Crusaders 2019
-
I see that argument but feel like it is different to an academy, which should be purely about development of NZ talent.
I could be wrong, but I think some of those examples (or at least some others from the Chiefs at least) are funded by cooperative agreements.
Also, he's not a PI player - he's an Australian. There's no development of the 2nd tier argument to be made either.
At best, it's an attempted poach; at worst, it's pissing away money to develop an Aussie player.
Now, if the money is the Crusaders alone; that's fine. However, if it's funded by NZ rugby, somebody should have to explain that investment.
-
@gt12 said in Crusaders 2019:
I see that argument but feel like it is different to an academy, which should be purely about development of NZ talent.
I could be wrong, but I think some of those examples (or at least some others from the Chiefs at least) are funded by cooperative agreements.
Also, he's not a PI player - he's an Australian. There's no development of the 2nd tier argument to be made either.
At best, it's an attempted poach; at worst, it's pissing away money to develop an Aussie player.
Now, if the money is the Crusaders alone; that's fine. However, if it's funded by NZ rugby, somebody should have to explain that investment.
If it's NZRU money, how is itr any different to paying James Haskell, Tyler Ardron etc? Playing Super rugby here is going to be as beneficial - if not moreso - to a guys' development as being in an academy. At least if a guy has been in an academy, someone has thought at some stage that they might play for NZ.
-
Yeah Frost struggled to start for his club side so was not really going to hang round.
-
@98blueandgold And in the meantime kept a local promising player out of the academy.
-
-
@Chris said in Crusaders 2019:
https://crusaders.co.nz/news/1340-squad-named-to-travel-to-south-africa
So no Jordan, Enari, Funnell or Cameron. Hunt seems to be preferred again. Last ditch effort to re-sign him?
-
I am guessing no Jordan because of his injury? Didn't see the game last night. What did he injure?
-
@Crazy-Horse Foot or ankle.
-
@Cyclops said in Crusaders 2019:
@Chris said in Crusaders 2019:
https://crusaders.co.nz/news/1340-squad-named-to-travel-to-south-africa
So no Jordan, Enari, Funnell or Cameron. Hunt seems to be preferred again. Last ditch effort to re-sign him?
A much less speculative reason could be that Hunt is their 2nd best first five-eighth. Why leave him in NZ and opt for a player that's not even up to SR level?
-
No Harmon either.
Strange not going is an interesting one after missing the squad last night - injured or demoted?
Jordan will be out due to injury - he limped off immediately he damaged something, so presumably knew it was a strain or tear rather than a knock.
On the injured list at present: Franks, Faingaanuku, Jordan, Perry - plus Dagg and Mataele gone for the season.
-
@Stargazer said in Crusaders 2019:
@Cyclops said in Crusaders 2019:
@Chris said in Crusaders 2019:
https://crusaders.co.nz/news/1340-squad-named-to-travel-to-south-africa
So no Jordan, Enari, Funnell or Cameron. Hunt seems to be preferred again. Last ditch effort to re-sign him?
A much less speculative reason could be that Hunt is their 2nd best first five-eighth. Why leave him in NZ and opt for a player that's not even up to SR level?
Except that up until now Cameron seemed to have been generally preferred to Hunt.
-
@Cyclops said in Crusaders 2019:
@Stargazer said in Crusaders 2019:
@Cyclops said in Crusaders 2019:
@Chris said in Crusaders 2019:
https://crusaders.co.nz/news/1340-squad-named-to-travel-to-south-africa
So no Jordan, Enari, Funnell or Cameron. Hunt seems to be preferred again. Last ditch effort to re-sign him?
A much less speculative reason could be that Hunt is their 2nd best first five-eighth. Why leave him in NZ and opt for a player that's not even up to SR level?
Except that up until now Cameron seemed to have been generally preferred to Hunt.
Not sure that's right. Pretty sure Mitch had the bench for the first few games. Then Cameron had a run of about four games - including a start vs the Waratahs and a cameo where he came on (against the Canes?) and his only significant contribution was a terribly sliced penalty touchfinder.
Since then it's been back to Mitch. I'd guess it's 7-4 or possibly 6-5 to Mitch in terms of appearances.
-
Who's coming off that CBHS production line?
I guess Fergus Burke is in the frame somewhere since he's been brought down from the north?
Watch: Aaron Cruden's brother duels the next Beauden Barrett
The crossing of paths between Stewart Cruden and Fergus Burke could prove to be an historic one in the future.
-
@Higgins said in Crusaders 2019:
@98blueandgold And in the meantime kept a local promising player out of the academy.
I don't think there are any restrictions on numbers in academies, within reason. So I'm sure any promising locks would be involved.
-
@Chris-B said in Crusaders 2019:
Who's coming off that CBHS production line?
I guess Fergus Burke is in the frame somewhere since he's been brought down from the north?
Watch: Aaron Cruden's brother duels the next Beauden Barrett
The crossing of paths between Stewart Cruden and Fergus Burke could prove to be an historic one in the future.
Who's next? Assuming we don't like Fletcher Smith (and i don't), check out who's covering 10 for the Highlanders tonight.
-
@Chris-B said in Crusaders 2019:
@Cyclops said in Crusaders 2019:
@Stargazer said in Crusaders 2019:
@Cyclops said in Crusaders 2019:
@Chris said in Crusaders 2019:
https://crusaders.co.nz/news/1340-squad-named-to-travel-to-south-africa
So no Jordan, Enari, Funnell or Cameron. Hunt seems to be preferred again. Last ditch effort to re-sign him?
A much less speculative reason could be that Hunt is their 2nd best first five-eighth. Why leave him in NZ and opt for a player that's not even up to SR level?
Except that up until now Cameron seemed to have been generally preferred to Hunt.
Not sure that's right. Pretty sure Mitch had the bench for the first few games. Then Cameron had a run of about four games - including a start vs the Waratahs and a cameo where he came on (against the Canes?) and his only significant contribution was a terribly sliced penalty touchfinder.
Since then it's been back to Mitch. I'd guess it's 7-4 or possibly 6-5 to Mitch in terms of appearances.
It had felt to me like Cameron had gone past Hunt with the Waratahs start and bench opportunities. But you're probably right that the poor performances and maybe a bit of rotation are a more likely explanation.
