Players to build the team around?
-
@chimoaus said in Players to build the team around?:
How do you accurately judge a players discipline? Was Ardie unlucky when he got pulled off his feet and landed on the wrong side giving away a penalty? Or should he not have made the play?
It seems a very fine line at times, do players intentionally pull down mauls, enter from the side, off their feet, pancake etc. Is it poor technique, poor game knowledge or just unlucky.
On the weekend we got smashed with those soft penalties where the player should have known better. When you aggregate all these penalties it certainly stopped us building pressure and allowed Sanchez to build points.
Can you coach those stupid plays out of players or are some more prone to it than others?
And sometimes the ref just sees it differently. Last penalty I think Sam W was pretty sure he was legal, but Angus thought he knew better.
-
@taniwharugby said in Players to build the team around?:
@chimoaus well a penalty conceded is a penalty conceded, the slip of a bind at scrumtime equals the same as a dumb little slap.
SOmetimes pulling down a maul is deliberate, hopefully just a penalty to stop a try...but alot of the times a foot slips, a player lets you go, pulls at you...
Just unfortunate.
That slip of the bind was BS.
-
@Tim said in Players to build the team around?:
@taniwharugby said in Players to build the team around?:
Tuipoluto isnt dominating like a guy of his size should
This is true, and I wish they would use him to hit the ball up in the middle of the park, and target guys for hits with a rush defence close in too. Don't think he suits the go wide quickly and short passing game plans they use.
It's very frustrating. First few games of SRA he was looking like the beast we thought he'd be. But seemed to lose impact over course of SRA. hasn't really regained that early SRA form for ABs?
-
OK, so the question is who's going to be there over the next two cycles. I'll assume that's about 6 years or so, and we assume they can do a Conrad/Ma'a/DC/McCaw and get into their mid 30's.
The obvious six year candidates are
- Cane
- ALB
- BBBR
- Mo'unga
- ...? Hos? Akira?
-
-
@nzzp said in Players to build the team around?:
@canefan said in Players to build the team around?:
@nzzp BBBR is 29
eh, we should get at least 4-5 years out of him, and a mid career break could extend. Locks can still perform into their mid 30's I reckon ... look at AWJ for instance.
His current sabbatical should help
-
@nostrildamus said in Players to build the team around?:
@Bones yes I liked him, always went forward, and same height as Brad Thorne who went alright at lock.
he may not have been super tall but he was a solid lineout option, strong in the air
how i'd love to have seen PPP maybe getting a run, could do with a bit more bulk but showing some good signs i think
-
@pakman said in Players to build the team around?:
It's very frustrating. First few games of SRA he was looking like the beast we thought he'd be. But seemed to lose impact over course of SRA. hasn't really regained that early SRA form for ABs?
It doesn't look like Tuitpulotu is 100%
From memory, he had an injury after the North/South match and missed the opening rounds of the NPC.
They were going to put him straight into the Bledisloe match and he said he wasn't ready and requested to play in round 3 of the NPC.
Then he pulled out of the last Bledisloe on match day with an illnessNot massive issues but I do question if he would be playing if the other locking options weren't a rookie and a retard.
-
@Duluth said in Players to build the team around?:
Not massive issues but I do question if he would be playing if the other locking options weren't a rookie and a retard.
quality
Top 5 locks for a squad then would be (when fit and playing)
- BBBR
- SW
- Daylight... but PT
- Va'ai
- Scott of the B's (or maybe PPP or A N Other)
damn, looks so thin right now
-
surely there is someone standing out at lock in the NPC
not to come straight in or anything, but to watch in next years SR
-
@Kiwiwomble said in Players to build the team around?:
surely there is someone standing out at lock in the NPC
Jacob Pierce is easily the next best
-
The way Romano is playing I think he deserves another opportunity
-
@family-man 34 is pretty late for a second shot though isn't it
-
@Kiwiwomble said in Players to build the team around?:
@family-man 34 is pretty late for a second shot though isn't it
that's before you mention he was barely to standard in his prime. Hugely overrated.
-
NZ haven't great player now. Clarke looked promising but only for one match
We were spoiled in the recent past. Starting with Carter and McCaw. But add in Brodie Allan Retallick and the likes of Nonu and Smith etc. Also Coles at his best. I'm sure they will come but not yet
