Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc
-
@dan54 said in All Blacks 2022:
We tend to only see a very small amount of fan's opinions on the net, and they should always be taken with a huge dose of salt!
Yeah, Warrenball was a press thing, but I recall my two Welsh mates with serious rugby smarts also agreeing with the general feeling about Gatland and I value their opinions highly. Their view seems to be about lack of creativity and not making the best of his resources.
Came right in the end though, I guess.
-
@victor-meldrew said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
@nepia said in All Blacks 2022:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2022:
@bones said in All Blacks 2022:
@dagrubster said in All Blacks 2022:
our leading most experienced coaches are not in NZ.
It's an easy thing to say, but how about some names? Jamie Joseph I think could be handy.....who else?
Schmidt is already in. Gatland?
The more involvement he has the worse the Chiefs are. When MacMillan has been in charge they look a much better team. Maybe his NH style doesn't work for our players?
IIRC, Gatland wasn't all that rated by many Welsh fans up to 2017 with his style of play being derided as "Warrenball", but he won 4 6N's has been relatively successful with the Lions.
Now he's full-time with the Chiefs we'll be able to see how good he is in SR and how he goes with the team over the next year.
Harsh, he is by far the most sucessful Lions coach ever!
But I think the reason we only had 2 people apply for the ABs job was timing. They left it until well late, so would you apply for your dream job with the ABs when, if you don’t get it there’s no decent jobs left (and the encumbent was in a very strong position to take the role)? That’s why Razor went for it, he was good to do some more years at sadres after. I wouldn’t do that, against a stacked deck and the posibility of coaching outer mongolia afterwards as that was the only job left.
IMO NZR did this on purpose, so they could have their choice confirmed. Not their fault only 2 applied, and one doesn’t have any international experience… /tinfoil hat
-
@machpants they may have assumed that Shag would win out in Tokyo therefore making Foster's succession feel like a natural step
-
@canefan said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
@machpants they may have assumed that Shag would win out in Tokyo therefore making Foster's succession feel like a natural step
They must’ve had their eyes closed since 2017 if they thought that! But that could be so
-
@machpants said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
@canefan said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
@machpants they may have assumed that Shag would win out in Tokyo therefore making Foster's succession feel like a natural step
They must’ve had their eyes closed since 2017 if they thought that! But that could be so
NZRFU arrogance
-
I agree with @Dan54 about Rennie, as he (Rennie) has said that he was already in discussions with Raelene Castle well before the RWC. I'm not absolving NZR, because they should have been proactive in approaching all potential candidates well in advance of Tokyo.
I've always been bemused about the term "Warrenball" because there are plenty of examples of teams he has coached that played expansive rugby. Wasps and Waikato being two. Maybe he was more pragmatic at international level but I don't think that Wales have changed too much since he left. So it is now Pivacball?
-
-
@bovidae said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
I agree with @Dan54 about Rennie, as he (Rennie) has said that he was already in discussions with Raelene Castle well before the RWC. I'm not absolving NZR, because they should have been proactive in approaching all potential candidates well in advance of Tokyo.
I've always been bemused about the term "Warrenball" because there are plenty of examples of teams he has coached that played expansive rugby. Wasps and Waikato being two. Maybe he was more pragmatic at international level but I don't think that Wales have changed too much since he left. So it is now Pivacball?
Yep well many of net experts have to wait for media to come up with name to jump on board mate. You will notice that some of our press even used the Warrenball crap when Lions were here in 2017, and then same on net. If anyone thought the Lions went so well by playing Warrenball ie a big centre carrying it up etc, they not watching the game. The other think about Warrenball, how many keep harping it the way ABs should play, and moaned about Laumape etc going because he played it to a "T".
-
@victor-meldrew said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
@dan54 said in All Blacks 2022:
We tend to only see a very small amount of fan's opinions on the net, and they should always be taken with a huge dose of salt!
Yeah, Warrenball was a press thing, but I recall my two Welsh mates with serious rugby smarts also agreeing with the general feeling about Gatland and I value their opinions highly. Their view seems to be about lack of creativity and not making the best of his resources.
Came right in the end though, I guess.
Funnily enough by best mate is a Welshman too Vic, a real rugby man, him and I have been known to chase rugby all over the place to actually watch it, and he was always keen on what Gatland did, but didn't like some of Hansen's decisions.I always remember talking to a load of Welshmen during Lions tour to Aussie in 2001, and them asking me how NZ let Henry go, they thought he was great. I myself reckoned Hanry got better as an international coach AFTER theLions and Wales, as did Hansen, who says he learnt so much doing that job.
And even Razor says he would like to get international experience, why he wanted to go as an assistant on Lions tour to SA.And I know it's thought that promoting from within is not the thing to do by many in here, I will bet that Dan McKellar get's the Wallabies job after Rennie, RA is already hinting strongly that is the case.
And already Rennie is starting to cop it a bit in at least one Aussie forum. -
@bovidae said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
I've always been bemused about the term "Warrenball" because there are plenty of examples of teams he has coached that played expansive rugby. Wasps and Waikato being two. Maybe he was more pragmatic at international level but I don't think that Wales have changed too much since he left. So it is now Pivacball?
IMO really good coaches have an ability to see the way rugby should be played, but pragmatic enough to adopt the best way for the talent at hand.
-
@hooroo said in All Blacks 2022:
The good thing about the next AB coach is it will be his own success without argument.
Henry took over a successful Mitch Squad, Hansen over Henry and then Fozzie sucked the Kumara. The new coach will get to build from Scratch again and make it theres.
Almost every coach brings in own players and so really makes team his own, Henry had a few of Mitchell's, same as Hansen and Foster. It will be same with next coach who will have a decent amount of present players. It has been same for as long as I have watched rugby, with maybe the only real new team was the baby Blacks where most of preferred team was stood down.
-
@antipodean And I thought that's what Gatland did with Wales.
-
@machpants said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
Harsh, he is by far the most sucessful Lions coach ever!
I'm so old I go back to Syd Millar and Carwyn James...
-
@dan54 said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
I always remember talking to a load of Welshmen during Lions tour to Aussie in 2001, and them asking me how NZ let Henry go, they thought he was great.
I've heard that too. His legacy was far more than simply coaching the national team and been told he was heavily involved in re-structuring the game in Wales.
As an aside, my Welsh mate's wife was an Assistant Headteacher and went to talk by Henry on education & extra-curricular activities. She said it was poss. the best lecture she'd ever been to and he was clearly top of tree on education thinking.
-
@machpants said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
@victor-meldrew said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
@nepia said in All Blacks 2022:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2022:
@bones said in All Blacks 2022:
@dagrubster said in All Blacks 2022:
our leading most experienced coaches are not in NZ.
It's an easy thing to say, but how about some names? Jamie Joseph I think could be handy.....who else?
Schmidt is already in. Gatland?
The more involvement he has the worse the Chiefs are. When MacMillan has been in charge they look a much better team. Maybe his NH style doesn't work for our players?
IIRC, Gatland wasn't all that rated by many Welsh fans up to 2017 with his style of play being derided as "Warrenball", but he won 4 6N's has been relatively successful with the Lions.
Now he's full-time with the Chiefs we'll be able to see how good he is in SR and how he goes with the team over the next year.
Harsh, he is by far the most sucessful Lions coach ever!
Cough. Cough. Sir Ian McGeechan?
-
@victor-meldrew said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
@dan54 said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
I always remember talking to a load of Welshmen during Lions tour to Aussie in 2001, and them asking me how NZ let Henry go, they thought he was great.
I've heard that too. His legacy was far more than simply coaching the national team and been told he was heavily involved in re-structuring the game in Wales.
As an aside, my Welsh mate's wife was an Assistant Headteacher and went to talk by Henry on education & extra-curricular activities. She said it was poss. the best lecture she'd ever been to and he was clearly top of tree on education thinking.
Looking in from the outside I'd say one of the biggest successes he had with Wales (aside from the re-structure - jury still out I'd say), was how he instilled belief in the national squad. His biggest mistake for me was taking on the Lions job in 2001 where I feel he lost that belief by overlooking many Welsh players. Gatland didn't make that mistake.
-
@catogrande said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
@victor-meldrew said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
@dan54 said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
I always remember talking to a load of Welshmen during Lions tour to Aussie in 2001, and them asking me how NZ let Henry go, they thought he was great.
I've heard that too. His legacy was far more than simply coaching the national team and been told he was heavily involved in re-structuring the game in Wales.
As an aside, my Welsh mate's wife was an Assistant Headteacher and went to talk by Henry on education & extra-curricular activities. She said it was poss. the best lecture she'd ever been to and he was clearly top of tree on education thinking.
Looking in from the outside I'd say one of the biggest successes he had with Wales (aside from the re-structure - jury still out I'd say), was how he instilled belief in the national squad.
And convincing Kiwi players they were eligible to play for Wales if their ancestors had once shagged a girl called Bronwyn.....
-
@victor-meldrew said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
@dan54 said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
I always remember talking to a load of Welshmen during Lions tour to Aussie in 2001, and them asking me how NZ let Henry go, they thought he was great.
I've heard that too. His legacy was far more than simply coaching the national team and been told he was heavily involved in re-structuring the game in Wales.
As an aside, my Welsh mate's wife was an Assistant Headteacher and went to talk by Henry on education & extra-curricular activities. She said it was poss. the best lecture she'd ever been to and he was clearly top of tree on education thinking.
Yep Vic my daughter went to some safety education thing or something he spoke at a couple of years back and said he was most enlightening, and entertaining as he got message across.
-
@catogrande said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
@machpants said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
@victor-meldrew said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
@nepia said in All Blacks 2022:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2022:
@bones said in All Blacks 2022:
@dagrubster said in All Blacks 2022:
our leading most experienced coaches are not in NZ.
It's an easy thing to say, but how about some names? Jamie Joseph I think could be handy.....who else?
Schmidt is already in. Gatland?
The more involvement he has the worse the Chiefs are. When MacMillan has been in charge they look a much better team. Maybe his NH style doesn't work for our players?
IIRC, Gatland wasn't all that rated by many Welsh fans up to 2017 with his style of play being derided as "Warrenball", but he won 4 6N's has been relatively successful with the Lions.
Now he's full-time with the Chiefs we'll be able to see how good he is in SR and how he goes with the team over the next year.
Harsh, he is by far the most sucessful Lions coach ever!
Cough. Cough. Sir Ian McGeechan?
Nope lost too NZ, hardest tour to win. Garland got a draw, otherwise results equal, 50-50
-
@machpants said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
@catogrande said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
@machpants said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
@victor-meldrew said in Foster, Robertson, Rennie etc:
@nepia said in All Blacks 2022:
@victor-meldrew said in All Blacks 2022:
@bones said in All Blacks 2022:
@dagrubster said in All Blacks 2022:
our leading most experienced coaches are not in NZ.
It's an easy thing to say, but how about some names? Jamie Joseph I think could be handy.....who else?
Schmidt is already in. Gatland?
The more involvement he has the worse the Chiefs are. When MacMillan has been in charge they look a much better team. Maybe his NH style doesn't work for our players?
IIRC, Gatland wasn't all that rated by many Welsh fans up to 2017 with his style of play being derided as "Warrenball", but he won 4 6N's has been relatively successful with the Lions.
Now he's full-time with the Chiefs we'll be able to see how good he is in SR and how he goes with the team over the next year.
Harsh, he is by far the most sucessful Lions coach ever!
Cough. Cough. Sir Ian McGeechan?
Nope lost too NZ, hardest tour to win. Garland got a draw, otherwise results equal, 50-50
I'd say his two Lions tours wins puts him ahead of Gatland's one. A counter argument would say that they both have a 50% winning record, either way it kinda disproves an assertion that Gatland was "by far the most successful Lions coach ever".
