Italy v All Blacks
-
@antipodean said in Italy v All Blacks:
@Machpants said in Italy v All Blacks:
FFS Ioane
Your IDS is turning into a full fledged mental disease. The pass was prefect and Tele'a fumbled a simple pass putting him in space.
I thought it was a forward pass, went back, still do. Tho the angle was poor so I could be wrong
-
@frugby said in Italy v All Blacks:
At the end of the day, this test means nothing, and regardless of what happens from here, is one nobody will remember. Lest we forget last time we played Italy in Italy, it was also a shitfest.
I think this was probably partly down to the fact a bunch of old guys didn't really fancy playing properly after a long tour in zero degrees temperatures.
This isn't exactly on the coach, because he wasn't the one kicking the ball, dropping it, failing to clear rucks etc.
Sure, if we ignore he selected and coached them.
-
@frugby said in Italy v All Blacks:
This isn't exactly on the coach, because he wasn't the one kicking the ball, dropping it, failing to clear rucks etc.
I always chuckle at statements like this.
If the performance of the team isn't on the coach then what is he there for? Vibes?
-
@frugby said in Italy v All Blacks:
This isn't exactly on the coach, because he wasn't the one kicking the ball, dropping it, failing to clear rucks etc.
Overall for the tour:
Razor picked players out of form, burnt out, or recently injured.
There were plenty of younger and fresher caps and inform players who could have been tested.
I am trying to think of a newbie found wanting at this level and all I can think of is Finau, and he still showed some glimpses. -
@antipodean said in Italy v All Blacks:
@frugby said in Italy v All Blacks:
At the end of the day, this test means nothing, and regardless of what happens from here, is one nobody will remember. Lest we forget last time we played Italy in Italy, it was also a shitfest.
I think this was probably partly down to the fact a bunch of old guys didn't really fancy playing properly after a long tour in zero degrees temperatures.
This isn't exactly on the coach, because he wasn't the one kicking the ball, dropping it, failing to clear rucks etc.
Sure, if we ignore he selected and coached them.
It is not all his fault though is it.
I think this is a good lesson to Razor, that at the end of a long tour, a long season (our longest ever?) when you are about to play in zero degree temperatures, picking the old guys who can't wait to get back to their families isn't the play.
The key, and we will talk about this at length, is that Robertson learns from this season, and the evidence of his coaching career is that he will. Writing him off after a year is silly, asking for him to be sacked is silly. Lets review things at the end of next year.
-
Bundaberg ‘moment of the match’ being when Sam Cane left the field says it all
-
Absolute masterclass from Razor and the AB's today. They have emulated the Crusaders winning approach totally. Absorb lots of goalline pressure, concede cards where needed to save worse, and use their weapon of scrum ming for penalties to the absolute max. Stunning!
Gee haven't Italy improved from conceding 96 points to Fozzie's rabble last year.
In fact it was such a complete performance, I might look for something more flawed to watch next year, like NRL. -
@frugby said in Italy v All Blacks:
At the end of the day, this test means nothing, and regardless of what happens from here, is one nobody will remember.
In may ways you're right.
There's been so many shit-fests like this recently, people have problems remembering them all
-
@nostrildamus said in Italy v All Blacks:
@frugby said in Italy v All Blacks:
This isn't exactly on the coach, because he wasn't the one kicking the ball, dropping it, failing to clear rucks etc.
Overall for the tour:
Razor picked players out of form, burnt out, or recently injured.
There were plenty of younger and fresher caps and inform players who could have been tested.
I am trying to think of a newbie found wanting at this level and all I can think of is Finau, and he still showed some glimpses.I totally agree, though the flip side of this of course, is that the newbies who have played are the cream of the crop. The forwards have been good all year, but definitely could have done with some fresh blood at 10 and 12... for whatever people think of DMac he isn't fresh blood. Could they have gone Lam? Obviously, whether he is the answer they won't know until they give them a go.
There should be plenty to play for in the Super season.
-
@frugby said in Italy v All Blacks:
@antipodean said in Italy v All Blacks:
@frugby said in Italy v All Blacks:
At the end of the day, this test means nothing, and regardless of what happens from here, is one nobody will remember. Lest we forget last time we played Italy in Italy, it was also a shitfest.
I think this was probably partly down to the fact a bunch of old guys didn't really fancy playing properly after a long tour in zero degrees temperatures.
This isn't exactly on the coach, because he wasn't the one kicking the ball, dropping it, failing to clear rucks etc.
Sure, if we ignore he selected and coached them.
It is not all his fault though is it.
I think this is a good lesson to Razor, that at the end of a long tour, a long season (our longest ever?) when you are about to play in zero degree temperatures, picking the old guys who can't wait to get back to their families isn't the play.
The key, and we will talk about this at length, is that Robertson learns from this season, and the evidence of his coaching career is that he will. Writing him off after a year is silly, asking for him to be sacked is silly. Let’s review things at the end of next year.
He needs to be ruthless going into next year for both players and coaching team. No more bros before hoes.
-
@KiwiMurph said in Italy v All Blacks:
@frugby said in Italy v All Blacks:
This isn't exactly on the coach, because he wasn't the one kicking the ball, dropping it, failing to clear rucks etc.
I always chuckle at statements like this.
If the performance of the team isn't on the coach then what is he there for? Vibes?
Tactics are for the coach, execution is for the players - although that is overly simplistic.
Beauden's silly kicks for instance - he has done them under Hansen, Foster and Robertson. He has done them all through Super Rugby. Let's be honest, that is how he likes to play rugby and no-one has ever coached it out of him. You can't put that on Robertson, although you can blame the selections.
-
@frugby said in Italy v All Blacks:
There should be plenty to play for in the Super season.
That's what we thought this year...
-
@Darth-Sader said in Italy v All Blacks:
@frugby said in Italy v All Blacks:
@antipodean said in Italy v All Blacks:
@frugby said in Italy v All Blacks:
At the end of the day, this test means nothing, and regardless of what happens from here, is one nobody will remember. Lest we forget last time we played Italy in Italy, it was also a shitfest.
I think this was probably partly down to the fact a bunch of old guys didn't really fancy playing properly after a long tour in zero degrees temperatures.
This isn't exactly on the coach, because he wasn't the one kicking the ball, dropping it, failing to clear rucks etc.
Sure, if we ignore he selected and coached them.
It is not all his fault though is it.
I think this is a good lesson to Razor, that at the end of a long tour, a long season (our longest ever?) when you are about to play in zero degree temperatures, picking the old guys who can't wait to get back to their families isn't the play.
The key, and we will talk about this at length, is that Robertson learns from this season, and the evidence of his coaching career is that he will. Writing him off after a year is silly, asking for him to be sacked is silly. Let’s review things at the end of next year.
He needs to be ruthless going into next year for both players and coaching team. No more bros before hoes.
Totally agree. Ball is in Robertson's court.
-
