. Or playing SA sides regularly too (although that's my hill to die on).
Yeah, reckon that's been the case for nearly a decade but it was papered over by an exceptional cohort of players that has gradually retired or hung around too long.
So exceptional selection and coaching skill more critical than ever.
The media circle jerk over Super Rugby Aoteoroa as "the toughest rugby competition in the world" a couple of years was laughable, and a lot of the NZ rugby public still buy into that perception. This morning I've seen people seriously suggesting selecting players from NPC.
-
@Crucial said in All Black pack:
@nzzp said in All Black pack:
@Chris said in All Black pack:
How many more do we use everyone in SR Yet the one consistent in this is Foster and he stays.
I have another read on this, which is that Super is no longer preparing people for Test rugby. It used to - we had a conveyor belt of talent. Now, not so much ... the questions are different, and players that shine in Super just dno't easily transfer the form to Tests. I think part of this is due to the coaching exodus, just not preparing players or lifting quality well enough. Or playing SA sides regularly too (although that's my hill to die on).
That's not on Foster. The crappy game plan and selections are on him, but the lack of world class players are not. That said, I think some of those players could be there or thereabouts - bu tthey need the environment, prep and coaching to get there, as well as a coherent game plan.
I tend to agree. Could Rangi stop the Blues from having a final meltdown? Could he get BB playing the type of test rugby game that he needed to? He's a good coach. Our players think they are better than they are frankly, and some of our coaches buy into that.
On the flip side of that ,Robertson prepared a team with a great game plan and tactics,Motivated them to buy into it and execute to win the SR final away from home.
Good coaching makes a difference and it shows. -
@BartMan remember when they cut to Coles on the sideline. He said we needed to clean up our infringements and keep up the intensity and the opportunities would come. Then we subbed our entire front row, gave away possession and penalties and other errors crept in.
Sigh.
-
@Crucial said in All Black pack:
@nzzp said in All Black pack:
@Chris said in All Black pack:
How many more do we use everyone in SR Yet the one consistent in this is Foster and he stays.
I have another read on this, which is that Super is no longer preparing people for Test rugby. It used to - we had a conveyor belt of talent. Now, not so much ... the questions are different, and players that shine in Super just dno't easily transfer the form to Tests. I think part of this is due to the coaching exodus, just not preparing players or lifting quality well enough. Or playing SA sides regularly too (although that's my hill to die on).
That's not on Foster. The crappy game plan and selections are on him, but the lack of world class players are not. That said, I think some of those players could be there or thereabouts - bu tthey need the environment, prep and coaching to get there, as well as a coherent game plan.
I tend to agree. Could Rangi stop the Blues from having a final meltdown? Could he get BB playing the type of test rugby game that he needed to? He's a good coach. Our players think they are better than they are frankly, and some of our coaches buy into that.
Someone mentioned in the game thread, I think, about how many player's we'd want from SA or Arg - not many! Really bollox, I'd take a lot of boks, and an Puma or two. Sami and Ardie are our only really top class players. Ioane could be, but he's not world class in the centres. Whitelock is good in the lineout. Ummmm. That's about it in a world 23. But Most countries have similar, just a handful that would be in a world 23. But their coaches use what they have so much better
-
@Machpants said in All Black pack:
@Crucial said in All Black pack:
@nzzp said in All Black pack:
@Chris said in All Black pack:
How many more do we use everyone in SR Yet the one consistent in this is Foster and he stays.
I have another read on this, which is that Super is no longer preparing people for Test rugby. It used to - we had a conveyor belt of talent. Now, not so much ... the questions are different, and players that shine in Super just dno't easily transfer the form to Tests. I think part of this is due to the coaching exodus, just not preparing players or lifting quality well enough. Or playing SA sides regularly too (although that's my hill to die on).
That's not on Foster. The crappy game plan and selections are on him, but the lack of world class players are not. That said, I think some of those players could be there or thereabouts - bu tthey need the environment, prep and coaching to get there, as well as a coherent game plan.
I tend to agree. Could Rangi stop the Blues from having a final meltdown? Could he get BB playing the type of test rugby game that he needed to? He's a good coach. Our players think they are better than they are frankly, and some of our coaches buy into that.
Someone mentioned in the game thread, I think, about how many player's we'd want from SA or Arg - not many! Really bollox, I'd take a lot of boks, and an Puma or two. Sami and Ardie are our only really top class players. Ioane could be, but he's not world class in the centres. Whitelock is good in the lineout. Ummmm. That's about it in a world 23. But Most countries have similar, just a handful that would be in a world 23. But their coaches use what they have so much better
Has anyone reached Sean Fitzpatrick for comments on this ?
-
@Machpants said in All Black pack:
@Crucial said in All Black pack:
@nzzp said in All Black pack:
@Chris said in All Black pack:
How many more do we use everyone in SR Yet the one consistent in this is Foster and he stays.
I have another read on this, which is that Super is no longer preparing people for Test rugby. It used to - we had a conveyor belt of talent. Now, not so much ... the questions are different, and players that shine in Super just dno't easily transfer the form to Tests. I think part of this is due to the coaching exodus, just not preparing players or lifting quality well enough. Or playing SA sides regularly too (although that's my hill to die on).
That's not on Foster. The crappy game plan and selections are on him, but the lack of world class players are not. That said, I think some of those players could be there or thereabouts - bu tthey need the environment, prep and coaching to get there, as well as a coherent game plan.
I tend to agree. Could Rangi stop the Blues from having a final meltdown? Could he get BB playing the type of test rugby game that he needed to? He's a good coach. Our players think they are better than they are frankly, and some of our coaches buy into that.
Someone mentioned in the game thread, I think, about how many player's we'd want from SA or Arg - not many! Really bollox, I'd take a lot of boks, and an Puma or two. Sami and Ardie are our only really top class players. Ioane could be, but he's not world class in the centres. Whitelock is good in the lineout. Ummmm. That's about it in a world 23. But Most countries have similar, just a handful that would be in a world 23. But their coaches use what they have so much better
Something else that isn't helping is that we aren't able to get a decent lead in a game to give the next tier game time. How is Vai'i going to get to be a test lock without playing? Sotutu? Dalton P?
We have seen Taylor fall off a cliff and Coles slide down down it. That could happen with Whitelock and some will argue that it has already started with BBBR. -
@Chris said in All Black pack:
@nzzp said in All Black pack:
The crappy game plan and selections are on him,
This is Foster right through from his Chiefs days.
And he is coaching and selecting the AB's ,seems to me not the right choice and nothing will change while he is there.Not a single word about the "All Black pack" in that post.
There's a thread for bitching about Foster, where the same old arguments can be re-hashed ad-nauseum. -
@BartMan said in All Black pack:
Set piece much improved. But outlayed in last 30 big time.
The last 35mins
The drop in the quality of work around the field from the starting front row to that Crusaders front row was massive. The clean outs went to shit again.. a problem the AB tight five has had for a few years now (back to the tail end of Hansen)
A lot of that is the enormous gap in quality between Samisoni and Taylor. However I think a few people need to pump the breaks on the hype around the newer props.
-
@Duluth said in All Black pack:
@BartMan said in All Black pack:
Set piece much improved. But outlayed in last 30 big time.
The last 35mins
The drop in the quality of work around the field from the starting front row to that Crusaders front row was massive. The clean outs went to shit again.. a problem the AB tight five has had for a few years now (back to the tail end of Hansen)
A lot of that is the enormous gap in quality between Samisoni and Taylor. However I think a few people need to pump the breaks on the hype around the newer props.
"brakes" - but yeah, agreed... the hype-train on the newer props seems massively over-done on very little evidence. Optimism, I guess. I certainly HOPE they're as good as people seem to think/hope.
But... when I accept the ABs head coach role, and make all decisions based on a read-through of the Fern... I'd like to think there's some realistic suggestions and expectations. -
@sparky said in All Black pack:
Front five apart from Taylor okay. Vaii needs more gametime.
Backrow not working. Ardie empties the tank every week but he's not a natural 8. Flankers get outplayed by the opposition in most games.
Starting Back row: Akira Ioane, Papali'i, Sotutu. Ardie off the bench.
Won't happen though because Foster has his favourites.
I would not have Akira in the team, your perfect flat track bully. So I'd go Papali'i at 6, as he's more than big enough for that spot physicallly. Ardi at 7, his natural position, and a real 8 at 8, would go with Grace, but he's broken and not in squad, so that leaves Sotutu, give him plenty of game time. Sam Cane joins Cody Taylor in the needs a huge super season to be back in black.
-
@Tim said in All Black pack:
Oh hey, the
bestfastest-driving player in the country (Papalii) can't be played because the coach loves the worst.He hasn't played enough at AB level to give the "best player in the country" accolade IMHO. And certainly not at 6.
-
@BartMan said in All Black pack:
@sparky said in All Black pack:
Front five apart from Taylor okay. Vaii needs more gametime.
Backrow not working. Ardie empties the tank every week but he's not a natural 8. Flankers get outplayed by the opposition in most games.
Starting Back row: Akira Ioane, Papali'i, Sotutu. Ardie off the bench.
Won't happen though because Foster has his favourites.
I would not have Akira in the team, your perfect flat track bully. So I'd go Papali'i at 6, as he's more than big enough for that spot physicallly. Ardi at 7, his natural position, and a real 8 at 8, would go with Grace, but he's broken and not in squad, so that leaves Sotutu, give him plenty of game time. Sam Cane joins Cody Taylor in the needs a huge super season to be back in black.
I think maybe his Blues supporters may finally be seeing that. Did he come on last night just so he could fall over?
When you are competing for a spot with someone that apparently has more drive than you at least you can make an effort when carrying FFS. He was carrying like George Bridge.
Waste of good fotballing talent because either no one tells him, or he doesn't listen, that he isn't the strongest kid in the playground any more.
I'd love to see the guy in the team so when all the hard work is done an opportunity appears to show the talent but he doesn't want to contribute to the hard work.
Sotutu isn't much better judging by his NPC time. Lots of flash and dash but not enough bash and smash. -
-
@Crucial said in All Black pack:
@BartMan said in All Black pack:
@sparky said in All Black pack:
Front five apart from Taylor okay. Vaii needs more gametime.
Backrow not working. Ardie empties the tank every week but he's not a natural 8. Flankers get outplayed by the opposition in most games.
Starting Back row: Akira Ioane, Papali'i, Sotutu. Ardie off the bench.
Won't happen though because Foster has his favourites.
I would not have Akira in the team, your perfect flat track bully. So I'd go Papali'i at 6, as he's more than big enough for that spot physicallly. Ardi at 7, his natural position, and a real 8 at 8, would go with Grace, but he's broken and not in squad, so that leaves Sotutu, give him plenty of game time. Sam Cane joins Cody Taylor in the needs a huge super season to be back in black.
I think maybe his Blues supporters may finally be seeing that. Did he come on last night just so he could fall over?
When you are competing for a spot with someone that apparently has more drive than you at least you can make an effort when carrying FFS. He was carrying like George Bridge.
Waste of good fotballing talent because either no one tells him, or he doesn't listen, that he isn't the strongest kid in the playground any more.
I'd love to see the guy in the team so when all the hard work is done an opportunity appears to show the talent but he doesn't want to contribute to the hard work.
Sotutu isn't much better judging by his NPC time. Lots of flash and dash but not enough bash and smash.That’s asking an awful lot of some of them, steady on.
-
@KiwiMurph said in All Black pack:
@Crucial said in All Black pack:
Sotutu isn't much better judging by his NPC time. Lots of flash and dash but not enough bash and smash.
I wouldn't overreact to his first game in 2 months. He showed plenty of bash and smash in Super Rugby.
Served the Blues well when it got to the big game didn't it?
-
@Crucial said in All Black pack:
@BartMan said in All Black pack:
@sparky said in All Black pack:
Front five apart from Taylor okay. Vaii needs more gametime.
Backrow not working. Ardie empties the tank every week but he's not a natural 8. Flankers get outplayed by the opposition in most games.
Starting Back row: Akira Ioane, Papali'i, Sotutu. Ardie off the bench.
Won't happen though because Foster has his favourites.
I would not have Akira in the team, your perfect flat track bully. So I'd go Papali'i at 6, as he's more than big enough for that spot physicallly. Ardi at 7, his natural position, and a real 8 at 8, would go with Grace, but he's broken and not in squad, so that leaves Sotutu, give him plenty of game time. Sam Cane joins Cody Taylor in the needs a huge super season to be back in black.
I think maybe his Blues supporters may finally be seeing that. Did he come on last night just so he could fall over?
When you are competing for a spot with someone that apparently has more drive than you at least you can make an effort when carrying FFS. He was carrying like George Bridge.
Waste of good fotballing talent because either no one tells him, or he doesn't listen, that he isn't the strongest kid in the playground any more.
I'd love to see the guy in the team so when all the hard work is done an opportunity appears to show the talent but he doesn't want to contribute to the hard work.In 14 minutes he carried the ball seven times. A carry every two minutes compared to Frizell's every eight and Savea's every seven. He also made more tackles per minute which would suggest his workrate isn't an issue. By the time he came on Argentina had a lead and were defending for the game.
-
@antipodean said in All Black pack:
@Crucial said in All Black pack:
@BartMan said in All Black pack:
@sparky said in All Black pack:
Front five apart from Taylor okay. Vaii needs more gametime.
Backrow not working. Ardie empties the tank every week but he's not a natural 8. Flankers get outplayed by the opposition in most games.
Starting Back row: Akira Ioane, Papali'i, Sotutu. Ardie off the bench.
Won't happen though because Foster has his favourites.
I would not have Akira in the team, your perfect flat track bully. So I'd go Papali'i at 6, as he's more than big enough for that spot physicallly. Ardi at 7, his natural position, and a real 8 at 8, would go with Grace, but he's broken and not in squad, so that leaves Sotutu, give him plenty of game time. Sam Cane joins Cody Taylor in the needs a huge super season to be back in black.
I think maybe his Blues supporters may finally be seeing that. Did he come on last night just so he could fall over?
When you are competing for a spot with someone that apparently has more drive than you at least you can make an effort when carrying FFS. He was carrying like George Bridge.
Waste of good fotballing talent because either no one tells him, or he doesn't listen, that he isn't the strongest kid in the playground any more.
I'd love to see the guy in the team so when all the hard work is done an opportunity appears to show the talent but he doesn't want to contribute to the hard work.In 14 minutes he carried the ball seven times. A carry every two minutes compared to Frizell's every eight and Savea's every seven. He also made more tackles per minute which would suggest his workrate isn't an issue. By the time he came on Argentina had a lead and were defending for the game.
I'd suggest that is the role of the fresh legs forward. To do the carrying for the other more tired players. They would be looking for him every time.
What did he do with all those carries except an Owen Franks impression?
