Rugby World Cup general discussion
-
@bayimports yep, because after all, NH teams think people will target this and sacrifice a player to take him out
:jokingnotjoking
-
You would have to target him if he plays , not to the head but hard physical contact within the laws .
Why make it easy ?
Boks won’t need reminding 😁
-
@canefan said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
@taniwharugby said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
@canefan am sure they have some top medical people on it, but agree from my layman position, seems very risky.
I heard some talk of a mask. That may be fine in basketball, but rugby is far more physically confronting. Mask or not, one big shot to the face and he's in big trouble
Very Phantom of the Opera...
-
What are they calling an exit success?
-
@taniwharugby Stats can be a bit misleading, these should add up to 200% points to reach QF, not just under 400 haha
-
@taniwharugby said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
What are they calling an exit success?
that screams Glen Jackson
-
@Machpants said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
@taniwharugby Stats can be a bit misleading, these should add up to 200% points to reach QF, not just under 400 haha
No, because all of those teams (2 teams from each pool) are going to make the quarter finals so that's why they are each almost at 100% probability.
-
@LABCAT said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
@Machpants said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
@taniwharugby Stats can be a bit misleading, these should add up to 200% points to reach QF, not just under 400 haha
No, because all of those teams (2 teams from each pool) are going to make the quarter finals so that's why they are each almost at 100% probability.
d'oh yup I was thinking semi
-
-
@Nepia said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
I just don't understand the line between yellow and red anymore.
this has been the case for at least a year or so now.
Dipping, absorbing, all sorts of defence applied, except when it isnt.
-
Are we allowed to be a bit disappointed in the performance of Samoa and Tonga in this cup?
They have never had greater access to players than they do now. Both teams loaded with pros, including ex-Internationals from higher ranked teams. And they have been pretty ordinary. Each will probably get a soft kill to at least get a win on the board, but they haven't been great.
-
@mariner4life said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
Are we allowed to be a bit disappointed in the performance of Samoa and Tonga in this cup?
They have never had greater access to players than they do now. Both teams loaded with pros, including ex-Internationals from higher ranked teams. And they have been pretty ordinary. Each will probably get a soft kill to at least get a win on the board, but they haven't been great.
Totally agree, Fiji is almost overachieving with last-minute coach change and all sorts of (as standard) financial and governance shenanigans at the union. But Samoa and Tonga have pretty much sucked. The same can be said for Japan, I guess Joseph not getting all his players for a year-long camp this time has impacted them
-
@mariner4life said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
Are we allowed to be a bit disappointed in the performance of Samoa and Tonga in this cup?
They have never had greater access to players than they do now. Both teams loaded with pros, including ex-Internationals from higher ranked teams. And they have been pretty ordinary. Each will probably get a soft kill to at least get a win on the board, but they haven't been great.
The ex internationals have been fairly average across the board, including the ones that get brought up frequently as ones that NZ could do with.
-
-
@mariner4life said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
Are we allowed to be a bit disappointed in the performance of Samoa and Tonga in this cup?
They have never had greater access to players than they do now. Both teams loaded with pros, including ex-Internationals from higher ranked teams. And they have been pretty ordinary. Each will probably get a soft kill to at least get a win on the board, but they haven't been great.
Tonga look unfit, and TBH poorly coached.
Samoa don't look as smart as their pro paycheques might indicate. I'm halfway through the Japan game and they're just trying to bash their way to a win. Again: poorly coached.
Or both sides are just ignoring the coach and doing what they want.
-
@NTA said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
@mariner4life said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
Are we allowed to be a bit disappointed in the performance of Samoa and Tonga in this cup?
They have never had greater access to players than they do now. Both teams loaded with pros, including ex-Internationals from higher ranked teams. And they have been pretty ordinary. Each will probably get a soft kill to at least get a win on the board, but they haven't been great.
Tonga look unfit, and TBH poorly coached.
Samoa don't look as smart as their pro paycheques might indicate. I'm halfway through the Japan game and they're just trying to bash their way to a win. Again: poorly coached.
Or both sides are just ignoring the coach and doing what they want.
Actually the bashing straight up the guts is what got them back in it
-
@MiketheSnow said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
@NTA said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
@mariner4life said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
Are we allowed to be a bit disappointed in the performance of Samoa and Tonga in this cup?
They have never had greater access to players than they do now. Both teams loaded with pros, including ex-Internationals from higher ranked teams. And they have been pretty ordinary. Each will probably get a soft kill to at least get a win on the board, but they haven't been great.
Tonga look unfit, and TBH poorly coached.
Samoa don't look as smart as their pro paycheques might indicate. I'm halfway through the Japan game and they're just trying to bash their way to a win. Again: poorly coached.
Or both sides are just ignoring the coach and doing what they want.
Actually the bashing straight up the guts is what got them back in it
I'm more of the opinion that it was smarter play rather than just bash. Pick n go rather than trying to grunt it up in channel 1 or 2 removed Japan's advantage: speed.
Japan were determined to play line defence and probably let them carry a few too many times from pick n go - most teams can't get more than a couple of those away because eventually they get turned over.
Japan weren't interested in the ruck unless it was one of their back row getting an isolated runner a distance from the previous ruck.
-
@NTA said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
@MiketheSnow said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
@NTA said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
@mariner4life said in Rugby World Cup general discussion:
Are we allowed to be a bit disappointed in the performance of Samoa and Tonga in this cup?
They have never had greater access to players than they do now. Both teams loaded with pros, including ex-Internationals from higher ranked teams. And they have been pretty ordinary. Each will probably get a soft kill to at least get a win on the board, but they haven't been great.
Tonga look unfit, and TBH poorly coached.
Samoa don't look as smart as their pro paycheques might indicate. I'm halfway through the Japan game and they're just trying to bash their way to a win. Again: poorly coached.
Or both sides are just ignoring the coach and doing what they want.
Actually the bashing straight up the guts is what got them back in it
I'm more of the opinion that it was smarter play rather than just bash. Pick n go rather than trying to grunt it up in channel 1 or 2 removed Japan's advantage: speed.
Japan were determined to play line defence and probably let them carry a few too many times from pick n go - most teams can't get more than a couple of those away because eventually they get turned over.
Japan weren't interested in the ruck unless it was one of their back row getting an isolated runner a distance from the previous ruck.
Absolutely
I simplified it, possibly oversimplified it
There was no advantage to spinning it wide against a fast defence with one extra player
Great in the moment adjustment from Samoa
