Ashes 2023

MN5

@KiwiMurph said in Ashes 2023:

@NTA said in Ashes 2023:

@Catogrande said in Ashes 2023:

The two issues that did bite us I think were that our attack was partially dependent upon two guys (Stokes and Moeen) that had not bowled much if at all in test cricket recently and were carrying fitness issues and then not taking the new ball when Lyons was the newish batsman (I refuse to say batter).

Forget all that; your fielding was poor. That's what cost you.

You need a better keeper and some of the boundary fielding ... Yikes...

I go back to my earlier comment about how a year with McCullum should produce better fielding...

You'd think a former keeper as coach would understand the value of wicketkeeping. Poor keepers/part time keepers are enough of a risk in ODI cricket let alone The Ashes.

Wonderful game of cricket.

The anticipation of Marnus to move early and get the catch of Brooks was huge.

England did pretty well when you consider that I don’t think many of this England team would crack a combined XI

Root, even then he doesn’t quite walk in as he may have a couple of years ago with the 3-5 they currently have.

An out of form Warner is still better value than either of their openers.

Stokes gets in ahead of Green for his leadership and big match temperament but maybe not in a year or two.

Bairstow doesn’t get past Carey on keeping.

If Anderson and Broad could be guaranteed to not break would either make it ahead of Cummins, Hazelwood or Boland ?

Dickhead persona aside Robinson is a chance.

So yeah, only Root would be a definite, possibly at the expense of Green to expand the batting. Every other Englishman is only a chance of making it at best.

MN5

@MajorRage said in Ashes 2023:

Outstanding test match.

For all the talk of Bazball, it could also be known as not good enough ball. England, pound for pound, are miles behind Australia when it comes to cricketing prowess in their top teams. Yet, they managed to almost pull off a seemingly unlikely victory.

Ultimately, they couldn't find a way through the number 8 and 9 batsman on a 5th day pitch with a new ball. Yes, it was a dead pitch and the batting conditions were favourable but they still should have been able to. I have no qualms about their batting, but their bowling simply isn't really up to taking 20 wickets.

Broad and Anderson won't be able to play all 5 tests at maximum attack, Robinson needs more miles under the clock to know how to really exploit things (his record is brilliant, but so is Kyle Jamiesons) & playing Ali, who hadn't bowled a test ball in years, showed the depth of spin.

I think Australa will be 2 nil up after 3 with the Ashes retained. Hope I'm wrong, but I just can't see the bowling attack making real inroads.

Fantastic test though, well played both teams. That dogged Australia never say die cricketing spirit took it in the end. An all time classic match.

Interesting, I reckon their batting is more of an issue than their bowling. Root is brilliant as the British press keep reminding us but the rest are journeymen or unproven ( still a question mark over Harry Brook for me after only eight tests )

Of course if Broad and Anderson break down you’re more correct than I am to be fair.

Catogrande

@barbarian said in Ashes 2023:

Great win. Can't quite believe we pulled it off. I've watched the Aussie cricket team on the losing end of these sorts of matches more times than I can count, as the bowling side and the batting side.

Jeez it feels like England lost the unloseable test though. At 8/390 on the afternoon of day 1, how do you lose a four day test?

For all the thrashing about Bazball, it's just poor cricket not to escape with at least a draw…

…Because while it's fun to play reckless cricket, I'd rather be 0-0 than 1-0 down.

For sure but in the past England would have gone meekly looking for a draw and still been in with a good chance of losing but zero chance of winning. We’ve had much previous criticism of not being aggressive enough and rightly so. For now I’m very happy with the overall approach but gnash my teeth about some of the individual actions. Finding a balance will be key, but for now, as an Englishman I’m just enjoying the journey (c: J Mitchell. 2003).

mariner4life

@barbarian dunno, this post seems very good with the benefit of hindsight

But when they had Aus 8/220 needing 280, and only the bowlers left, at that point you could easily have said they had played it perfect

Undone by a 60 run 9th wicket partnership. I think that says less about approach and more about options available in the attack

barbarian

@Catogrande said in Ashes 2023:

@barbarian said in Ashes 2023:

Great win. Can't quite believe we pulled it off. I've watched the Aussie cricket team on the losing end of these sorts of matches more times than I can count, as the bowling side and the batting side.

Jeez it feels like England lost the unloseable test though. At 8/390 on the afternoon of day 1, how do you lose a four day test?

For all the thrashing about Bazball, it's just poor cricket not to escape with at least a draw…

…Because while it's fun to play reckless cricket, I'd rather be 0-0 than 1-0 down.

For sure but in the past England would have gone meekly looking for a draw and still been in with a good chance of losing but zero chance of winning. We’ve had much previous criticism of not being aggressive enough and rightly so. For now I’m very happy with the overall approach but gnash my teeth about some of the individual actions. Finding a balance will be key, but for now, as an Englishman I’m just enjoying the journey (c: J Mitchell. 2003).

I see what you mean, but it's not like England were hopeless before McCullum came along. They haven't lost a home Ashes since 2002.

barbarian

@mariner4life said in Ashes 2023:

@barbarian dunno, this post seems very good with the benefit of hindsight

But when they had Aus 8/220 needing 280, and only the bowlers left, at that point you could easily have said they had played it perfect

Undone by a 60 run 9th wicket partnership. I think that says less about approach and more about options available in the attack

Yep fair point. But I think there's a world where an Australian victory is off the table at that point as a possible outcome. All hypothetical I suppose.

NTA

Language warning:

Facebook

KiwiPie

@barbarian That's a good point. Ashes results in England, England's score first

2005: 2-1
2009: 2-1
2013: 3-0
2015: 3-2
2019: 2-2 (first shared Ashes series since 1972)

Donsteppa

Can't be many Tests in recent years where Australia win with Labuschagne and Smith contributing only 35 runs.

Duluth

Maybe see what Starc can do in the next Test?

NTA

@Duluth said in Ashes 2023:

Maybe see what Starc can do in the next Test?

Will depend on the pitch. Slope at Lords is always interesting.

Changing horses mid race tho? 🤔

MN5

@NTA said in Ashes 2023:

@Duluth said in Ashes 2023:

Maybe see what Starc can do in the next Test?

Will depend on the pitch. Slope at Lords is always interesting.

Changing horses mid race tho? 🤔

Starc is a very good bowler but behind Hazelwood and Cummins. Gives that nice left handed variation though.

Handy low order batsman too which should be a factor in selection.

MN5

@Donsteppa said in Ashes 2023:

Can't be many Tests in recent years where Australia win with Labuschagne and Smith contributing only 35 runs.

Yep. Both due massive scores this series which should worry England.

….and I’m probably the only one saying this but I reckon Warner is due too.

Victor Meldrew

Cricket doesn't do much for me anymore, but have to admit enjoyed that last day. Might even follow the Lord's Test more closely as this series has all the elements of 2005.

And Ollie Roberson & McCullum seem to like being hostages to fortune:

Robinson revealed that, so buoyant were England after the two-wicket defeat at 7.21pm on day five, the head coach Brendon McCullum said it felt like a victory.

“Baz said it after the game, ‘It feels like we’ve won, lads’. We’ve entertained the world, and we’ve put the Aussies on the back foot. For him to say that after a loss is quite significant for us.

“We were surprised to see Australia so defensive from ball one. You just don’t see the Australians cautious and on the back foot like that. As soon as we saw the field for that first over, we felt like we had a hold on them.

“And then came that first shot from Zak Crawley. Broady [Stuart Broad] said it’s his favourite ever Ashes moment. The noise, the sound, the crowd, it was just amazing to witness, and the roar in the dressing room was so loud, you’d have thought we’d won the series already.