All Blacks 2023
-
@Bovidae said in All Blacks 2023:
Carlos also wants Barrett and DMac in the 23, the latter starting at fullback.
And there every chance they will be, as Carlos says they will need some experience when things get tight. See I'm one that doesn't see Jordan as an option at 15, mainly because the last test I saw him play, (on wing I know) he had no interest in taking high balls, and that worries the f*** out of me at test level. But almost guarantee that RMo, DMac and BB will go to WC, in whatever position or whatever I not sure though at this satge of season I think RMo is starting 10, and I say that thinking that from what I have seen we will not be running a 10 who will be in top 2-3 in world.
-
@Dan54 said in All Blacks 2023:
@Bovidae said in All Blacks 2023:
Carlos also wants Barrett and DMac in the 23, the latter starting at fullback.
And there every chance they will be, as Carlos says they will need some experience when things get tight. See I'm one that doesn't see Jordan as an option at 15, mainly because the last test I saw him play, (on wing I know) he had no interest in taking high balls, and that worries the f* out of me at test level**. But almost guarantee that RMo, DMac and BB will go to WC, in whatever position or whatever I not sure though at this satge of season I think RMo is starting 10, and I say that thinking that from what I have seen we will not be running a 10 who will be in top 2-3 in world.
What are you talking about? Avoiding high balls? BS! He could have been more accurate in some instances for sure but avoiding high balls? Nope.
-
@Old-Samurai-Jack said in All Blacks 2023:
@Dan54 said in All Blacks 2023:
@Bovidae said in All Blacks 2023:
Carlos also wants Barrett and DMac in the 23, the latter starting at fullback.
And there every chance they will be, as Carlos says they will need some experience when things get tight. See I'm one that doesn't see Jordan as an option at 15, mainly because the last test I saw him play, (on wing I know) he had no interest in taking high balls, and that worries the f* out of me at test level**. But almost guarantee that RMo, DMac and BB will go to WC, in whatever position or whatever I not sure though at this satge of season I think RMo is starting 10, and I say that thinking that from what I have seen we will not be running a 10 who will be in top 2-3 in world.
What are you talking about? Avoiding high balls? BS! He could have been more accurate in some instances for sure but avoiding high balls? Nope.
Mate I only saying the last time I saw him in a test match, was at Wellington against Ireland, and he looked to have no interest at all, he scored one great try, but almost seemed not interested for the other 79.5 minutes of game. I actually wondered if he was injured,, I a Jordan fan, but had to agree with fella behind me who noticed it too. I must admit I haven't rewatched game on tv to see if anything stood out there, but at game I was buggered if I know what seemed to be wrong. As I said I like the bugger as a player, but think he more suited to wing. I also think we forget how highly all the coaches and players seem to regard players in 15 who can call the shots and let 10 know whats they see in gaps etc.
-
@Canes4life said in All Blacks 2023:
@mariner4life said in All Blacks 2023:
@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks 2023:
@mariner4life to me DMac is the best 10 option. At least Carlos has some interesting takes instead of the usual rubbish on the Breakdown.
IMO DMac brings the same set of problems to test match rugby that Mo'unga does. That's the fucking problem. DMac maybe a better field kicker (certainly was last time they played each other) but there's fuck all in it. The main difference i see is that DMac isn't afraid to run in the tight channels.
I wouldn't start him at 15 either.
I wouldn't pick BB at all.
Agreed on BB, his form over the last couple years doesn't warrant selection in that 23.
If I was the coach right now and the WC was tomorrow, I would be picking Stevenson at fullback (with Jordan absent) and DMac at 10. They've clearly been the best in those positions this year. I also feel like McKenzie's stint away from NZ has made him far less erratic in his decision making.
I was a tad concerned the way Stevenson didn't involve himself much in the game against the Blues. Maybe play just didn't go his way and it wasn't his fault, but it's hard to shake a reputation. I don't think he can afford too many more big games like that.
-
@Crazy-Horse said in All Blacks 2023:
@Canes4life said in All Blacks 2023:
@mariner4life said in All Blacks 2023:
@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks 2023:
@mariner4life to me DMac is the best 10 option. At least Carlos has some interesting takes instead of the usual rubbish on the Breakdown.
IMO DMac brings the same set of problems to test match rugby that Mo'unga does. That's the fucking problem. DMac maybe a better field kicker (certainly was last time they played each other) but there's fuck all in it. The main difference i see is that DMac isn't afraid to run in the tight channels.
I wouldn't start him at 15 either.
I wouldn't pick BB at all.
Agreed on BB, his form over the last couple years doesn't warrant selection in that 23.
If I was the coach right now and the WC was tomorrow, I would be picking Stevenson at fullback (with Jordan absent) and DMac at 10. They've clearly been the best in those positions this year. I also feel like McKenzie's stint away from NZ has made him far less erratic in his decision making.
I was a tad concerned the way Stevenson didn't involve himself much in the game against the Blues. Maybe play just didn't go his way and it wasn't his fault, but it's hard to shake a reputation. I don't think he can afford too many more big games like that.
which would be an absolutely valid comment if he was trying to force his way past a star who was owning the spot
but to rule a guy out on a quiet game means you are happy to go back to the guy playing ordinary football just because you know him. And unfortunately for NZ rugby, i have a sneaky suspicion that this is actually how our selectors think.
-
@mariner4life said in All Blacks 2023:
@Crazy-Horse said in All Blacks 2023:
@Canes4life said in All Blacks 2023:
@mariner4life said in All Blacks 2023:
@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks 2023:
@mariner4life to me DMac is the best 10 option. At least Carlos has some interesting takes instead of the usual rubbish on the Breakdown.
IMO DMac brings the same set of problems to test match rugby that Mo'unga does. That's the fucking problem. DMac maybe a better field kicker (certainly was last time they played each other) but there's fuck all in it. The main difference i see is that DMac isn't afraid to run in the tight channels.
I wouldn't start him at 15 either.
I wouldn't pick BB at all.
Agreed on BB, his form over the last couple years doesn't warrant selection in that 23.
If I was the coach right now and the WC was tomorrow, I would be picking Stevenson at fullback (with Jordan absent) and DMac at 10. They've clearly been the best in those positions this year. I also feel like McKenzie's stint away from NZ has made him far less erratic in his decision making.
I was a tad concerned the way Stevenson didn't involve himself much in the game against the Blues. Maybe play just didn't go his way and it wasn't his fault, but it's hard to shake a reputation. I don't think he can afford too many more big games like that.
which would be an absolutely valid comment if he was trying to force his way past a star who was owning the spot
but to rule a guy out on a quiet game means you are happy to go back to the guy playing ordinary football just because you know him. And unfortunately for NZ rugby, i have a sneaky suspicion that this is actually how our selectors think.
I don't think that game would have ruled him out by any stretch. But I don't think it would have gone unnoticed.
-
@Crazy-Horse It was a strange game in that the Blues dominated possession and territory, particularly in the 2nd half (75%), so Stevenson spent that 40 mins mostly defending. He did make the last pass for Narawa's second try in the 1st half, and was involved in denying Papalii a try in the 2nd half.
-
@Crazy-Horse said in All Blacks 2023:
@mariner4life said in All Blacks 2023:
@Crazy-Horse said in All Blacks 2023:
@Canes4life said in All Blacks 2023:
@mariner4life said in All Blacks 2023:
@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks 2023:
@mariner4life to me DMac is the best 10 option. At least Carlos has some interesting takes instead of the usual rubbish on the Breakdown.
IMO DMac brings the same set of problems to test match rugby that Mo'unga does. That's the fucking problem. DMac maybe a better field kicker (certainly was last time they played each other) but there's fuck all in it. The main difference i see is that DMac isn't afraid to run in the tight channels.
I wouldn't start him at 15 either.
I wouldn't pick BB at all.
Agreed on BB, his form over the last couple years doesn't warrant selection in that 23.
If I was the coach right now and the WC was tomorrow, I would be picking Stevenson at fullback (with Jordan absent) and DMac at 10. They've clearly been the best in those positions this year. I also feel like McKenzie's stint away from NZ has made him far less erratic in his decision making.
I was a tad concerned the way Stevenson didn't involve himself much in the game against the Blues. Maybe play just didn't go his way and it wasn't his fault, but it's hard to shake a reputation. I don't think he can afford too many more big games like that.
which would be an absolutely valid comment if he was trying to force his way past a star who was owning the spot
but to rule a guy out on a quiet game means you are happy to go back to the guy playing ordinary football just because you know him. And unfortunately for NZ rugby, i have a sneaky suspicion that this is actually how our selectors think.
I don't think that game would have ruled him out by any stretch. But I don't think it would have gone unnoticed.
I do tink with Stevenson also will be how word comes back to selectors on his communication skills, which as I said ealier is held in pretty high regard by selectors etc.
-
I hope they go with Stevenson, but it would be considered a massive call if history is to go by anything to select a brand new fullback for a RWC campaign. This isn’t the wing (or centre), it’s one of our most critical positions in the way the ABs play.
Do they go back to Mo’unga and DMac starting? They’ve started 7 tests together (3x Oz, Italy USA, Fiji, Tonga) and haven’t lost but the opposition suggests it hasn’t been their thinking in the ‘big’ tests.
-
@Dan54 said in All Blacks 2023:
@Old-Samurai-Jack said in All Blacks 2023:
@Dan54 said in All Blacks 2023:
@Bovidae said in All Blacks 2023:
Carlos also wants Barrett and DMac in the 23, the latter starting at fullback.
And there every chance they will be, as Carlos says they will need some experience when things get tight. See I'm one that doesn't see Jordan as an option at 15, mainly because the last test I saw him play, (on wing I know) he had no interest in taking high balls, and that worries the f* out of me at test level**. But almost guarantee that RMo, DMac and BB will go to WC, in whatever position or whatever I not sure though at this satge of season I think RMo is starting 10, and I say that thinking that from what I have seen we will not be running a 10 who will be in top 2-3 in world.
What are you talking about? Avoiding high balls? BS! He could have been more accurate in some instances for sure but avoiding high balls? Nope.
Mate I only saying the last time I saw him in a test match, was at Wellington against Ireland, and he looked to have no interest at all, he scored one great try, but almost seemed not interested for the other 79.5 minutes of game. I actually wondered if he was injured,, I a Jordan fan, but had to agree with fella behind me who noticed it too. I must admit I haven't rewatched game on tv to see if anything stood out there, but at game I was buggered if I know what seemed to be wrong. As I said I like the bugger as a player, but think he more suited to wing. I also think we forget how highly all the coaches and players seem to regard players in 15 who can call the shots and let 10 know whats they see in gaps etc.
Do you remember when we played South Africa in 2022 and we dropped a whole heap of defensive high balls?
I told y'all I didn't think Jordan dropped any - except very early he caught one, took two steps and lost the ball in contact. You told me I hadn't watched the game closely enough.
I went back and re-watched - and got interrupted so missed 10minutes or so, but what was evident was Jordie was catching (or dropping) almost everything on the right hand side.
Will was leaving them to Jordie.
Since I haven't noticed Will struggling under the high ball for the Crusaders, I'm inclined to think this is tactical - to have probably our best broken field runner available to receive the pass infield rather than making the pass infield.
-
@Chris-B https://www.msn.com/en-au/sport/other/it-s-there-for-him-cam-roigard-continues-to-stake-all-blacks-claim/ar-AA19EZBU?ocid=ACERDHP17&pc=ACTE&cvid=68ce0e187c134d3dab37ef21d42e52b8&ei=16
He has experience at 10 could he be a future option? Has a more than descent kicking game.
-
@SBW1 Not sure why you've tagged me since I don't think I've commented on Roigard.
A wise choice though - @Nepia knows I've been the expert halfback analyst since the days of Andy Ellis!
I like the look of him though - promising allrounder. He's got good size and might be able to add a few kgs and play that 4th loose forward type halfback role as well as having decent distribution and running.
-
@Dan54 Roger that. If a winger was gunshy on taking the high ball though, I don't want them anywhere near the ABs. You know what is coming in France and we need a "bomb-squad version 2" out there. I think Jordan commits himself to take the high ball without hesitation (from what I have seen) but the ABs seem to take a "hope for the best" approach. This makes all the high ball takers in the ABs look incompetent. J. Barrett, Jordan, Clarke, etc.
Here is my argument., and I have mentioned it before. Watch SA, Ireland, France etc, and the jumper is usually not committed to catching, just disrupting. A fingertip will do. The non-jumpers will put themselves in positions to take advantage of any messy ball, scoop it up, and get the ball back. In contrast, the AB patterns under the high ball have been just a mess in the Foster era. When the ball is disrupted by the opposition (most of the time these days) nobody is positioned to clean it up. -
@Old-Samurai-Jack We clearly changed - or at least Will did - our tactics after that first SA test, where the SA jumpers got in our faces and caused a lot of drops.
In subsequent tests, Will stopped trying as much to catch offensive high balls and concentrated on getting a hand up to disrupt.
He got criticized for that as well!
-
@ACT-Crusader said in All Blacks 2023:
I hope they go with Stevenson, but it would be considered a massive call if history is to go by anything to select a brand new fullback for a RWC campaign. This isn’t the wing (or centre), it’s one of our most critical positions in the way the ABs play.
Do they go back to Mo’unga and DMac starting? They’ve started 7 tests together (3x Oz, Italy USA, Fiji, Tonga) and haven’t lost but the opposition suggests it hasn’t been their thinking in the ‘big’ tests.
Pity we can't just clone Jordie.
But, I'm not convinced he's more crucial at 2nd five than at fullback.
-
@Chris-B said in All Blacks 2023:
@ACT-Crusader said in All Blacks 2023:
I hope they go with Stevenson, but it would be considered a massive call if history is to go by anything to select a brand new fullback for a RWC campaign. This isn’t the wing (or centre), it’s one of our most critical positions in the way the ABs play.
Do they go back to Mo’unga and DMac starting? They’ve started 7 tests together (3x Oz, Italy USA, Fiji, Tonga) and haven’t lost but the opposition suggests it hasn’t been their thinking in the ‘big’ tests.
Pity we can't just clone Jordie.
But, I'm not convinced he's more crucial at 2nd five than at fullback.
The least Smiley Barrett could have done would be to have twins. Gordy Barrett has a nice ring to it.
I mean, he’s contributed to the All Black legacy but let’s be honest, he could have done more.
-
@Chris-B said in All Blacks 2023:
@ACT-Crusader said in All Blacks 2023:
I hope they go with Stevenson, but it would be considered a massive call if history is to go by anything to select a brand new fullback for a RWC campaign. This isn’t the wing (or centre), it’s one of our most critical positions in the way the ABs play.
Do they go back to Mo’unga and DMac starting? They’ve started 7 tests together (3x Oz, Italy USA, Fiji, Tonga) and haven’t lost but the opposition suggests it hasn’t been their thinking in the ‘big’ tests.
Pity we can't just clone Jordie.
But, I'm not convinced he's more crucial at 2nd five than at fullback.
What's your reasoning?
To me Jordie is far more suited to 12 + we have more depth at fullback than 12.
While Jordie is great under the high ball to me he wasn't quick enough to make his own breaks at fullback and wasn't a fullback that set up other players in attack. To me his size and direct game is more effective and a better decision maker in the confined spaces of midfield and closer to the ruck
-
Jordie at fullback is a defensive move, I see the merit, but I don't see us beating the top sides with a defensive mindset. We're gonna need to throw caution to the wind at this RWC, so players like Jordan are going to be critical to our chances.
@Chris-B was that the game Bridge had a shocker under the high ball? If so I agree with your assessment, I think the plan was for Bridge and Jordie to field the kicks and set Jordan loose from the back to counter that tactic. I think I remember them talking about selecting Bridge for that exact reason, but then Bridge dropped one early and lost all confidence, so Jordie was charging around trying to catch everything.
-
@KiwiMurph I'm not particularly concerned about depth at fullback.
Who is the first choice?
