Rebels v Hurricanes
-
I watched the whole thing live (on TV).
He walked in to separate things, then literally rag dolled a bloke out which escalated it then lost his head when given the YC.
IF somebody does a hit and run, should we be lauding him for indicating to turn a a corner before the hit and run?
I have no comment on if the YC was deserved. For the rag doll, perhaps not, but the ref says it was for repeat offence. No view on that one as only got one eye on the first 30 mins of the game.
-
@MajorRage said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
@MajorRage said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
@BerhamporeNinja said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
Wow oh wow thought I've seen it all
Ardie was trying to calm the situation . Ref is handling it well đArdie was trying to calm the situation?
What coverage are you watching? He saw the red mist and lost his head.
@antipodean said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
@MajorRage said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
@BerhamporeNinja said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
Wow oh wow thought I've seen it all
Ardie was trying to calm the situation . Ref is handling it well đArdie was trying to calm the situation?
What coverage are you watching? He saw the red mist and lost his head.
Perhaps watch the 15 seconds prior to that.
I watched the whole thing live (on TV).
Try again with your eyes open this time.
He walked in to separate things, then literally rag dolled a bloke out which escalated it then lost his head when given the YC.
He did nothing at first other than exhorting players not to escalate. Somehow the Rebels five eighth is in there and Ardie rightly flings him out. Doleman considers that action as Ardie is "third player in escalating". That's his explanation. His words.
IF somebody does a hit and run, should be lauding him for indicating to turn a a corner before the hit and run?
Shit analogy is shit.
-
@ACT-Crusader said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
Coles and a Rebels player were going at it. In rush several players mainly Canes players first. Thereâs a pile on of sorts. Rebels players trying to get their man. Canes players trying to get Coles. Jules was getting into and Ardie just comes in and flings a player. Unnecessary in my view, but it happened.
Ardie was unhappy with the YC and made a beeline for the halfback đ
I just rewatched as I couldnât work out what happened first time.
Coles most likely mouthed off but it was Blue 4 that took him to ground off the ball and after the whistle. It was more than the refs âpush and shoveâ. Coles was having his head pushed hard into the ground by Blue 4.
The escalation happened from Blue who all kept marching forward at yellow who were standing still. Blue 10 in particular fought his way through from the back to be standing right over Coles. Ardie looked to pull him away before he stepped on prone heads.
All bullshit stuff but I donât think the officials got it right. Nothing escalated after Ardie yanked the player away. -
-
What you mean to say is "Agree to Disagree".
-
Nice patient start to the half by the Canes, unlucky not to get the try there.
-
Rebels defence on their heels. But they did well to hold up Aumua who usually scores in those situations.
-
@NTA said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
It balances out the YC that should never have been given to Wilkin.
Doleman is just meh.
Yes he is, but that's a clear YC. As Ayoub once famously said; "if there was a snake in there..."
-
Now one of the ARâs trying to make a name themselves. YC.
-
@ACT-Crusader said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
Now one of the ARâs trying to make a name themselves. YC.
What the fuck, there was nothing in that.
-
-
@MajorRage said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
What you mean to say is "Agree to Disagree".
I'm not arguing with you, I'm telling you: Your take is wrong.
-
@Canes4life said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
@ACT-Crusader said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
Now one of the ARâs trying to make a name themselves. YC.
What the fuck, there was nothing in that.
Fair enough IMO. Canât dive on a prone player with your arm tucked. The head contact may have been accidental but the act that caused it was dumb
-
@Nepia said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
Thatâs not consistent after the shot on JB wasnât even looked at.
And a good case can be made that the one on Jordie would've met the RC threshold.
-
@Crucial said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
@Canes4life said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
@ACT-Crusader said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
Now one of the ARâs trying to make a name themselves. YC.
What the fuck, there was nothing in that.
Fair enough IMO. Canât dive on a prone player with your arm tucked. The head contact may have been accidental but the act that caused it was dumb
I think it was just clumsy, he was trying to help Aumua over the line. Definitely not a red.
-
@Canes4life said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
@Crucial said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
@Canes4life said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
@ACT-Crusader said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
Now one of the ARâs trying to make a name themselves. YC.
What the fuck, there was nothing in that.
Fair enough IMO. Canât dive on a prone player with your arm tucked. The head contact may have been accidental but the act that caused it was dumb
I think it was just clumsy, he was trying to help Aumua over the line. Definitely not a red.
It isnât a red (yet)
Aumua was well over the line. He was well late
-
@Canes4life said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
@Crucial said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
@Canes4life said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
@ACT-Crusader said in Rebels v Hurricanes:
Now one of the ARâs trying to make a name themselves. YC.
What the fuck, there was nothing in that.
Fair enough IMO. Canât dive on a prone player with your arm tucked. The head contact may have been accidental but the act that caused it was dumb
I think it was just clumsy, he was trying to help Aumua over the line. Definitely not a red.
Clumsy can still be red.
