Things that annoy you about rugby...
-
Late to party but I wish 15s was ref'd like the 7s, with all the ball chucking and pretending that you thought the penalty went your way etc. 7s refs smash down on that, the game is faster and that is better to watch, more respectful and also good for Kiwi teams
-
@taniwharugby see I didn't notice it that much, it was just watching Murray do it last night I thought he was going to get smoked the first time I saw him do it as it was so far out of the breakdown, like a metre. Then the ref says it's still in. It was like Murray was making a parody of it at first. Nothing in the blues game came close that I saw.
-
At some point a captain should just say no
No no no, stop the game, this is horseshit.And then point out to the ref that the ruck is on the halfway, and hence there is no way the ball on the 10m can not be out.
I know that we are basically the pioneers of pushing the boundaries, but the game is entering joke status.
-
@bones said in Things that annoy you about rugby...:
@taniwharugby see I didn't notice it that much, it was just watching Murray do it last night I thought he was going to get smoked the first time I saw him do it as it was so far out of the breakdown, like a metre. Then the ref says it's still in. It was like Murray was making a parody of it at first. Nothing in the blues game came close that I saw.
Murray completely takes the piss with that. Frustrating to watch.
-
@no-quarter said in Things that annoy you about rugby...:
@bones said in Things that annoy you about rugby...:
@taniwharugby see I didn't notice it that much, it was just watching Murray do it last night I thought he was going to get smoked the first time I saw him do it as it was so far out of the breakdown, like a metre. Then the ref says it's still in. It was like Murray was making a parody of it at first. Nothing in the blues game came close that I saw.
Murray completely takes the piss with that. Frustrating to watch.
Plays the game to the letter of the law. If that's hwo it'll be refereed, play that way - that will drive change more than whinging
-
This post is deleted!
-
One thing i've noticed a lot this year is defending teams intentionally knocking an attacking pass backwards/down as they face their own goal-line chasing in defense.
It's legal - as the goes backwards not down/forwards but to me seems a bit of a cheap cop out. There is no intention to catch the ball whatsoever - its a very negative play.
-
@kiwimurph said in Things that annoy you about rugby...:
One thing i've noticed a lot this year is defending teams intentionally knocking an attacking pass backwards/down as they face their own goal-line chasing in defense.
It's legal - as the goes backwards not down/forwards but to me seems a bit of a cheap cop out. There is no intention to catch the ball whatsoever - its a very negative play.
Christ. Do you just hate defenders?
-
@rapido said in Things that annoy you about rugby...:
@kiwimurph said in Things that annoy you about rugby...:
One thing i've noticed a lot this year is defending teams intentionally knocking an attacking pass backwards/down as they face their own goal-line chasing in defense.
It's legal - as the goes backwards not down/forwards but to me seems a bit of a cheap cop out. There is no intention to catch the ball whatsoever - its a very negative play.
Christ. Do you just hate defenders?
well, he's a Blues fan...
-
@kiwimurph said in Things that annoy you about rugby...:
One thing i've noticed a lot this year is defending teams intentionally knocking an attacking pass backwards/down as they face their own goal-line chasing in defense.
It's legal - as the goes backwards not down/forwards but to me seems a bit of a cheap cop out. There is no intention to catch the ball whatsoever - its a very negative play.
It's clever. If a team makes a stupid pass too close to defenders why should they be rewarded?
-
@booboo said in Things that annoy you about rugby...:
@kiwimurph said in Things that annoy you about rugby...:
One thing i've noticed a lot this year is defending teams intentionally knocking an attacking pass backwards/down as they face their own goal-line chasing in defense.
It's legal - as the goes backwards not down/forwards but to me seems a bit of a cheap cop out. There is no intention to catch the ball whatsoever - its a very negative play.
It's clever. If a team makes a stupid pass too close to defenders why should they be rewarded?
Yep, like calling for the ball when you're running a defensive line behind someome. Seems to work well, and it's just smart play
-
@booboo said in Things that annoy you about rugby...:
@kiwimurph said in Things that annoy you about rugby...:
One thing i've noticed a lot this year is defending teams intentionally knocking an attacking pass backwards/down as they face their own goal-line chasing in defense.
It's legal - as the goes backwards not down/forwards but to me seems a bit of a cheap cop out. There is no intention to catch the ball whatsoever - its a very negative play.
It's clever. If a team makes a stupid pass too close to defenders why should they be rewarded?
In my opinion as a viewer a pass in this instance is a positive attacking piece of play - when this is occuring typically the defender is facing their own goal line which means the attacking team is making/made a break and has momentum - knocking it down with no intention of catching it is a negative play and just takes away the momentum in a cheap way.
I just find it negative just like how an intentional knock forward is penalised instead of a straight knock on or like how intentionally knock the ball out of play is penalised (e.g. SBW v France last year).
However to be clear I'm not talking about changing the rule cos I understand it could then open up a can of worms (e.g. knocking the ball back from a lineout etc). It just annoys me is all.
-
@nzzp said in Things that annoy you about rugby...:
@no-quarter said in Things that annoy you about rugby...:
@bones said in Things that annoy you about rugby...:
@taniwharugby see I didn't notice it that much, it was just watching Murray do it last night I thought he was going to get smoked the first time I saw him do it as it was so far out of the breakdown, like a metre. Then the ref says it's still in. It was like Murray was making a parody of it at first. Nothing in the blues game came close that I saw.
Murray completely takes the piss with that. Frustrating to watch.
Plays the game to the letter of the law. If that's hwo it'll be refereed, play that way - that will drive change more than whinging
I'm pretty sure it's the exact opposite of playing to the letter of the law
-
@rapido said in Things that annoy you about rugby...:
I'm pretty sure it's the exact opposite of playing to the letter of the law
Look, I don't like it and I would like something to be done. I just think that if you can make it look ridiculous week after week, something will be done.
As for the 'letter of the law', I'd challenge anyone to actually play the game the way the law book sets it out. So much of rugby is accepted referees interpretation. I have issues with it, but it's just the way life will go.
-
@nzzp said in Things that annoy you about rugby...:
@booboo said in Things that annoy you about rugby...:
@kiwimurph said in Things that annoy you about rugby...:
One thing i've noticed a lot this year is defending teams intentionally knocking an attacking pass backwards/down as they face their own goal-line chasing in defense.
It's legal - as the goes backwards not down/forwards but to me seems a bit of a cheap cop out. There is no intention to catch the ball whatsoever - its a very negative play.
It's clever. If a team makes a stupid pass too close to defenders why should they be rewarded?
Yep, like calling for the ball when you're running a defensive line behind someome. Seems to work well, and it's just smart play
I think so too. However there was a massive thread on the refs forum a while back about whether calling for a pass from the opposition was contrary to the spirit of the game and should be penalized. Daft idea in my view, but there you go. Was split fairly evenly if I recall correctly.