Blues v Highlanders
-
@steven-harris said in Blues v Highlanders:
@pukunui you reckon Collins is a poor selection..?,I reckon he’s one of the better ones and from what I heard does a ton of talking and directing traffic from the back..got crucified by a few people on this site for what I admit was very poor tackling effort on Jean Luc Deprie in the Sharks game,game but people failed to notice was the missed tackle by Jerome Kaino on the advantage line in the sharks game that lead up to that try
From a Northland piece,Sam Nock has been a real disappointment, and while Hyland did not cover himself in glory with his game on Friday ,he’s really only there because of injuries..Kara Pryor has been better than I thought he would be,but is not a long time answer,and he’s no Blake Gibson.
My biggest disappointment has been Patrick Tuipulotu,does one or 2 good carries in a game and then is never seen again,given his size and reputation is a real let down,compare his workrate to Jackson Hemapo,not even in the same ball park.
Parsons the skipper is no more than a plodder..
I am willing to cut some slack on Perofeta and Gatland simply because they are young guys,but have not had a shed load of experience around them..Yes, I think Collins is rubbish. Definitely not Super rugby starting standard. Regardless of that im still not seeing anyone actually coming up with a list of names of experienced guys Tana "should have signed".
Regarding Black. He is probably the best 10 signing they have made since Nick Evans a decade ago and he hasn't even played a game. But that's not a hard list to top.
-
@pukunui is he the best signing cos he hasnt yet had a chance to fail to meet the high expectations on him?
-
@taniwharugby said in Blues v Highlanders:
@pukunui is he the best signing cos he hasnt yet had a chance to fail to meet the high expectations on him?
No, mainly because he is competing with guys who were past it or never even showed a glimpse of having it. Black has at least played a few games of super rugby and shown that he isn't completely useless, he is also fair young so could be around for a few years.
-
@pukunui Otere Black is 6 days older than Bryn Gatland, who is 10 months older than Perofeta...all 3 could be about for many years to come!
-
@taniwharugby said in Blues v Highlanders:
@pukunui Otere Black is 6 days older than Bryn Gatland, who is 10 months older than Perofeta...all 3 could be about for many years to come!
Not sure what point you are making. That is great. He has a bit of a head start on Super rugby experience on those other guys but that may not count for much after this season sitting on the sideline.
-
@pukunui the other 2 are younger, both been slated past couple of weeks, and they are playing...Black is simply benefiting from not playing and thus looking by far the best option...if we use the Ngatai rule, he will get better the longer he doesnt play
-
@pukunui I’m curious about why in your opinion Collins is rubbish,and who you would play there..?.
As for Otere Black only time will tell if he’s a decent pivot,have heard from some turbo supporters that Jade Te Rure is a better allround player. -
@taniwharugby said in Blues v Highlanders:
@pukunui the other 2 are younger, both been slated past couple of weeks, and they are playing...Black is simply benefiting from not playing and thus looking by far the best option...if we use the Ngatai rule, he will get better the longer he doesnt play
With the current state of Blues results that is the general rule that gets applied to any player not taking the field. Continual grasping at straws with 'why isn't so and so playing instead, they are better' followed by 'why was so and so picked, they were crap'. Anyone not playing gets talked up as a potential saviour.
-
@steven-harris Collins has two big limits: speed and kicking game. Kicking game is surprisingly poor. Agreed that he is probably otherwise one of the safer and better thinking players.
-
@tim I thought his game against the touring Lions team last year was outstanding,he fielded all the high kicks that came his way and his kicking game on the night was first class.
In the bigger picture,Collins is the least of the Blues problems.. -
@steven-harris said in Blues v Highlanders:
@pukunui I’m curious about why in your opinion Collins is rubbish,and who you would play there..?.
As for Otere Black only time will tell if he’s a decent pivot,have heard from some turbo supporters that Jade Te Rure is a better allround player.I just think he offers very little other than this supposed "communication" that keeps getting talked about. Rarely beats a man with strength, a step or speed, isn't flash on defence and kicking is no better than average. Fullback is hugely important position and he has been there most of the last two seasons and the Blues have been shit in that time. I think he is part of it and his communication isn't adding much.
I think a Ioane/Nanai/Duffie back three in whatever order you put it should be the first choice. Nanai isn't the finished product by any means but he has been stuck behind Collins unable to get the minutes he needs to develop.Again for Black, not suggesting he is a saviour. Just refuting the claim that they haven't recruited anyone decent. He has already proved himself decent. Could all turn to shit but that doesn't come into it.
Still waiting on a list of experienced guys they didn't sign. -
@pukunui You got me interested which led me to this:
http://www.espn.com.au/rugby/playerstats?gameId=292124&league=242041It's the only one I've looked at so far, but the only player that beat more defenders is Akira in this list. Obviously it's only stats, but if he's not beating them with speed/step/strength, what do ya reckon it is? Guile while on his way to the sideline to be subbed?
-
@bones said in Blues v Highlanders:
@pukunui You got me interested which led me to this:
http://www.espn.com.au/rugby/playerstats?gameId=292124&league=242041It's the only one I've looked at so far, but the only player that beat more defenders is Akira in this list. Obviously it's only stats, but if he's not beating them with speed/step/strength, what do ya reckon it is? Guile while on his way to the sideline to be subbed?
Maybe he communicated them into slipping over and plodded past.
Regardless i trust my eyes more than i trust some very basic stats. His highlight reel would be great for curing insomnia. -
Experienced first-fives they might have chased (or kept) include:
Tom Taylor
Stephen Donald, after Rennie arrived
Gareth AnscombeBut they weren't looking for players like that. They didnt want solid and reliable. They wanted superstar players. Since none were available they signed kids hoping they'd come right.
-
-
@chester-draws said in Blues v Highlanders:
Experienced first-fives they might have chased (or kept) include:
Tom Taylor
Stephen Donald, after Rennie arrived
Gareth AnscombeBut they weren't looking for players like that. They didnt want solid and reliable. They wanted superstar players. Since none were available they signed kids hoping they'd come right.
You keep mentioning Anscombe as a 10. He wasn't a Super level quality 10. Chiefs played him at 15. If memory serves me correctly he was named to start one Super game at 10 for the Chiefs at Pukekohe but got injured in the leadup and didn't play.
-
@chris-b didn't they try to sign Slade?
-
@taniwharugby said in Blues v Highlanders:
@chris-b didn't they try to sign Slade?
Not that I can recall - at least, not at that time.
I recall suggesting at the time that they should - but, the Blues fans didn't seem keen on the idea.
You'd have to think that for the right deal he would have been signable - I'm pretty sure the Crusaders wouldn't have been in a position to throw a bucket of money at him and his previous shift to the Highlanders and subsequent shift to Pau suggests he wasn't wedded to them.
-
@chris-b said in Blues v Highlanders:
I recall suggesting at the time that they should - but, the Blues fans didn't seem keen on the idea.
Slade could have been the new Chris Noakes. I really don't think it would have made any difference who signed at 10.
The main problem is internal standards. No one is accountable for anything. Board, coaches and players. The search for a flyhalf obsession is just another excuse for people not to perform their jobs properly and blame an external factor
Poor Umaga, Redman, players. If only they had Beauden Barrett. It's just not fair! The reality is if Barrett came to the Blues he would be surrounded, at every level, by people with such low standards he would fail.
