Blues v Waratahs

Bones

@anonymous said in Blues v Waratahs:

Where's the card for the penalty try?

I feel the seven points is enough. Don't like a YC being arbitrarily handed out just because one scrum got dominated. Right decision instead of guessing by Pickerill. Unlike the penalty only decision 90secs before.

I agree pretty much although when I started thinking about it... penalty try isn't really reward/punishment, it's the ref saying a try probably would've been scored. Maybe play should restart with a halfway pen to remove the feeling a yc us needed?

antipodean

@derpus said in Blues v Waratahs:

@antipodean i thought the rules stated that you have to yellow card when issuing a penalty try.

That's correct, but who is at fault in that scrum? Not sure I'd trust the ref to make that call correctly.

Agree regarding the outcome.

Derpus

@antipodean nah the refs are absolute mongs.

Bones

@derpus said in Blues v Waratahs:

i thought the rules stated that you have to yellow card when issuing a penalty try.

I had no idea about that. Interesting.

Nepia

Heem in again.

Anonymous

@antipodean said in Blues v Waratahs:

@derpus said in Blues v Waratahs:

@antipodean i thought the rules stated that you have to yellow card when issuing a penalty try.

That's correct, but who is at fault in that scrum? Not sure I'd trust the ref to make that call correctly.

Agree regarding the outcome.

1 in 14. That's better odds than normal, right?

Derpus

@bones nor do the refs, apparently.

antipodean

@kiwimurph said in Blues v Waratahs:

Kneepkens on please

11 minutes to impress

KiwiMurph

Lovely box kick Nock.

Derpus

So trying to put a positive spin on this tripe, Bell and Gordon both look really good. A couple of locks and wingers and the Waratahs might actually be able to compete with someone.

gt12

@kiwimurph said in Blues v Waratahs:

Lovely box kick Nock.

When he gets the distance right they are always contestable, because he gets so much height.

gt12

Neepkins with a good first touch. Nice turnover

antipodean

As good as Zarn has been, and he has, Otere has been poor.

Bones

@derpus said in Blues v Waratahs:

@bones nor do the refs, apparently.

I found this...

A penalty try is awarded between the goal posts if foul play by the opposing team prevents a probable try from being scored, or scored in a more advantageous position. A player guilty of this must be cautioned and temporarily suspended or sent off. No conversion is attempted.

Maybe it's semantics...."a player" but not "a front row".

Anonymous

Looked forward

gt12

Touch judge is right there.

Derpus

That pretty much sums up the last 10 years of Australian rugby

gt12

@anonymous said in Blues v Waratahs:

Looked forward

I cant believe that wasn’t checked, has the video ref already started on the Ham sandwiches?

taniwharugby

@gt12 he saw Smithy walking toward him so went to lock the door

gt12

Blues win by plenty but you’d have to say they left plenty out there.

The Silver Fern

Blues v Waratahs