Blues v Rebels
-
@crucial said in Blues vs. Rebels:
I'll get accused of white knighting but questioning the decency of a person is getting a bit carried away surely?
He should resign, end of story.
If he doesn’t then he’s not acting as a decent person would.
-
@steven-harris said in Blues vs. Rebels:
As for Tana,it’s all very well lamenting all your injuries,but at the end of the day,Squad selection is huge,injuries have got to be taken into account,and on that note alone,Umaga,Jackson & Hanks are all totally culpable..The CEO Redman needs to have a good look in the mirror as well..The have got everything they desired in terms of a training facility and by the sounds it of their own autonomy..!
Yes exactly. It’s obvious where the problem starts. If there wasn’t a popular former player in the middle of that group there would have been a blood bath. The media would have reported accurately and the nzru wouldn’t have protected reputations.
Why should Blues fans suffer because one of the incompetent people was a popular player? Fuck that. The back room should be judged by the same standard as any other franchise. They are all terrible compared to their contemporaries
I’m still amazed that the people involved haven’t quit.
-
It's hard to know what NZR thinks about the Blues, but it looks from the outside they're a bit complacent. I would tell the Blues board etc. that either you fix this or we will. NZ doesn't need the Blues to be strong for NZ rugby to be strong, but it's certainly not helping that they're so woeful.
Seems like they need a complete clean out and then get a hardened coach in there that's actually earned his stripes. -
@steven-harris said in Blues vs. Rebels:
I was told by Hanks,the Blues would be the surprise packet,I did not believe that for a minute...
They have been a surprise package, just not the way most would hope...the surprise is the lowest of the low they are at.
Problem is these guys like Redman know if they backtrack on Tana it makes them look even more incompetent so need to carry on backing him, despite the results being some of the worst by any NZ team in probably a decade?
-
@taniwharugby said in Blues vs. Rebels:
Problem is these guys like Redman know if they backtrack on Tana it makes them look even more incompetent so need to carry on backing him, despite the results being some of the worst by any NZ team in probably a decade?
Yes, more reputation protection. That’s all that matters
Worth noting this board took over mid 2013. It’s been a disaster the whole way through
-
This has probably already in one of the many earlier threads, but how do the Board keep getting reappointed?
-
@mariner4life said in Blues vs. Rebels:
This has probably already in one of the many earlier threads, but how do the Board keep getting reappointed?
Root cause of the problems, and unwilling to deal wtih them.
The rot became visible after Pat Lam got sacked a year into a two year extension. If you got it that wrong, fall on your sword.
-
Obviously, the media are exaggerating this as usual, but after Jordie's maccas fuelled antics early yesterday morning, now Rieko Ioane also giving ABs management some head ache:
The Blues were also in damage control, after an incident that saw All Blacks wing Rieko Ioane involved in an altercation with a teammate, after their 20-10 loss to the Melbourne Rebels on Saturday night. Newshub believes the two players have since apologised to each other and are embarrassed by their behaviour. Both Barrett and Ioane reported to All Blacks camp on Sunday afternoon to prepare for the upcoming three-test series against France. Ioane will be sporting an injury above his eye.What is a bigger thing to worry about is that it was an altercation between two Blues team mates ...
-
@stargazer was probably giving Collins shit for not being able to pass the ball....
-
@kiwimurph are plenty of players he could be giving shit to in his team, and rightfully so too...
being part of a losing culture cant be easy, gonna take its toll I expect.
-
-
-
@taniwharugby Gatland might do it.
The thing is you have to do due diligence, but great coaches come out of unlikely spots.
No-one picked Dave Rennie to win the competition in his first year. Many predicted that his squad was weak and would struggle.
Tana, on the face of it, did well with Counties, and I thought there was merit in his Blues selection at the time. I'd be very interested in hearing from his players there what made him good there, but doesn't work at the Blues (I suspect "just letting the players have their heads", which is exposed at higher levels by well-drilled sides).
But boards need to check this stuff, and not assume what looks like success on paper is what it seems. I'm always astounded how many successful people assume they are good at everything, including assessing a person's abilities off a short interview. Interviews are a terrible way to pick staff.
There will be some guys out there doing awesome stuff with limited resources, but who don't have a "face" and interview poorly. It's not really the fans job to locate them. The Blues need a hard task-master coach to sort them out -- one who will piss people off no doubt -- but such people can be hard to like.
Waikato has had a run of bollocks coaches for years, for similar reasons. There's a couple of excellent coaches at school and club level that won't get the gig though, because they are abrasive and won't fit the politics.
-
@chester-draws I think Rennie had served a decent apprenticeship before taking over the Chiefs and was highly rated, plus had a good team around him
I may have my timelines confused, but Tana had a similar path, but probably not as much NPC experience, so I guess you can understand why the appointment was made, but thier continued support of him in the face of some of the worst results in the teams history is an issue.
Twattue is right now and again...
-
@taniwharugby said in Blues vs. Rebels:
@chester-draws I think Rennie had served a decent apprenticeship before taking over the Chiefs and was highly rated, plus had a good team around him
Rennie had a hard time with Wellington at ITM level and got moved on if I recall -- certainly wasn't seen as a world beater or a locked in super coach.
-
@nzzp said in Blues vs. Rebels:
@taniwharugby said in Blues vs. Rebels:
@chester-draws I think Rennie had served a decent apprenticeship before taking over the Chiefs and was highly rated, plus had a good team around him
Rennie had a hard time with Wellington at ITM level and got moved on if I recall -- certainly wasn't seen as a world beater or a locked in super coach.
He was great for Wellington, won the NPC back when it still mattered.
Then got overlooked for years for higher jobs, eventually went sideways and slightly backwards to coach Manawatu also 'only' at NPC level.
He was the Wayne Pivac of the Lower North Island.
