Tallest vs Heaviest : who wins ?

[cgrant]

Just for fun : which team should win this imaginary game ?

Tall XV :
Nanai
Duffie
SBW
J. Barrett
Lam
Banks
TKB
Kaino
Boshier
Seu
Bird
Retallick
Ofa T
Moulds
Prattley

Heavy XV :
Dagg
Tamanivalu
Ioane
Laumape
Savea
Barrett
Guyton
Luatua
Cane
Squire
Lousi
Tuipolutu
Kautai
Pleasants-Tate
Moli

[booboo]

The one with thebest height to weight ratio, ie, the one with Hayman at Number 8.

[MN5]

So Julian Savea doesn't make a tall XV and George Moala doesn't make a heavy XV? Banks over deceptively tall Beauden Barrett? Luatua and Kaino clearly in the wrong teams?

This is the stupidest thread in fern history which is quite a feat....

[Bones]

More troubling would Be no mention of Ardie in the tall xv.

[cgrant]

I know it is stupid but it is just for fun as I wrote it ...
No Beauden Barrett in the tall XV because he is 1.87 m tall while Marty Banks is 1.91 m tall.
I forgot Moala (104 kg) : he's heavier than Laumape (103 kg).

[cgrant]

By the way, Ben Lam is standing 1.94m while Julian Savea is "only" 1.92 m tall.

[JC]

It's a trick question isn't it? Guyton isn't a rugby player.

[antipodean]

@JC said in Tallest vs Heaviest : who wins ?:

It's a trick question isn't it? Guyton isn't a rugby player.

[Rancid Schnitzel]

This reminds me of the notorious Black Dragon for some reason.

[MN5]

@antipodean said in Tallest vs Heaviest : who wins ?:

@JC said in Tallest vs Heaviest : who wins ?:

It's a trick question isn't it? Guyton isn't a rugby player.

The fucken CATELINA WINE MIXER!

[Nepia]

@cgrant TJ is heavier than Guyton and I'm sure @JC would consider him a rugby player.

[booboo]

@Rancid-Schnitzel said in Tallest vs Heaviest : who wins ?:

This reminds me of the notorious Black Dragon for some reason.

@booboo said in Tallest vs Heaviest : who wins ?:

The one with thebest height to weight ratio, ie, the one with Hayman at Number 8.

Ahem

[Rancid Schnitzel]

@booboo said in Tallest vs Heaviest : who wins ?:

@Rancid-Schnitzel said in Tallest vs Heaviest : who wins ?:

This reminds me of the notorious Black Dragon for some reason.

@booboo said in Tallest vs Heaviest : who wins ?:

The one with thebest height to weight ratio, ie, the one with Hayman at Number 8.

Ahem

So it was you!!!!!! Are Conrad Smith's legs still too short?