All Blacks v France Test #1
-
-
I wonder if they might gove Taufua a nench spot next week instead of Ardie. I guess the third test is most likely.
Was a bit surprised they didn't give Fifita 10mins at lock given he was supposedly covering there in thos game. It wouldn't have given them much of an idea but at least it would start to paint a picture of whether or not he is capable. -
@kirwan said in All Blacks v France Test #1:
@stargazer said in All Blacks v France Test #1:
@kirwan Ah, yes, of course, Jordie!
I’d consider Jordie to cover 10 over DMac as well.
Based on what?
-
@stargazer That shouldn't be too hard if you assume they're only making that "commitment" for the original 33 man squad.
With Retallick and SBW ruled out, they've only got to find places for eight more guys across two tests. I think people like JTA, Frizzell and TTT will be planned only to get a few minutes off the bench, somewhere.
Wouldn't be hard to give either Naholo or Goodhue a start in the second test and also, as Pukunui suggests, stick someone like Taufua on the bench.
I reckon they'll be hoping to give Mo'unga a start in the third test and plonk Beaudy on the bench as cover. Which leaves NMS to get a run somewhere - probably in the third test - maybe a back three of Naholo, NMS, BFA for that one?
-
righto, quick match report.
Beer was tasty. It wasn't what Eden Park sells.
Weather was dry but cold.
Codie was excellent.
Ryko Yoarney did well to grab a brace - but weirdly ran away from the posts.
Ref was slightly random, particularly with cards/high tackle penalties
France were good for 40. I have no idea what Steveo said at half time, but it bloody worked. 44-0 in a half is some scoreline.
ALB and RC aren't physical enough. Wouldn't mind seeing Laumape at 12. I miss Nonu
Also, I miss BBBR.
JB is tall, skinny, white, fast, accurate and quality. Colour me impressed.
Some great tries live, they'll live on in my hazy memory for soem time.
-
yeah the mid-field balance isnt right at present, maybe NL/RC or RC/JG
Cant see any other combo due to inexperience
-
@crucial said in All Blacks v France Test #1:
@kirwan said in All Blacks v France Test #1:
@stargazer said in All Blacks v France Test #1:
@kirwan Ah, yes, of course, Jordie!
I’d consider Jordie to cover 10 over DMac as well.
Based on what?
That when he goes into first receiver he doesn’t play like a headless chicken?
-
Much better second half. That card was fucked though. Ruined the game.
Laumape needs to start.
Ben Smith started to get the hang of wing again in the second half.
Locks went well.
Karl T great work.
Codie T man of the match.
DMac looks great running into huge gaps but doesnt really answer any questions about a tight game.
-
The double tackle on Remy Grosso by Sam Cane and Ofa Tu'ungafasi has caused serious injury to Grosso, more in particular Ofa's shoulder. He has a double facial fracture, according to the website Rugbyrama. One is a sinus fracture. He's been advised not to travel back to France immediately, because the pressure in the plane is considered a risk.
According to the same article, the French management have asked the citing commissioner to examine the footage of the incident (as they can do under the rules).
Obviously, there's again a lot of talk of one set of rules for the ABs and one set of rules for the rest. I've been lurking on a few French forums and they go as far as saying that the high tackles from Cane and Ofa were deliberate, and that Ofa's shoulder hit to Grosso's face amounts to assault that should be prosecuted (but won't be because of, "All Blacks"). Apparently, referees are still scared of the ABs and, therefore, do not penalise them. These comments do not only come from French rugby fans, but I've also seen them again from English speaking rugby fans, and media.
-
@kiwimurph said in All Blacks v France Test #1:
DMac looks great running into huge gaps but doesnt really answer any questions about a tight game.
The guy’s on a hiding to nothing with some people isn’t he?
He is hardly perfect and certainly hit and miss at times but the coaches realise the value of when he does something good it is very good.(and back themselves to try and reduce the very bad).
You can hardly deny what a player brings when two touches of the ball result in two tries. I’ll take that any day.
That first try wasn’t a huge gap. That was classic Cullen like play where he spotted an opportunity from deep and accelerated into the right place on the right line at the right time. Only players with great instinct do that. Cullen was brilliant at it because he also glided at speed very deceptively and seemingly popped up from nowhere.
I think DMac did his job today very well and only pushed the situation once in a poor way.
He tries to create scoring chances and as long as he comes out on the right side of the ledger it’s a win. -
@stargazer said in All Blacks v France Test #1:
The double tackle on Remy Grosso by Sam Cane and Ofa Tu'ungafasi has caused serious injury to Grosso, more in particular Ofa's shoulder. He has a double facial fracture, according to the website Rugbyrama. One is a sinus fracture. He's been advised not to travel back to France immediately, because the pressure in the plane is considered a risk.
According to the same article, the French management have asked the citing commissioner to examine the footage of the incident (as they can do under the rules).
Obviously, there's again a lot of talk of one set of rules for the ABs and one set of rules for the rest. I've been lurking on a few French forums and they go as far as saying that the high tackles from Cane and Ofa were deliberate, and that Ofa's shoulder hit to Grosso's face amounts to assault that should be prosecuted (but won't be because of, "All Blacks"). Apparently, referees are still scared of the ABs and, therefore, do not penalise them. These comments do not only come from French rugby fans, but I've also seen them again from English speaking rugby fans, and media.
The ref had two howlers, marring an otherwise decent game for him. It was disappointing because it spoiled what was a good test match.
Sometimes refs and touchies miss things, or are the French forgetting 2007? Because I haven't -
@stargazer said in All Blacks v France Test #1:
I’m not quite sure what your point is. Just because someone gets injured doesn’t mean he was targeted. First player tackles, French player slips, shoulder hits face. Anyone not a Kiwi will be latching onto it though.
-
@billy-tell I'm not sure why you think I'm making a point. I just posted - without comment - the clip of the incident to enable people to watch again what happened. From one angle, that is.
-
@canefan said in All Blacks v France Test #1:
The ref had two howlers, marring an otherwise decent game for him. It was disappointing because it spoiled what was a good test match.
Sometimes refs and touchies miss things, or are the French forgetting 2007? Because I haven'tThey probably think there was nothing wrong with the officiating in 2007. I have, however, again seen references to McCaw kneeing Parra in the face in the 2011 final, something they keep on coming back to each time they think the referees have missed foul play by the ABs. I once replied with a reference to the alleged eye gouging committed against McCaw in the same match. I was almost eaten alive.
-
I’d love to hear comment from the referees as to why, yet again, a player in front of the ball that catches a knock on isn’t penalised.
As far as I know there has been no directive to be lenient and award scrums but twice now at EP in a test we have seen this ‘agreement’
