Exodus
-
-
@mariner4life said in Exodus:
So weird to think we are what, 16 months from an AB test that will feature a new coaching group.
And that new coaching group will be without the following stalwarts that will feature all this year
Our two veteran starting locks
Openside and Captain
Starting #8
Our starting #9
BOTH our starting options at 10, one who is the starting 15.This alone would be huge if it wasn't also followed up by the fact that, barring one lock and the openside, there is literally no one to step in that has TEST PLAYER written all over him.
Even with the ATGs that left after 2015 we were comfy that there were replacements.
2024 will certainly be interesting. If Foster already knows he is gone come November, then he won't spend even a micro-second doing anything to build depth this year either, he'll be focused on his top 23 being 100% ready for the RWC.
Minor point but Savea is available for the ABs next year. Also, Cane is still around, just likely won't be starting. Lock and 10 looks very light.
-
@gt12 yeah, I don't know why and I know it's pretty much criminal to say here, but I find Retallick rather overrated. I feel like he had a couple of seasons where he was a bit of a beast, but I don't think I'd have him in my all time.
Huh there's a loud anti-BBBR squad on here, I see you've already picked up a like from the squad leader.
@gt12 He was in way better form last year than he was given credit for, whereas Whitelock was fawned over for similar form, so it's swings and roundabouts to how they're rated really. That 2015 steal is anything but underrated, it's constantly brought up (and deservedly so).
I love them both, the guy who plays for the Magpies/Chiefs shades it for me over the guy who has the double negative of being from the Poo and plays for the Crusaders obviously.
-
Liam Allen has signed an injury replacement contract with Lyon, to cover for injured Jordan Taufua (neck injury) and Maxime Gouzou (ACL), starting in March until ????
Site officiel | LOU Rugby
Retrouvez toutes les actualités du LOU Rugby : classement, matchs à venir, soirée, ...
-
Blade Thompson retires after head injury -
Welsh rugby fans' favourite quits with immediate effect after head injury
He won 10 caps after arriving in Wales in 2018
-
-
-
@Bovidae He's the type of player who unfortunately is a big loss, never going to be an AB , but so important to depth!
A little more than that IMO.
We are very quick to write players off in NZ if they don't look test standard after a couple of years.
Nankivell is 26 and each year he has shown improvements to his game while gaining experience. He is exactly the type of player that other countries target, qualify then turn back at us (eg Lowe, JGP etc).
Not saying he will be an international elsewhere but does roughly fit that scenario.
The concern isn't the other teams getting him, it is us missing out on possibly having a 28 year old, very experienced midfield player in the best form of his life as all the pieces of the puzzle come together for him.
Evidence in NZ over recen times though shows that those players are usually ignored in favour of some flash young potential that has to learn on the job.
Pity. -
@Daffy-Jaffy said in Exodus:
Blade Thompson retires after head injury -
He won 10 caps after arriving in Wales in 2018
That's sad to hear, he's the third player from the 2015 Hurricanes to retire with concussion issues (Goodes and Broadhurst were the others).
-
-
@Stargazer said in Exodus:
@Crucial I would have picked him ahead of RTS, who was only in the ABs on league reputation and perceived potential, and nothing else.
I'm not saying he is AB material at the moment just that he looks to be still on the up and by the time he reaches his 'best' he could be a very good player with heaps of experience. Has some rough edges and decision making issues at times but they usually disappear over time.
It is hard though. What do you do with players in that boat to keep them? Not quite at the level for high salary or high level games but could get there and be very valuable. -
@Bovidae He's the type of player who unfortunately is a big loss, never going to be an AB , but so important to depth!
A little more than that IMO.
We are very quick to write players off in NZ if they don't look test standard after a couple of years.Bundee Aki and James Lowe....
-
@canefan tbf I think Lowe always looked the goods but he was getting on a bit and wasn't the next big thing 22 year old we seem to always want and was a bit injury prone IIRC, so never even got a shot.
-
@Bovidae He's the type of player who unfortunately is a big loss, never going to be an AB , but so important to depth!
A little more than that IMO.
We are very quick to write players off in NZ if they don't look test standard after a couple of years.The more I read this, the more I'm wondering what you mean. Who's "we"? And how are "we" writing players off?
-
@taniwharugby said in Exodus:
@canefan tbf I think Lowe always looked the goods but he was getting on a bit and wasn't the next big thing 22 year old we seem to always want and was a bit injury prone IIRC, so never even got a shot.
I was just pointing out two guys who never really seemed close to ABs selection but we're clearly good enough when put into the right situation. We can't help it when players leave, but when young players on the cusp of the ABs leave it hurts. Guys like Piatau and Luatua had a chance to be in the side for a while, but left
-
@Stargazer said in Exodus:
@Bovidae He's the type of player who unfortunately is a big loss, never going to be an AB , but so important to depth!
A little more than that IMO.
We are very quick to write players off in NZ if they don't look test standard after a couple of years.The more I read this, the more I'm wondering what you mean. Who's "we"? And how are "we" writing players off?
I suppose that the “we” that matters is the high level selectors and player development people.
The other “we” is just comment from general punters and mediathat compare players still developing with the finished level and declare that they’ll never make it.
The comments around Aki, JGP and Lowe on these forums for example were numerous in condemnation.
For every poster that is currently claiming great knowledge because the have argued for Jordie at 12 there have been 5 saying that those guys would never be international standard.
That kind of public sentiment does filter through and combine it with a lack of opportunity or planning from on high and no wonder players look elsewhere.
