2023 (expanded) World Cup in South Africa

rotated

My favourite part is how Ireland is unfit to host a World Cup for having limited Stadia, shit weather and a poor RWC record while 1999 is the gold standard for World Cups and was hosted in fucking Wales.

Derm McCrum

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="JC" data-cid="554994" data-time="1454036477">
I went to the 95 RWC. There were theoretically lots of things to do but safaris and such were expensive and not necessarily convenient. All the activities were organised for us and we were warned in most places not to go out on the dazzle by ourselves. I haven't been back since so I'm not sure if it would be the same now. I had a great time but I recall a lot of travelling to and from, and in, airports, which are shit places with a hangover. 
On the other hand I've been to Ireland more times than I can count. Now the Irish team may be a pack of rabbit-punching thugs :fishing: but Ireland is fucking awesome. And that, by the way, is official. Anybody who says there isn't enough to do there is a fucking simpleton, and not someone with whom I would care to share a quiet pint and a yarn.</blockquote>
 
Can I use that in our tourism marketing literature? 
(Actually, I'm only asking out of politeness, I'm going to copy it anyway.)

Nepia

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="jegga" data-cid="554981" data-time="1454031227">
<div>
I'm not sure what you're talking about, SARU let Meyer pick at least half of the team.
</div>
</blockquote>
Half is a bit rough, there were more white players and Bryan Habana than that.
 
Just catching up with the Rowan posting on this thread, WT actual F??? He clearly is trying to out winger winger. Has anyone asked him/her their thoughts on vaccinations?

JC

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="Pot Hale" data-cid="554997" data-time="1454036901">
<div>
Can I use that in our tourism marketing literature? (Actually, I'm only asking out of politeness, I'm going to copy it anyway.)
</div>
</blockquote>
And why would I expect anything else from a light-fingered celt?

JC

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="Pot Hale" data-cid="554997" data-time="1454036901">
<div>
Can I use that in our tourism marketing literature? 
(Actually, I'm only asking out of politeness, I'm going to copy it anyway.)
</div>
</blockquote>
And also, what time do you get up in the morning? Or are you still at the pub?

Rancid Schnitzel

Christ guys. The troll has not only been fed, but has helped himself to 4th and 5th servings and is now raiding the dessert cart. Stop indulging it or it will keep coming back for more.

Smudge

The only thing that surprises me is that Rowan has reported posts. Usually trolls have a skin made of rhino hide, and let the robust insults just slide off their back. Not our Rowan though - he's got hurt feelings, he's got hurt feelings.

jegga

Rowan doesn't think he's a troll though , he thinks he's casting pearls of wisdom to the masses . That's why he's so hurt, " why are these people asking for proof ? Isn't the fact that I said it good enough?" 
No Rowan it isn't .

Catogrande

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="mariner4life" data-cid="554905" data-time="1454022324">
<div>
Dude, I'm loving your work, but wasn't 99 "in" Wales? And i have strange memories of watching the 2007 final in Paris.
</div>
</blockquote>
Aaaaaargh! Fuck it. Memory is a bastard. And what's more I do need to check my maths. Sorry Rowan.

Rowan

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="JC" data-cid="554994" data-time="1454036477">
<div>
I went to the 95 RWC. There were theoretically lots of things to do but safaris and such were expensive and not necessarily convenient. All the activities were organised for us and we were warned in most places not to go out on the razzle by ourselves. I haven't been back since so I'm not sure if it would be the same now. I had a great time but I recall a lot of travelling to and from, and in, airports, which are shit places with a hangover.
 
On the other hand I've been to Ireland more times than I can count. Now the Irish team may be a pack of rabbit-punching thugs :fishing: but Ireland is fucking awesome. And that, by the way, is official. Anybody who says there isn't enough to do there is a fucking simpleton, and not someone with whom I would care to share a quiet pint and a yarn.
</div>
</blockquote>
 
So now we're down to personal anecdotes.

Rowan

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="rotated" data-cid="554996" data-time="1454036878">
<div>
My favourite part is how Ireland is unfit to host a World Cup for having limited Stadia, shit weather and a poor RWC record while 1999 is the gold standard for World Cups and was hosted in fucking Wales.
</div>
</blockquote>
 
Almost everybody else here has been saying the 99 format was a shambles. I didn't think it was bad. Two very dramatic semis, and an historic win for Argentina over the Irish. Not the best World Cup ever, but far from the worst.
 
Of course, what you're overlooking here is that France, England, Scotland and Ireland were all involved in hosting this event. No way Wales could have done it on its own. So, once again, I think we can be pretty sure that, if awarded the event, Ireland would follow that fine tradition of immediately doing an about-face on the single host nation pledge and ship a bunch of games across to Britain - & possibly France, depending on how the behind-the-scenes wheeling and dealing played out.
 
So it really comes down to a 2nd World Cup in sunny, rugby-mad South Africa with its vast array of rugby-purpose stadia, or a 5th World Cup on the chilly, football-mad north-west tip of Europe, with games either crammed into Ireland's one major rugby venue and a bunch of creaky old converted Gaelic stadiums, or once again spread throughout the Home Unions and possbily France.

Derm McCrum

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="Rowan" data-cid="555098" data-time="1454069740">
Almost everybody else here has been saying the 99 format was a shambles. I didn't think it was bad. Two very dramatic semis, and an historic win for Argentina over the Irish. Not the best World Cup ever, but far from the worst. 
Of course, what you're overlooking here is that France, England, Scotland and Ireland were all involved in hosting this event. No way Wales could have done it on its own. So, once again, I think we can be pretty sure that, if awarded the event, Ireland would follow that fine tradition of immediately doing an about-face on the single host nation pledge and ship a bunch of games across to Britain - & possibly France, depending on how the behind-the-scenes wheeling and dealing played out. 
So it really comes down to a 2nd World Cup in sunny, rugby-mad South Africa with its vast array of rugby-purpose stadia, or a 5th World Cup on the chilly, football-mad north-west tip of Europe, with games either crammed into Ireland's one major rugby venue and a bunch of creaky old converted Gaelic stadiums, or once again spread throughout the Home Unions and possbily France.</blockquote>
 
Rowan. When did you visit Ireland - where did you go and what time of year? 
Simple question.

JC

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="Rowan" data-cid="555097" data-time="1454069622">
<div>
So now we're down to personal anecdotes.
</div>
</blockquote>
And? My anecdotes are just as worthy of filling space here as your opinion. And at least they have the benefit of being based on experience, whereas yours is based on Google, ignorance and hot air.
 
And it wasn't just an anecdote. There was an insult in there that could be construed as being aimed at you. Do you want me to point it out so you can report it?

Rowan

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="Pot Hale" data-cid="555103" data-time="1454081210">
<div>
Rowan. When did you visit Ireland - where did you go and what time of year? 
Simple question.
</div>
</blockquote>
 
April 2000. Dublin. Stayed in the Times Hostel, I think it was. Very chilly, not much above zero, but no rain as I recall. It was just a weekend trip I was working just out of Douglas on the Isle of Man at the time.

Rowan

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="JC" data-cid="555104" data-time="1454083376">
<div>
And? My anecdotes are just as worthy of filling space here as your opinion. And at least they have the benefit of being based on experience, whereas yours is based on Google, ignorance and hot air.
 
And it wasn't just an anecdote. There was an insult in there that could be construed as being aimed at you. Do you want me to point it out so you can report it?
</div>
</blockquote>
 
Well, my brother often goes on surfing trips to Durban and loves the place. A few of my friends have been there and done safari tours and all, and loved the place as well. None of them got shot or robbed or anything.

rotated

Another concern with hosting in South Africa is the current issue with pitch invaders with villainous intentions. I've only seen two pitch invaders make contact with players during a test and both were South African - the most recent being in this past RWC against Samoa. This is a clear trend which is googleable. I'm not sure we can even guarantee the safety of the players and officials on the paddock, let a lone off.

Rowan

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="Catogrande" data-cid="555036" data-time="1454056389">
<div>
Aaaaaargh! Fuck it. Memory is a bastard. And what's more I do need to check my maths. Sorry Rowan.
</div>
</blockquote>
 
No need to apologise. :)
 
Yes, France hosted as recently as 2007 and are probably only bidding this time to strengthen their case for 2027. I wouldn't be surprised at all if they ended up co-hosting with Italy. I only hope that Italy would be the senior partner in such a venture, though I suspect they would have to be the junior. Btw, previous Italian bids included the French city of Marseille among the proposed venues.
 
"Another concern with hosting in South Africa is the current issue with pitch invaders with villainous intentions. I've only seen two pitch invaders make contact with players during a test and both were South African - the most recent being in this past RWC against Samoa. This is a clear trend which is googleable. I'm not sure we can even guarantee the safety of the players and officials on the paddock, let a lone off."
 
 :mocking: Grasping at straws there, I think. That would easily be dealt with. & there have been plenty of pitch invasions elsewhere, including NZ:

Football cancellation in Europe because of terrorist threat: <a data-ipb='nomediaparse' href='http://www.irishnews.com/news/2015/11/17/news/football-match-cancelled-due-to-bomb-fears-326875/'>http://www.irishnews.com/news/2015/11/17/news/football-match-cancelled-due-to-bomb-fears-326875/</a>
Football cancellations in Ireland because of terrible weather: <a data-ipb='nomediaparse' href='http://www.bbc.com/sport/football/35333560'>http://www.bbc.com/sport/football/35333560</a>

Derm McCrum

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="Rowan" data-cid="555105" data-time="1454084902">
<div>
April 2000. Dublin. Stayed in the Times Hostel, I think it was. Very chilly, not much above zero, but no rain as I recall. It was just a weekend trip I was working just out of Douglas on the Isle of Man at the time.
</div>
</blockquote>
 
Yep - it was the coolest April since 1989. Temps ranged from 8-15 in Dublin. And it would be fair to say that you have little or no personal experience of the country. 
 
South Africa and Ireland are both popular tourist destinations, as evidenced by their growing tourist numbers each year. Each has its own attractions. The size of cities and places is not really relevant in the context of Ireland - particularly when the plan is to spread the games around the country as opposed to all in one place. 
 
You have your view on the quality of the stadia in each country. Clearly South Africa has more of them. But it's not just about how many, it's also where they are located, facilities and resources around them, and ease of access for people moving around. 
 
The "creaking old stadiums" that you've referred to are listed in an earlier post of mine. Most of them have been or are currently being re-developed within the last ten years, simply because the demand and market is there for them. There is an inevitable amount of facilities upgrading to be done to number of them for media, catering, etc, but all entirely achievable, budgeted for, underwritten, and capable of being completed within time. I think you'll find that some of the stadia in South Africa are also "old", but they have had similar upgrades over the years.
 
In terms of capacity, the stadia used in England ranged from Sandy Park 12,300 to 5 stadia in the 30-40k capacity, 3 in the 50-53k range and 3 in the 70-90 range.
 
Ireland doesn't have the same spread clearly. However, Croke Park, which has been used Six Nations tournaments previously, would host opening and finals stage matches with Lansdowne Road taking some of the other big matches. There are a couple of other 50ks, 30-40ks, and 25ks. All of them suitable for use. The numbers have to stack up.
 
It's fair comment to say that Ireland could well turn around and say that they are going to use the Millennium stadium in Wales in order to drive up numbers. But the financial proposal submitted has to stack up on an all-island basis first with the resources and facilities that are here, not elsewhere. During the assessment and feasibility stages, partnerships with other nations, notably Scotland and Wales in a putative Celtic RWC bid, were considered and dropped. We'll have to wait and see what happens, but I know there is a strong determination that it will only be hosted in Ireland, and nowhere else, despite the inevitable vote-trading that happens around these bids. 
 
PS The European surfing championships have been regularly held in Ireland around Bundoran on North-West coast - best times being Sept-Dec. No one gets shot or robbed - or eaten by sharks even. :)

Rowan

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="Pot Hale" data-cid="555110" data-time="1454088624">
<div>
Yep - it was the coolest April since 1989. Temps ranged from 8-15 in Dublin. And it would be fair to say that you have little or no personal experience of the country. 
 
South Africa and Ireland are both popular tourist destinations, as evidenced by their growing tourist numbers each year. Each has its own attractions. The size of cities and places is not really relevant in the context of Ireland - particularly when the plan is to spread the games around the country as opposed to all in one place. 
 
You have your view on the quality of the stadia in each country. Clearly South Africa has more of them. But it's not just about how many, it's also where they are located, facilities and resources around them, and ease of access for people moving around. 
 
The "creaking old stadiums" that you've referred to are listed in an earlier post of mine. Most of them have been or are currently being re-developed within the last ten years, simply because the demand and market is there for them. There is an inevitable amount of facilities upgrading to be done to number of them for media, catering, etc, but all entirely achievable, budgeted for, underwritten, and capable of being completed within time. I think you'll find that some of the stadia in South Africa are also "old", but they have had similar upgrades over the years.
 
In terms of capacity, the stadia used in England ranged from Sandy Park 12,300 to 5 stadia in the 30-40k capacity, 3 in the 50-53k range and 3 in the 70-90 range.
 
Ireland doesn't have the same spread clearly. However, Croke Park, which has been used Six Nations tournaments previously, would host opening and finals stage matches with Lansdowne Road taking some of the other big matches. There are a couple of other 50ks, 30-40ks, and 25ks. All of them suitable for use. The numbers have to stack up.
 
It's fair comment to say that Ireland could well turn around and say that they are going to use the Millennium stadium in Wales in order to drive up numbers. But the financial proposal submitted has to stack up on an all-island basis first with the resources and facilities that are here, not elsewhere. During the assessment and feasibility stages, partnerships with other nations, notably Scotland and Wales in a putative Celtic RWC bid, were considered and dropped. We'll have to wait and see what happens, but I know there is a strong determination that it will only be hosted in Ireland, and nowhere else, despite the inevitable vote-trading that happens around these bids. 
 
PS The European surfing championships have been regularly held in Ireland around Bundoran on North-West coast - best times being Sept-Dec. No one gets shot or robbed - or eaten by sharks even. :)
</div>
</blockquote>
 
Coolest April since 89? Just my luck! But I have provided figures from the Irish meteorological servce which indicate both Dublin and Belfast are generally quite cool and wet in May as well.
 
Yes, my only point about the stadia is that South Africa has more - and much of it rugby-purpose. I'm not saying Ireland couldn't host it. They certainly could. But what kind of a tournament would it be? That's my main concern, and I've already expressed the reasons why, without going over it again. & even if we were to consider the bids entirely equal on merit, then it really comes down to whether World Rugby wants to rotate its tournament around the continents, or just send it back to France & the Home Unions on every second occasion. It comes down to whether South Africa should receive it again almost 30 years after doing such a fantastic job the first time, or whether the British Isles should be involved in hosting it for a 5th time, just 8 years after England - while Ireland would be involved for the third time. It comes down to whether it is staged in the world's 2nd largest rugby community, and a nation which has won two World Cups to date, or whether it is staged in the world's 7th largest rugby community, and a nation which has never made a World Cup semi-final.

taniwharugby

<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="Rowan" data-cid="555098" data-time="1454069740">Almost everybody else here has been saying the 99 format was a shambles. I didn't think it was bad.</blockquote> 
<blockquote class="ipsBlockquote" data-author="Rowan" data-cid="555097" data-time="1454069622">So now we're down to personal anecdotes.</blockquote>

The Silver Fern

2023 (expanded) World Cup in South Africa