All Blacks 2022
-
@Bovidae said in All Blacks 2022:
With Bower, the problem is his inconsistent scrummaging, not what he does around the field. It will be interesting to see which LH props are selected for the 1st test. Tu'inukuafe has to start, or not be in the 23.
I'm thinking a fairly conservative start with the bench options to see what difference can be made. May as well take last year's lot, see how they stack up and provide some opportunities for others. If all goes well can change things up next time with the starters (eg RM or SB) and bench (eg Sotutu)
Karl Tu’inukuafe, Samisoni Taukeiaho, Nepo Laulala,
Brodie Retallick, Sam Whitelock
Sam Cane (c), Akira Ioane, Ardie Savea,
Aaron Smith
Beauden Barrett
David Havili/ Quinn Tupaea, Rieko Ioane
Jordie Barrett, Caleb Clarke, Will Jordan
Bench: Aidan Ross, Ofa Tuungafasi, Codie Taylor, Tupou Vaa'i, Dalton Papalii, Folau Fakatava, Stephen Perofeta, Sevu Reece
-
@Steven-Harris said in All Blacks 2022:
@number9 agree about Karl T, his form has been patchy and he’s heading overseas 🤷🏻♂️.
On Angus Ta’avao, I don’t believe he’s an international class tighthead prop , thought he was average when he first made the Blues, improved when he went to the Warratahs, but in my opinion is no better than super level ..would get eaten by most international loose head props ..Other than Australians I guess?
-
@Higgins said in All Blacks 2022:
@Chris said in All Blacks 2022:
@Kirwan said in All Blacks 2022:
@Chris said in All Blacks 2022:
With those prop selections we don't seem to be addressing the lack of ball running ability problem from last season.
Is this going to be more of the same the backs taken out of the game by us not getting over the gain line up front.
PGS there for that I suppose but won't start ahead of Ardie,RTS,LF will not get much game time it looks a lot like last year to me.The 23 looks like it will not change from last season.PGS will be the backup six to Akira, IMO. If they start ST instead of Taylor, and with Ofa's improved ball running/fitness (probably from the bench) you have two great ball running options just from the front row.
Akira/Ardie/Cane with Dalton on the bench gives good options there too. Really the locks that have to up that area of the game, so a lot resting on Scott Barrett IMO.
Maybe, I just don't have much faith in Fosters and co's selections when it comes to the 23.I can see better options in the squad than what they might actually pick.
It will be interesting to see that first 23 for the first test v Ireland.
I think Barret is probably the no.1 lock ATM.That he might be, but not much use to the team when he is sitting down for ten or twenty minutes thanks to the inevitable carding.
he seems to have adjusted the tackling technique for one, I noticed last week all his 20 plus tackles were below the hips.
-
@Crucial I would be nervous as hell going into RWC ,QF,Semi or Final with Angus on the bench no matter whom we were up against ..
-
@Steven-Harris You could say the same about Ofa as he regularly gets penalised in the scrum.
-
Karl T, ST, Laulala
Whitelock, SB
AI, Sotutu, Paps
Smith
BB, RTS, RI
Jordan, JB, ReeceOT, Ta'avao, Coles, BBBR, Savea, Tupaea, Fakatava, Mounga
Unlikely to be anywhere close to the 23 but given the squad that is the team I would put out there.
Hardest part was cover for RI should he go down early, who goes to 13? That made the reserves a bit tricky as Goodhue is the obvious cover but lacks pace and not sure the impact so went with Tupaea.
Also should probably have Cane in there but not sure he is back to full fitness mentally and in body.
-
@chimoaus said in All Blacks 2022:
Karl T, ST, Laulala
Whitelock, SB
AI, Sotutu, Paps
Smith
BB, RTS, RI
Jordan, JB, ReeceOT, Ta'avao, Coles, BBBR, Savea, Tupaea, Fakatava, Mounga
Unlikely to be anywhere close to the 23 but given the squad that is the team I would put out there.
Hardest part was cover for RI should he go down early, who goes to 13? That made the reserves a bit tricky as Goodhue is the obvious cover but lacks pace and not sure the impact so went with Tupaea.
Also should probably have Cane in there but not sure he is back to full fitness mentally and in body.
Why mentally? Seems an odd comment.
-
@Crucial said in All Blacks 2022:
@chimoaus said in All Blacks 2022:
Karl T, ST, Laulala
Whitelock, SB
AI, Sotutu, Paps
Smith
BB, RTS, RI
Jordan, JB, ReeceOT, Ta'avao, Coles, BBBR, Savea, Tupaea, Fakatava, Mounga
Unlikely to be anywhere close to the 23 but given the squad that is the team I would put out there.
Hardest part was cover for RI should he go down early, who goes to 13? That made the reserves a bit tricky as Goodhue is the obvious cover but lacks pace and not sure the impact so went with Tupaea.
Also should probably have Cane in there but not sure he is back to full fitness mentally and in body.
Why mentally? Seems an odd comment.
Dunno, just seems since his injury last year I just don't feel he has reached peak Cane and not sure if he believes it either. No evidence, just an armchair observation. I also found it very odd he was on the bench in a semi-final.
-
-
I'd like to see the coaches show some balls and open with:
A Smith
Beauden
Clarke
RTS
Rieko
Jordan
JordieReece, Mo'unga and Fakatava on the bench to carve up against their tiring defense.
We've got to move on from "safe" players (E.G. Havili) or we won't have a point of difference against the other top sides. Then all we need the forwards to do is actually gain some fucking parity and watch that backline tear them to pieces.
-
@Stargazer Bower's got a decent turn of speed. I think he's a good selection.
-
@Chris-B I guess if they can up the workrate of that crop of props, it isnt an issue.
Do we know the average number of scrums set in games these days given the importance it looks like they have put on that aspect of the game.
-
@Bovidae you will get no argument from me on that one Ofa T, Kart T and Angus T ..all very lucky , all have 2nd names that start with ,T just a coincidence 😂
-
@Steven-Harris Strange to say that Ofa Tu'ungufasi is lucky to make the ABs. He's been one of the best and most involved players in the competition. He had one bad night at the scrum with two light weight locks behind him. Otherwise he's been excellent.
-
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks 2022:
Do we know the average number of scrums set in games these days given the importance it looks like they have put on that aspect of the game.
It's only not an issue until it is. If you're conceding scrum penalties, teams can keep resetting until you get carded. I don't think yo uhve to be dominant, but I do think you have to be able to hold your own.
-
@Tim said in All Blacks 2022:
QUESTIONS!
Who do you think will be in the 23 for the first test if everyone is available?
Who would you pick from this squad for the 23 for the first test if everyone is available?
Me: Bower, Sam T, Ofa, SBarrett, Retallick, Ioane, Savea, Sotutu, Smith, BBarrett*, Reece, Goodhue, Ioane, Jordan, Jordie
Taylor, Ross, Laulala, Whitelock, Cane, Christie, Mo'unga*, Clarke- This might change on Saturday night!
Fozzie: Bower, Taylor, Laulala, Retallick, Whitelock, Ioane, Cane, Savea, Smith, Barrett, Reece, (12. Any of four?), Ioane, Jordan Jordie
Sam T., Big Karl, Ofa, Barrett, Papalií if fit, Christie, Mo'unga, (Any of three remaining midfielders). -
@Tim , just has’nt developed into the international prop i thought he he could be ,rocks and diamonds , more rocks in recent years stand to be corrected on Ofa but boy there are times in find myself being more frustated with him most of the time and then he comes up with a big hit or an awesome carry , just need to see more consistancy
-
@Steven-Harris said in All Blacks 2022:
@Tim , just has’nt developed into the international prop i thought he he could be ,rocks and diamonds , more rocks in recent years stand to be corrected on Ofa but boy there are times in find myself being more frustated with him most of the time and then he comes up with a big hit or an awesome carry , just need to see more consistancy
Which is exactly what's happened in 2022. He's been phenonemal for the Blues
-
@nzzp I was going to also say, I reckon there must be well over double or triple the number of resets than actual scrums
Ref plays a part in resets too, I mean the stat that Pickerill has more restarts than other refs, what is he dong wrong to cause/allow that? Or is he more accurate there and other refs giving leeway....
-
@Kirwan , i think phenomenal is bit of stretch , i think Papalii pre injury was phenomenal , maybe even Perofeta ..i would still put Ofa T in the reasonably good category .
Is he a starting AB prop …?, not in my book.
