North vs South

voodoo

Lots of love for A Smith on here tonight. This is a bit controversial, but I thought he was average. Sure, a class above TJ, but hardly impressive. Indecisive, sloppy, lots of telling but not much actual engagement.

Obviously our #1 HB and has had an amazing season, but tonight? Not so much.

Machpants

@sparky said in North vs South:

Wil Jordan must be a starting AB.

One catch and try, an all black does not make. I only watched the second half, but that was it from him. As to Clark, his throw randomly in field cost the North the game. So neither test match ready

Yeetyaah

Highlanders players fucked it up for the North in the final 5.

Tim

@Machpants Might be Rieko on the wing this year. Don't like any of our 12 options.

sparky

@Tim said in North vs South:

@sparky Why? His defence is poor on the wing and Barrett is a better fullback.

He has gas and nerves of steel.

Machpants

@Tim said in North vs South:

@Machpants Might be Rieko on the wing this year. Don't like any of our 12 options.

Seems trendy to play 13s at 12 this year

Bovidae

Also, Moody seems to have inherited the invisibility cloak at the breakdown. He never gets penalised for entering from the side and going off his feet.

Tim

@sparky oh calm down.

sparky

@Tim Perfectly calm, thank you.

Rebound

@junior plus he missed the initial effort. That's bad considering Saves was penalised for the same thing earlier in the half

Mokey

Some really great tries scored tonight. Shame that Ash Dixon saved his worst game for the North. Ioane was good (he and McKenzie worked well together), Will Jordan will probably be an AB sooner rather than later, Caleb Clarke also. Whitelock was the better captain.

Few current ABs that really went MIA though.

antipodean

@Rebound said in North vs South:

@antipodean clearly it's not a a matter of understanding the law. Your link to the laws governing a maul does not back up your case. Because the only things in this instance that you can claim to being in place for the maul to continue. Is point 13 & 13 of the laws. Defending players internationally leaving the maul. Neither happened. So like the ref, my interpretation is the maul is over the moment the attacking team broke off.

That wasn't the ref's interpretation - he penalised them for Laulala's actions.

I'm uninterested in explaining this to you any further.

Toddy

Was great to see Hoskins step up at this higher level. A few north towards did themselves no favours. Ardie & Patty we're average as. Aioane was real disappointing. Seems to have so much potential but can't find it consistently. Worst loosie on the park tonight.

antipodean

@Toddy said in North vs South:

@antipodean True. Just look at what he and his captaincy ability brought to the Chiefs this year.

So by the same measure Whitelock isn't a good captain, he's just surrounded by better players.

Rebound

@antipodean where did the ref say this. I might have missed it, but he explained that he's opinion is the maul was over and the players Infront of the ball carriers caused obstruction. that's what he explained to the captain

Bovidae

All those praising Whitelock's captaincy at the end are going overboard. Coltman throws another crooked lineout and we are saying why did he choose to kick to the corner. He would have been holding his breath like the rest of us.

Yeetyaah

I've seen someone on facebook say that this game is the reason why Whitelock would be a better AB captain. Because they won and All Black trial match? Pretty silly analogy.

Bones

@gt12 said in North vs South:

@Machpants

Stocks went up:

Sanders
Clarke
Rioane
Dmac
Jordan

Best on park:

Whitelock
Rioane
Clarke
Smith

Ok had to stop reading the thread here. Wtf??

Bones

@Siam said in North vs South:

Jordan might be a smokey for the AB's tomorrow?

😂 Oh yeah that would be such a massive surprise...

PecoTrain

@sparky said in North vs South:

@Yeetyaah said in North vs South:

Ardie you beast

Ardie wins you tight matches.

Followed by an Ardie penalty that contributes the the loss.

The Silver Fern

North vs South