Blues vs Crusaders

[Tim]

Collins!

[Machpants]

Collins fault he's so crap

[hydro11]

I'm okay with the outcome. Seems like a strange reasoning. Intent doesn't normally matter.

[Bones]

Seems fair here - otherwise we're gonna be penalising guys in the lineout when they try to tap it down but accidentally knock it on.

[antipodean]

@hydro11 said in Blues vs Crusaders:

I'm okay with the outcome. Seems like a strange reasoning. Intent doesn't normally matter.

How can you be ok with the outcome?

[gt12]

Christ - look at Nonu with the mismatch if Collins has passed behind there.

[Tim]

@antipodean Fuck me. even TJ is shocked.

[kiwiinmelb]

Missed a sitter , how will he kick this

[hydro11]

@antipodean said in Blues vs Crusaders:

@hydro11 said in Blues vs Crusaders:

I'm okay with the outcome. Seems like a strange reasoning. Intent doesn't normally matter.

How can you be ok with the outcome?

I don't really think deliberate knock ons should be penalties (generally). I would say it should have to be a slap down for a penalty - that isn't how it tends to be refereed though.

[hydro11]

He'll probably kick this.

[Bones]

@antipodean said in Blues vs Crusaders:

Not a deliberate knock on? WTF is the clown smoking?

It's not a deliberate knock on. How many penalties are we gonna have if we start penalising people for accidental knock ons?

[Kirwan]

God, can he get the kick?

[antipodean]

@hydro11 said in Blues vs Crusaders:

@antipodean said in Blues vs Crusaders:

@hydro11 said in Blues vs Crusaders:

I'm okay with the outcome. Seems like a strange reasoning. Intent doesn't normally matter.

How can you be ok with the outcome?

I don't really think deliberate knock ons should be penalties (generally). I would say it should have to be a slap down for a penalty - that isn't how it tends to be refereed though.

That's the dumbest refereeing. Anyone who has played knows you can knock a ball up with no ability or intent to ever manage an intercept.

[Kirwan]

@Kirwan said in Blues vs Crusaders:

God, can he get the kick?

Close!

[Machpants]

@hydro11 said in Blues vs Crusaders:

I'm okay with the outcome. Seems like a strange reasoning. Intent doesn't normally matter.

Intent does matter with "deliberate" knock on, Without assessing intent, how can you call deliberate or not?

[Bones]

@hydro11 said in Blues vs Crusaders:

@antipodean said in Blues vs Crusaders:

@hydro11 said in Blues vs Crusaders:

I'm okay with the outcome. Seems like a strange reasoning. Intent doesn't normally matter.

How can you be ok with the outcome?

I don't really think deliberate knock ons should be penalties (generally). I would say it should have to be a slap down for a penalty - that isn't how it tends to be refereed though.

Are you meaning if someone taps it forward but up? Shouldn't be a penalty? Oh yes it fucken should.

[antipodean]

@Bones said in Blues vs Crusaders:

@antipodean said in Blues vs Crusaders:

Not a deliberate knock on? WTF is the clown smoking?

It's not a deliberate knock on. How many penalties are we gonna have if we start penalising people for accidental knock ons?

It is deliberate because it didn't go backwards and he didn't catch it. That removes any "judgement".

[ShadowTrooper]

Geez we need to find some credible goslkickers before the WC

[gt12]

They were also about a mile offside.

The Saders have been very good at times, but I think they’ve also been over the line with their discipline.

Looks like it’s going to pay off though.

[antipodean]

Another dumb option from Pulu.