All Blacks 2023
-
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Blacks 2023:
Think it's going to take some challenging-the-norm thinking at a lot more levels than just the AB Head Coach.
but that is where it starts...the AB scrum efficiency lead to the roll out of the cron method, if Razor has some immediate success they will no doubt look to bottle that too.
I can only speak of what I see here, but players dont lack the skills, more seems at club and schoolboy they use similar game plans to our super teams and ABs, those dinky little kicks in the 22 and the inability to deal with a rush defence and other oft complained about tactics or lack therefor...I think, fresh ideas from the top will filter pretty quick, but I just hope we dont end up all in and neglect continued innovation.
-
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks 2023:
but that is where it starts...the AB scrum efficiency lead to the roll out of the cron method, if Razor has some immediate success they will no doubt look to bottle that too.
OK, everyone will want to copy the AB's, I get that, but maybe that's a big part of the problem. It works OK when things are going well but there's a real risk of stale thinking and inertia setting in when other countries catch-up or adapt. It becomes a vicious circle or closed loop.
We all want Robertson (or any AB Head Coach) to lead us to the promised land but we need players with the right physical and mental skills to do that. Overall, NZ rugby needs to think, challenge and innovate rather than just copy what the AB's do.
-
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Blacks 2023:
It works OK when things are going well but there's a real risk of stale thinking and inertia setting in when other countries catch-up or adapt. It becomes a vicious circle or closed loop.
that is exactly what has happened, and what I said above I hoped doesnt happen again if Razor is successful
-
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks 2023:
that is exactly what has happened, and what I said above I hoped doesnt happen again if Razor is successful
The problems (and solutions) in NZ Rugby run way deeper than whoever is All Blacks Head Coach IMHO. You can have the best quality roof in the world on your house but if the rafters and walls are crap, it'll still come tumbling down
-
@Victor-Meldrew but the problem in NZR is it is run from the top down, ABs are the shop window, and naturally people will try to replicate.
Coaching travels the same way, top down with ideas and practices, key is not stopping those that venture out of the box, and while only rumour, we kept hearing that Razor wasnt looked upon fondly due to this reason....which as it turns out, wasnt an issue, but maybe there was a tiny bit of truth in it?
-
@Crazy-Horse said in All Blacks 2023:
@Dan54 said in All Blacks 2023:
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks 2023:
@Chris I think that's the key, being able to adapt and adjust.
In years gone by, more often we were able to control the play and tempo, and even when we didn't we had superior fitness to outrun teams...
Now we seem to rely on an old game plan that is proven to be ineffective in tight battles with top teams, we are no longer fitter than everyone else, we have lost our cutting edge, relying on a once tried and true formula...are we too arrogant to see the successes of others and learn from them, then improve them.
Yep I think it's what I mentioned we no longer seem to coach skills at NPC or super level. When we were at our best we had a team of WC players who could beat teams with skill, we don't have the same anymore, and as Jason Ryan says they they were picking players to go same direct style that Edie Jones talked of.
I don't think it's as simple as no longer having the skill, or being coached the skill. I think the Lions series showed how to stifle the ABs and defences have evolved from there. The highly skilled fast pace game the ABs try to play struggles against such defences because it is a very big ask for players to execute the required skills game after game under immense pressure. Doubly so in WC knockout games.
Yep maybe mate, what I really meant is we don't have the skills seemingly anymore, even at super level etc without real rush defences.
-
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks 2023:
@Victor-Meldrew but the problem in NZR is it is run from the top down, ABs are the shop window, and naturally people will try to replicate.
I'd suggest that's been one of the biggest problems in the last few years - you end up with players emulating the AB's and we fall behind as the rest of the world has studied them, learned, adapted, improved and moved on.
Coaching travels the same way, top down with ideas and practices, key is not stopping those that venture out of the box, and while only rumour, we kept hearing that Razor wasnt looked upon fondly due to this reason....which as it turns out, wasnt an issue, but maybe there was a tiny bit of truth in it?
Maybe the top-down model isn't fit for purpose and being one-way approach simply stifles innovation, development and thinking at lower levels?
Not convinced the shape and development of playing culture, ideas and direction should be dependent on one bloke who may or may be successful. I'd much prefer some sort of process on player & coach development which looks at global ideas, trends, skills gaps, senior player pool and there's both way movement of ideas and planning.
-
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Blacks 2023:
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks 2023:
that is exactly what has happened, and what I said above I hoped doesnt happen again if Razor is successful
The problems (and solutions) in NZ Rugby run way deeper than whoever is All Blacks Head Coach IMHO. You can have the best quality roof in the world on your house but if the rafters and walls are crap, it'll still come tumbling down
Absolutely right but having a "caretaker coach" (Foster) has exacerbated the problem. And you are underestimating the influence of having a group of coaches at the top (Razor, Ryan, et al) that could influence the way the game is played in NZ. I understand your arguments but completely disagree with the potential outcomes of a new direction.
Look at France/Ireland now compared to 10 years ago. -
@Old-Samurai-Jack said in All Blacks 2023:
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Blacks 2023:
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks 2023:
that is exactly what has happened, and what I said above I hoped doesnt happen again if Razor is successful
The problems (and solutions) in NZ Rugby run way deeper than whoever is All Blacks Head Coach IMHO. You can have the best quality roof in the world on your house but if the rafters and walls are crap, it'll still come tumbling down
Absolutely right but having a "caretaker coach" (Foster) has exacerbated the problem. And you are underestimating the influence of having a group of coaches at the top (Razor, Ryan, et al) that could influence the way the game is played in NZ.
Way too simplistic to suggest that three people, alone, with no other changes can solve player development issues at the top level of NZ rugby.
Look at France/Ireland now compared to 10 years ago.
Yep, let's use Ireland as an example. They undertook a root and branch review of Irish rugby 10 years ago, tweaked their rugby structure and had lower level coaches and players interacting with the national team coaches on a regular basis, They appointed a national performance director who works with the Ireland coaching staff to ensure strength in depth in every department.
I understand your arguments but completely disagree with the potential outcomes of a new direction.
Look at Ireland.
-
I'll join in the Ireland circle jerk when they keep this level after a few key retirements
Lets see if they're a good team or a good system. I feel like it's the former
-
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Blacks 2023:
I understand your arguments but completely disagree with the potential outcomes of a new direction.
Look at Ireland.
You are saying what I was trying to say I think. It starts with changing the top coach though.
-
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Blacks 2023:
Yep, let's use Ireland as an example. They undertook a root and branch review of Irish rugby 10 years ago, tweaked their rugby structure and had lower level coaches and players interacting with the national team coaches on a regular basis, They appointed a national performance director who works with the Ireland coaching staff to ensure strength in depth in every department.
That sounds exactly like what happened here and what youbwere arguing against earlier...
-
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks 2023:
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Blacks 2023:
Yep, let's use Ireland as an example. They undertook a root and branch review of Irish rugby 10 years ago, tweaked their rugby structure and had lower level coaches and players interacting with the national team coaches on a regular basis, They appointed a national performance director who works with the Ireland coaching staff to ensure strength in depth in every department.
That sounds exactly like what happened here and what youbwere arguing against earlier...
It's exactly the sort of thinking I'm suggesting we need - not necessarily the same approach. They did a review, tweaked thir structure, identified the need to look at development both upward and downward and developed the roles - which they then filled.
Totally opposite approach from appointing a Head Coach and hoping his Ideas will trickle down.
-
@Old-Samurai-Jack
Ireland did the opposite. -
Only 1 match in, but based on Pumas and Japan XV matches only, it would be hard to see anyone from the NZ XV (barring chronic run of injuries) being promoted to the 1st XV. 3 Tests left until RWC squad is named.
-
-
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Blacks 2023:
@Old-Samurai-Jack
Ireland did the opposite.From my limited understanding, I believe Schmitt was hugely influential in administering change at both club level and higher.
I understand your argument and I agree about the systemic problems in NZ rugby, but are you arguing to keep the current AB coach because there are problems elsewhere? That seems to counter your argument and the part I don't understand.
Part of the changes surely would be to put someone in the AB coaching role with some new innovation to head the needed changes.
Foster, for all his experience, is not an innovator. Change is not in his DNA. -
@Old-Samurai-Jack said in All Blacks 2023:
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Blacks 2023:
@Old-Samurai-Jack
Ireland did the opposite.From my limited understanding, I believe Schmitt was hugely influential in administering change at both club level and higher.
The thinking and changes took place well before Schmidt joined. Cheika at Leinster was also hugely influential according to O'Driscoll
I understand your argument and I agree about the systemic problems in NZ rugby, but are you arguing to keep the current AB coach because there are problems elsewhere?
That seems to counter your argument and the part I don't understand.Nothing to do with Foster or whoever is Head Coach (did I even mention him?). I'm talking about the need for some thinking around player development at senior levels and putting some better structure in place.
Part of the changes surely would be to put someone in the AB coaching role with some new innovation to head the needed changes.
Well, we could think about putting put someone close to the coaching staff (maybe call him a National Performance director...) and use him to co-ordinate player development up and down the tree. This might work better than one relying on one bloke (the AB Head Coach) to drive skills, player development and performance across lower levels by proxy or osmosis.
Foster, for all his experience, is not an innovator. Change is not in his DNA.
What has Foster got to do with it?
-
Every time. Every... fucking... time.
@Victor-Meldrew states something as simple as "I don't think just replacing the Head Coach of the All Blacks is going to fix everything... a more fundamental look at the entire structure is more likely to be of benefit"
Somebody interprets at as "Defending Foster". Just... how the fuck do we teach comprehension?
1 - There is ZERO fucking defence of Ian Foster in Meldrew's theory.
2 - Meldrew is NOT defending Ian Foster.
3 - Fucking FORGET Foster... nobody cares, not a single fucking bit, about yet another "Ugh... Foster is useless, because... blah blah"
4 - Read. Think. Comprehend. Then respond. (I know, I know... Cue: "un-fern-like", "ban him", etc) -
