ABs vs Kangaroos?
-
The window was apparently two weeks to a month after the RWC. Yeah OK. Win, lose or draw there's no fucking way the abs would want to play a game like that right after the RWC.
I don't mind if club teams or even a select group of players do something like this, but not the abs. No way.
-
I decided to click on one of the articles on Stuff and the hybrid game sounds farking ridiculous!
There would be 13 players per team (plus seven reserves), there would be lineouts but no lifting and the team in possession would have 60 seconds to cross the halfway line playing league rules, at which point, the referees would call change of play to rugby union laws.
-
I used to like watching the crossover games that the UK club champs for league and rugby played way back when.
-
This hybrid league nonsense raises its head occasionally. It's all about league trying to get some international relevance and some rugby following Australians trying to get the level of support league does in the delusion that this would make them rugby superpowers. Like England.
Add to that a healthy dose of used car salesmen looking for that one big break to catapult them into that middle ground between miners and mine owning bogans, the whole thing is an immense pile of shit.
The Daily Telegraph themselves must have been laughing as they wrote it: Kieran Read v Wade Graham, Boyd Cordner v Samuel Whitelock - giving away 22 cm and 32 kilos in just two forwards.
-
@act-crusader at least they were a half of league and a half of rugby, this 'hybrid game' sounds stupid.
-
-
@bovidae said in ABs vs Kangaroos?:
I remember watching the Wigan-Bath clashes in 1996. They were full games of each code.
Wiki says Wigan won the RL game 82-6 and Bath won the rugby game 44-19. Wigan was very good back then and were much fitter than their rugby counterparts.
Inga played flanker for Wigan.
-
Who wouldn't want to watch this?!! I don't care if you are a purist or not, there would not be a NZ man, women, cat, dog or amoeba that would not take a passing interest in this.
Of course its not going to happen but whats wrong with talking about who would win? We would only need to play our backs with Ardie, Read and Coles. No locks, no props. And we'd win. SWB, Laumape, c'mon, you already know.
-
@raznomore said in ABs vs Kangaroos?:
Who wouldn't want to watch this?!! I don't care if you are a purist or not, there would not be a NZ man, women, cat, dog or amoeba that would not take a passing interest in this.
Of course its not going to happen but whats wrong with talking about who would win? We would only need to play our backs with Ardie, Read and Coles. No locks, no props. And we'd win. SWB, Laumape, c'mon, you already know.
No Cane? He'd be great as a tackling machine.
I'd prefer a one game of each than any of this hybrid shit. And I guess the Kangaroos would win the league and the ABs would pummel them in the rugby.
Funnily enough, although he's departing, I think the TKB would be the best bet to play dummy half, good at running from the base and strong defence.
-
@raznomore said in ABs vs Kangaroos?:
No locks, no props.
If there are scrums and rucks I'd want locks and props. It would quickly become a game of 13 vs 7.
-
More pertinent, a 2003 clash between a now fully professional Sale and St Helens was also played (one half of each code). Jason Robinson was playing for Sale.
Sale won the 1st half of RU 41-0 and St Helens scored 39 pts in the 2nd half of RL. Final score 41-39.
-
@antipodean I think the best spectacle is to go more into the league variant. There would be no real scrums as the league boys do not have props with the right training to compete. Thus not requiring locks either.
-
@raznomore said in ABs vs Kangaroos?:
@antipodean I think the best spectacle is to go more into the league variant.
Then what's the point if you remove the very thing that makes the two games different; a contest for possession? That's a spectacle like Joseph Merrick
-
@antipodean which is why it'd never truly work.
As it is, the hybrid version wants to go back 30 years to pre-lifting days.
Reckon their best bet, would be to get 20 Union players to play League, just for the festival side of things, whereas finding a competent forward pack of league players in Australia purely for the safety side of things would be impossible
-
@taniwharugby yip thats essentially it in a nut shell. Forget about which is the better game. We know that already, make it about which is the better athlete.
-
@raznomore said in ABs vs Kangaroos?:
@taniwharugby yip thats essentially it in a nut shell. Forget about which is the better game. We know that already, make it about which is the better athlete.
A decathlon?
-
@antipodean eat some ice cream do some bombs!
-
@taniwharugby said in ABs vs Kangaroos?:
@antipodean eat some ice cream do some bombs!
