AFL 2023
-
Ah the Brownlow. Every year the same thing.
This year Lachie Neale wins it because he's the best player in a team that finished 2nd, and played lots of games. And the salt, sand and tears from Victoria are delicious.
It's a midfielders medal you clowns. The guy who gets heaps and heaps of it, especially from clearances, is going to poll the votes off the umps every week. It's the same every year. It was the same last year where Cripps won it despite playing in a team that came 9th. It'll be the same next year.
Forwards kicking bags doesn't matter, and hasn't for as long as i have been watching.
-
the other news is North are getting 3 additional first-round draft picks (1 this year and 2 next year) and a couple of extra rookie spots, because they suck.
Not sure how i feel about it TBH. North need some help, but there are a lot of clubs that are just on the treadmill that probably do as well. Free Agency really works for some teams, but not others. Climbing the ladder is fucking tough. The Lions did it, but we nailed the draft and the trades year after year to do it. And then we got good enough people wanted to come. That's the problem. Players will only go to you if you are already good, or you regularly play in front of huge crowds at the 'G
North are neither of these
-
Brownlow result is farcical but as you say M4L it's designed to provide that result each year.
You can see it from a few angles. Dally M is much more accurate but also much less fun. So why don't we just accept that this is all just a dumb game and lean in to the madness of it all? It's much better that way IMO.
Lachie Neale wasn't the best player this year. He wasn't even in the top 10. But that's not what the Brownlow is, so get over it and have a laugh.
-
I watched the Swans final home and away game and Errol was on fire. 40+ possessions, a couple of goals - but didn’t get the 3 votes.
For me Neale was consistent - so best, nah. Fairest, perhaps. Consistent, yep.
-
@ACT-Crusader said in AFL 2023:
I watched the Swans final home and away game and Errol was on fire. 40+ possessions, a couple of goals - but didn’t get the 3 votes.
yeah....more than a few comments on the swans forums along these lines
-
that's exactly it. Lachie Neale was good to great every week. Got heaps of ball. And thus won votes. I watch every Lions game, did i think he would win it? No. But am i really surprised? Also no.
Dunkly, Cameron, Andrews, 2nd half of the year McCluggage, fuck even Cam Rayner at points all contributed heavily to our season, but polled fuck all. Contested ball beasts win Brownlow votesRemember the first couple of rounds where Jeremy Cameron was the best player in the comp? Stacks of ball, kicking bags. Did he even get a BOG? No, because he's not in the midfield.
-
@barbarian said in AFL 2023:
He wasn't even in the top 10
whoa hang on. Not top 10? He came 5th in the coaches votes as well.
-
@mariner4life I’m just glad that I got to watch every Saints game the season this happened
-
@mariner4life Yep but that's a midfielders award as well. He's not in my personal top 10. Which doesn't mean much in the grand scheme of things.
As a Carlton fan, Cripps in the Brownlow top 10 is absurd. Wasn't even in Carlton's best three this year (Curnow, Weitering, Cerra).
-
contested ball beast!
-
Go the Bronc...Lions
-
The quality of this game is off the charts.
Lesssgoooo Lions
-
Good game.
But boo.
-
Dumbest 50m penalty
Cost them the game
-
I hate it when Collingwood win.
-
What a game
I'm fucking shattered, but what a game
-
Congratulations Collingwood you guys were so good
-
@ACT-Crusader said in AFL 2023:
I hate it when Collingwood win.
At least Melbourne petty crime will be down.
(Drunken assaults up)
-
@ACT-Crusader said in AFL 2023:
I hate it when Collingwood win.
At least Melbourne petty crime will be down.
(Drunken assaults up)
And tattoo parlour business increase
-
thats probably the best final ive seen...personally dislike Collingwood but one of my best mates a ride or die collingwood so happy for him....he moved to german earlier in the year so hes a bit gutted to have missed it, have to get some collingwood merch to take him in Jan
