Brumbies v Crusaders

[frugby]

@African-Monkey said in Brumbies v Crusaders:

@Bones I thought it was a penalty try, Strange denied the Brumbies chaser a chance to get there by doing something completely illegal. A dumb play.

Could be wrong, but isn't foul play in the in-goal area immediately just a penalty try?

Foul play to stop a try, regardless of whether a try would have been scored, is surely exactly what the first part of the sentence is, which by any measure should be a penalty try?

[African Monkey]

@frugby Yes I did think that too, but was being told otherwise, so who knows haha.

[booboo]

@KiwiMurph said in Brumbies v Crusaders:

@African-Monkey said in Brumbies v Crusaders:

@nzzp He had to release or reach out.

Why does he have to release when he was never held

But he never got back to his feet. He was OK to stand up, but not propel himself forward on the ground.

[booboo]

@African-Monkey said in Brumbies v Crusaders:

@Grooter People watch too much league.

FIFY

[booboo]

@Yeetyaah said in Brumbies v Crusaders:

Just been leaked to me that Quinten Strange has been approached by the One New Zealand Warriors to swap codes effective immediately.

Dumb enough to play for the Wahs

[booboo]

@frugby said in Brumbies v Crusaders:

Could be wrong, but isn't foul play in the in-goal area immediately just a penalty try?

Unless the law has changed. Was always preventing a "probable" try.

[booboo]

worldrugby.org

Search the Laws of the Game | World Rugby

Search the Laws of the Game of rugby union.

Penalty try: Awarded when, in the opinion of the referee, a try probably would have been scored (or scored in a more advantageous position) if not for an act of foul play by an opponent

[Bones]

@Old-Samurai-Jack said in Brumbies v Crusaders:

When Strange didn't catch a high pass in midfield, he threw his hands in the air in frustration, and started walking with his hands on his hips. WTF? This isn't club rugby. Where is the attitude?

He's a grade A knob jockey on the field, bit harsh to judge the rest of the team by him.

[booboo]

@Bones said in Brumbies v Crusaders:

@Old-Samurai-Jack said in Brumbies v Crusaders:

When Strange didn't catch a high pass in midfield, he threw his hands in the air in frustration, and started walking with his hands on his hips. WTF? This isn't club rugby. Where is the attitude?

He's a grade A knob jockey on the field, bit harsh to judge the rest of the team by him.

Am not judging his character, just his ability.

An adequate Super squaddie. Not a starter. An example.of player getting higher mention due to being in a successful team.

[Bones]

@booboo it all started with this and his tough guy antics get more cowardly every season.

[Machpants]

He has been mentioned in several AB squads by the press, they are high on Old Crusader Spice.

[Damo]

@African-Monkey said in Brumbies v Crusaders:

@Bones Well he should have removed all doubt by not punching the ball dead, and if he does it with the Brumbies player that close to the ball which he did, he left the refs with no choice. It was a complete brain explosion.

I do agree with this. It was stupid to put yourself in that position.

All he really needed to do was get his hand to it first and try to catch it. If he's trying to catch it and it goes dead then no big deal, it's a line drop out.