Highlanders vs. Blues
-
@Stargazer said in Highlanders vs. Blues:
I don't think it's a publicity stunt at all. As I've mentioned before, people develop beliefs and opinions. You don't get them overnight. Because he has not grown up as a Muslim, he's started forming those beliefs quite late. Also factor in that he converted at a difficult time in his life when he had his alcohol issues (among other things), so he might not have started with all the information about what all the "requirements" are that a Muslim has to meet in his daily life (apart from the well-known ones, such as not drinking, not eating pork, halal food and gambling etc). Add to that the company he holds (some have been mentioned here) and possibly they're getting an increasing influence on him as well. So there are bound to be changes in what he considers compatible with his faith and what not.
So what was acceptable to him a couple of years ago when he played for the Crusaders and Chiefs may have gradually become unacceptable to him now. Obviously, there are inconsistencies along the way. I don't just mean the remaining logos on training jerseys, but also making selfies or being photographed to give just the one example. As far as I know, Islam prohibits the photography of animate things because - among other things - they can lead to worship and glorification of someone other than Allah. This won't be the end of SBW's religious development, esp if he's influenced by people with more strict/radical ideas.
It's also clear that he thought that having that conscientious objection clause available, meant that he could invoke that instantly, while - apparently - players need to make a request to NZR/their SR team first and obtain permission first. The fact that he didn't ask permission prior to taping off the logos seems to imply that he is either a very ignorant and impulsive person who didn't consider it properly, or a person who doesn't care about procedures and what his employers think about it.
I think you have to know him personally, like his team mates, to know what he's really like. I certainly won't form opinions about him by reading opinionated articles from journos. Just as I don't follow the fanboy hype around him, I won't let jealous/anti-religious/Islamophobic grudges influence me. Above all, I don't really care what he does or not, as long as he plays well when/if he gets to wear a black jersey again.How long will he be incapacitated when he gets the tatts removed? have the Blues factored this into the equation?
-
This whole thing is very David Pococky. If it was him doing it i would probably give him shit so ffs sbw, You don't help yourself with this sort of shit. Fair enough it is every players right because it's in their collective agreement but because it is based on religion and given the fact he is still happy to take money that has come from those sponsors it gets up my nose. Added to that he has already worn those logos plenty of times so it is hardly some life long belief.
As others have said it could have been done a whole lot more low key. Use black tape, pick the logo threads out, colour over it with black pen. Smacks of the controversial bullshit mundine and other boxers pull to get pay per view sales up when they have a fight.
-
-
@Stargazer said in Highlanders vs. Blues:
@MN5 LOL, let him do that after the EOYT (if selected) in his own time. BTW, are all tattoos against Islam?
You wrote the novel above, shouldn't you be the expert?
I think this is all a bit galling due to the fact that whilst SBW is obviously good he's not McCaw/DC good...even dare I say it Pocock good.....do we see Read, Kaino, BB, Whitelock, Retallick or whoever carrying on with this shit?
Sports teams come from all walks of life and backgrounds, you can guarantee more than a couple of his blues teammates will be spewing at all of this.
-
@Bones said in Highlanders vs. Blues:
Has he actually said it's religion based?
Stuff.co.nz believe it's religious based.
I'd bet my children's lives on the accuracy, integrity and proof reading of every single report I've ever read from them so that's good enough for me.
-
@Rocky-Rockbottom It wouldn't be religion if there wasn't an element of hypocrisy and cherry picking...
-
@MN5 Yeah good point.
I did have a laugh when I was saw the video on stuff that showed a clip from the game - I never noticed the tape and now I realise it was because it was pretty much the same colour as his skin. So black tape would've been a better option?
-
@Stargazer said in Highlanders vs. Blues:
I think you have to know him personally, like his team mates, to know what he's really like. I certainly won't form opinions about him by reading opinionated articles from journos. Just as I don't follow the fanboy hype around him, I won't let jealous/anti-religious/Islamophobic grudges influence me. Above all, I don't really care what he does or not, as long as he plays well when/if he gets to wear a black jersey again.
Haha, you call someone out on the hypocrisy of his actions and that hanging out with people that despise homosexuals reflects badly on him and suddenly made up words like Islamophobic come out.
I'm pretty comfortable forming an opinion of him based on those two things alone, let alone everything else that comes with brand SBW.
-
@Bones said in Highlanders vs. Blues:
@MN5 Yeah good point.
I did have a laugh when I was saw the video on stuff that showed a clip from the game - I never noticed the tape and now I realise it was because it was pretty much the same colour as his skin. So black tape would've been a better option?
Dude don't bring race into this.
-
@Stargazer Good post with well thought out argument - I don't agree with it, but your points are clear and succinct.
I do think it's naive though to think that this was done the way it was without intending it to cause the shitstorm it did. It could have been dealt with through the right channels very early on, instead of surprising everybody turning up on the day with them covered.
-
@No-Quarter Lima Sopoaga has to make a public apology for calling team mates gay on twitter and SBW gets a pass for hanging out with a guy who says homosexuals are worse than animals?
-
@No-Quarter said in Highlanders vs. Blues:
@Stargazer said in Highlanders vs. Blues:
I think you have to know him personally, like his team mates, to know what he's really like. I certainly won't form opinions about him by reading opinionated articles from journos. Just as I don't follow the fanboy hype around him, I won't let jealous/anti-religious/Islamophobic grudges influence me. Above all, I don't really care what he does or not, as long as he plays well when/if he gets to wear a black jersey again.
Haha, you call someone out on the hypocrisy of his actions and that hanging out with people that despise homosexuals reflects badly on him and suddenly made up words like Islamophobic come out.
I'm pretty comfortable forming an opinion of him based on those two things alone, let alone everything else that comes with brand SBW.
He's mates with Quade Cooper. That's another black mark.
However he also gave 100 grand to Christchurch for the earthquake appeal. He's well off but he's not Tiger Woods or David Beckham....kudos for him for that.
My main issue as it has always been has been the massive attention given to his every move relative to his talent....
-
@MN5 ironic that a count-back would more than likely show you as having the most posts on the guy
Rrrrrrraaaaiiiiinnn
-
there is a right way, a wrong way and an SBW way...is funny, this is the most @mn5 has posted on a rugby thread in years!
Am sure we will get some 'sound' reasoning as to why he did it this way, however I dont think it will be the full story...he's been a Muslim for 8 years, so surely it isnt something he has just realised, maybe he has just had someone point it out to him?
BUt as has been highlighted numerous time, the shear number of times BNZ has been mentioned in social media and mainstream media, it is almost as if it was some kind of covert publicility stunt, cos man they been getting some coverage
Or maybe the explanation is simple...if you look carefully, is that SBW at the end of the queue?
-
@mariner4life said in Highlanders vs. Blues:
@MN5 ironic that a count-back would more than likely show you as having the most posts on the guy
Rrrrrrraaaaiiiiinnn
@Hooroo and others are more full of hate though.
....and yours are definitely the gayest.
-
-
@MajorRage said in Highlanders vs. Blues:
Does anybody hate him? I don't think so , I know that I don't.
I just don't really care for the baggage that goes with him - of which not all his fault.
I love watching him play rugby, the sideshow that comes with him is very boring.
-
Yeah I'm a huge fan of how he plays. No matter what @MN5 says, the guy has put in and been a real asset to the AB squad. I personally don't think he did this to cause a stir. I saw it during the game and didn't even think a second thought. I was just hoping he'd wouldn't play well so the Landers would win.
I've seen other Super rugby players put tape on logos whether it's on compression gear or headgear. Those appear to be for financial and/or contractual purposes. This appears to be the same given its a contractual reason that has allowed him to tape over a sponsor.
It's neither here nor there for me. Bring on next week.
Stuff
Stuff
Stuff
