Foster, Robertson etc
-
@Victor-Meldrew I’m all for seeing more of Jordie at 12 , but yeah it’s easy to forget now how well he played last season as a test fullback. Was probably one of the few success stories .
Wasn’t that outrageous imo to play him there again .
-
@kiwiinmelb said in Foster:
@Victor-Meldrew I’m all for seeing more of Jordie at 12 , but yeah it’s easy to forget now how well he played last season as a test fullback. Was probably one of the few success stories .
Wasn’t that outrageous imo to play him there again .
I don't think anyone here would be quibbling about JB playing 15 if we had a steady 12 that was kicking ass or even just clearly growing into the role. Instead we have Havili and QT, neither of whom have stamped their mark, RTS waiting (and waiting) in the shadows, and ALB/Goodhue injured.
The real question is whether the best combo is one of those guys at 12 / JB at 15, or JB at 12 / BB at 15
-
@kiwiinmelb said in Foster:
@Victor-Meldrew I’m all for seeing more of Jordie at 12 , but yeah it’s easy to forget now how well he played last season as a test fullback. Was probably one of the few success stories .
Wasn’t that outrageous imo to play him there again .
I don't think anyone here would be quibbling about JB playing 15 if we had a steady 12 that was kicking ass or even just clearly growing into the role. Instead we have Havili and QT, neither of whom have stamped their mark, RTS waiting (and waiting) in the shadows, and ALB/Goodhue injured.
The real question is whether the best combo is one of those guys at 12 / JB at 15, or JB at 12 / BB at 15
Exactly. 15 isnt really a problem area. BB will always do the job there. But 12 was an area of serious concern. Hopefully not anymore 🤞
-
it would be odd (very stubborn) if he doesnt give JB more time on tour at 12 to at least see if he can build on his last outing.
-
@taniwharugby said in Foster:
it would be odd (very stubborn) if he doesnt give JB more time on tour at 12 to at least see if he can build on his last outing.
I wouldn't be surprised if we don't see him wearing 12 but moving into that position during games. ALB is back and they also need to see him as well as see how DH goes against NH sides now.
I think that to categorically lock JB in to that spot that need to explore the options and compare. I think that a few players may get half games. -
-
@KiwiMurph said in Foster:
A lot of talk about 12 but I think it will be interesting what they do at 13 in terms of building depth/options outside of just Rieko. I have a feeling they may look at ALB there.
I think Foster has most of his XV sorted, and he's just gambling on playing them together into form. It's weird, it's high risk, but it seems to fit what he does.
-
@KiwiMurph said in Foster:
A lot of talk about 12 but I think it will be interesting what they do at 13 in terms of building depth/options outside of just Rieko. I have a feeling they may look at ALB there.
Great to have someone who can play both 12 and 13 well esp as bench option but is 13 perhaps ALB's better position?
-
@Victor-Meldrew said in Foster:
@kiwi_expat said in Foster:
The guy still views RTS as a second-five eight.
As does Leon McDonald. What do you know that Foster and McDonald don't?
Leon McDonald doesn't exactly have a great reputation as a selector either, for example, dropping his 2 best locks for the SRP final and numerous other selections last season were detrimental to the Blues in 2021, when they finished 3rd with possibly the best roster in NZ.
-
-
Also, McDonald only played RTS at 12 because there was "a gap to fill there" it had very little to do with his suitability in that position given they already had 2 established wingers, fullback and R.Ioane locked at 13.
Have a gap in the backline and play your new recruit there.
Is this the hot takes thread?
-
Also, McDonald only played RTS at 12 because there was "a gap to fill there" it had very little to do with his suitability in that position given they already had 2 established wingers, fullback and R.Ioane locked at 13.
RTS was unsuitable in that position how exactly? Were there no other 12s available to McDonald or was he "forced" to play RTS there? (You know, like Foster was apparently "forced" to play Reiko at 13.)
-
@Machpants said in 2022 All Blacks NH tour:
Gawd he's an unispiring speaker
He's full of cliches - learnings, excitement blah blah blah
-
The fact that the improvements listed ('moved the performance needle big-time in the pack'; 'added some much-needed variation in attack'; the others mentioned have all flowed from those two) happened after Ryan and Schmidt were given roles in the ABs' coaching team speaks volumes.
The front row changes were injury-enforced, as Foster's original picks dropped out and had to be replaced by players who proved to be much better. Barrett at second-five was also injury-enforced, after Foster said he wasn't being looked at in that position.
In other words, Foster has been shown up as a poor coach and selector reliant on injury, not insight, to force clearly-needed changes, and reliant too on the competent coaches NZR added to the group when those chosen by Foster turned out, like him, to be not up to the job.
-
Rancid's analogy of a kid's rugby team having more skilled parents coming in to assist the well-liked but rather clueless original parent (who the kids don't want fired because they like him) is on point.
-
@taniwharugby said in Foster:
it would be odd (very stubborn) if he doesnt give JB more time on tour at 12 to at least see if he can build on his last outing.
Barrett 12, Jordan 15, Reece back at 14. Sevu is the best winger in the squad. Foster needs to play him - if he heads overseas... I'll be absolutely livered about it.
-
-
@kiwi_expat said in Foster:
The fact that the improvements listed ('moved the performance needle big-time in the pack'; 'added some much-needed variation in attack'; the others mentioned have all flowed from those two) happened after Ryan and Schmidt were given roles in the ABs' coaching team speaks volumes.
Glad you think things have improved under Foster. Long, long way to go, but I agree there are some promising signs.
. Barrett at second-five was also injury-enforced, after Foster said he wasn't being looked at in that position.
Foster preferring to play a pretty much world-class full-back at full-back? That's hardly an indicator of a poor selection mindset.
In other words, Foster has been shown up as a poor coach and selector reliant on injury, not insight, to force clearly-needed changes, and reliant too on the competent coaches NZR added to the group
Putting aside your inaccuracy that Schmidt was forced on Foster (he had been wanting Schmidt as an Assistant for 2 years), I'm puzzled by your argument that Foster is a poor Head Coach because he relies on his chosen assistants to do a good job.
-
Apparently, the reasons that fucking foster stayed were:
- Razor's 'in principle' team lacked international experience, so NZR wanted Schmidt in on it. He met Razor (as ordered by NZR), and then said 'no' - not due to not wanting to work with Razor, but because he thought it was pretty shitty for him to be talking to a potential replacement whilst working for Foster. Loyalty said he would stay.
- Great result SA 2
- Senior players loving getting picked no matter what and publicly backing him
Overall what a cluster, who the fuck is in charge? Not NZR, Robinson, or the Board!
Paywalled
Exclusive: The dramatic real reasons Ian Foster wasn't axed as All Blacks coach
The real story from the turbulent moments when the All Blacks role was at stake.
-
@Machpants said in Foster:
Apparently, the reasons that fucking foster stayed were:
- Razor's 'in principle' team lacked international experience, so NZR wanted Schmidt in on it. He met Razor (as ordered by NZR), and then said 'no' - not due to not wanting to work with Razor, but because he thought it was pretty shitty for him to be talking to a potential replacement whilst working for Foster. Loyalty said he would stay.
- Great result SA 2
- Senior players loving getting picked no matter what and publicly backing him
Overall what a cluster, who the fuck is in charge? Not NZR, Robinson, or the Board!
Paywalled
Exclusive: The dramatic real reasons Ian Foster wasn't axed as All Blacks coach
The real story from the turbulent moments when the All Blacks role was at stake.
What complete fuck feast,Not hard to see who is in charge and its not the board.
