Crusaders v Hurricanes - SF
-
Boyd's attitude about Jordie at 13 is in direct contrast to the tough calls that Razor has been making.
It comes across as 'he wants to play there and he's kind of OK, I prefer him at 15 but will give him a go'. It smacks of trying to fit the names in rather than planning the best balance. -
@crucial it’s a little surprising but other than Goosen, who is a better winger in my view, what are the options?
I think Savea shouldn’t be starting and NMS should play wing and Jordie at fullback. Goosen moves to centre. But that won’t work because that leaves Savea for the bench and I don’t think that’s what they want.
-
@act-crusader said in Crusaders v Hurricanes - SF:
Goosen, who is a better winger
Not a good wing IMO. Better centre.
-
There would/could have been another option, if the Canes, like the Chiefs, Crusaders & Highlanders, would have given more game time to rookies during the regular season. I may have mentioned a player a few times on the Fern. Promising centre/winger.
-
@stargazer said in Crusaders v Hurricanes - SF:
There would/could have been another option, if the Canes, like the Chiefs, Crusaders & Highlanders, would have given more game time to rookies during the regular season. I may have mentioned a player a few times on the Fern. Promising centre/winger.
Umaga-Jensen?
-
-
@stargazer said in Crusaders v Hurricanes - SF:
@pukunui No, IIRC, PU-J is a fullback but they played him at 12 in his one and only game this season. I was referring to Jonah Lowe, whose preferred position is centre, but he can play at both wings.
Sorry, lame joke.
I agree that it's crazy Lowe didn't get more time this season given the injuries they have had in midfield. Moving Jordie from his best position and playing a back three of Lam/NMS/Jules hasn't worked. -
@crucial said in Crusaders v Hurricanes - SF:
Boyd's attitude about Jordie at 13 is in direct contrast to the tough calls that Razor has been making.
Yeah Razor with those tough calls to make - 'Gee how do i fit all these ABs into the 23 this week? Oh I can't - Dagg and Crockett won't make it this week'
-
@act-crusader said in Crusaders v Hurricanes - SF:
@machpants I’d take Mo’unga’s form over Barrett’s this season.
Imagine Beaudy behind the Crusaders pack.
-
@antipodean said in Crusaders v Hurricanes - SF:
@act-crusader said in Crusaders v Hurricanes - SF:
@machpants I’d take Mo’unga’s form over Barrett’s this season.
Imagine Beaudy behind the Crusaders pack.
Yeah it’s his AB form circa 2018...mmm...
-
Hard to show form when you're not on the field.
-
@act-crusader Good to see that the movement is there for a completely untested Super-Rugby player to overtake a very good test player. Is it Damien McKenzie? Or is it someone else?
Even better things will happen when Tim Perry is comically included in the All Blacks, and people take a performance against the 2nd tier nation France as proof that Scott Barrett is a test lock.
Look forward to big test match performances from Luke Whitelock and Liam Squire too. Maybe fit in Ardie Savea as well.
-
@kiwimurph said in Crusaders v Hurricanes - SF:
@crucial said in Crusaders v Hurricanes - SF:
Boyd's attitude about Jordie at 13 is in direct contrast to the tough calls that Razor has been making.
Yeah Razor with those tough calls to make - 'Gee how do i fit all these ABs into the 23 this week? Oh I can't - Dagg and Crockett won't make it this week'
It's like the Ricky Ponting captaincy dilemma.
"Shit, i need a wicket, who do i toss the ball to, Warnie or McGrath?"
-
Razor has to be next AB coach doesn't he? The Saders were arse raped by the Canes in 2016. He's turned that round and he's done it with frequent injuries to his best players.
Surely there's no farking way Foster could get the nod over him even with Shag's blessing.
-
@rancid-schnitzel said in Crusaders v Hurricanes - SF:
Razor has to be next AB coach doesn't he?
Well, there is Joe Schmidt too.
-
@rancid-schnitzel he must surely be on the higher honours radar. Though they may want to see if he's another Rennie. Great intially but then couldn't crack the big one once other teams figure them out.
