Foster, Robertson etc
-
@His-Bobness said in Foster:
Excellent analysis in the Roar by ‘Highlander’ on Foster’s incomprehensible single-minded devotion to helter-skelter play that pays little heed to what the opposition will bring to the game. We have seen this so many times now, it raises questions about the man’s intelligence:
“The Foster iteration of the All Blacks has no identity, and even when they show periods of high-quality international rugby, it is not maintained and this reversion to helter-skelter nonsense just repeats ad nauseam from a side that simply does not have the skillset to play the way the way they are pursuing. For mine, this ill-directed game plan has an inbuilt negative multiplier of poor selection, both in personnel and positions.”
And a thought provoking quote in the comments -
"Was it just me [too many red wines] thinking that the AB backline was standing noticeably flatter this week than they were at Ellis Park. If I am right this must have been a coaching instruction from our new attack coach. During Schmidt’s time with Ireland it was a feature of their game that the backline had a very flat alignment. I thought the great strength of the ABs at Ellis Park was the extra depth of the backline enabling Mounga and Havili time to play to their strengths. I wonder if Schmidt is going to be the game changer for the ABs so many posters on here thought he would be. So far [and I know there has only been one game] the prospects don’t look promising. At the end of his time with Ireland they were being beaten by teams like Japan and the comment was being made that their game plan was very predictable. Some of the players subsequently made the point that Schmidt was extremely stubborn and refused to change. Sound familiar. Perhaps he and Foster were made for each other. It certainly looked so on Saturday night."
Yep noticed that flat alignment and wondered why the change from what we achieved at Ellis Park.
It certainly made a significant difference in a negative way standing really flat. -
@His-Bobness said in Foster:
Excellent analysis in the Roar by ‘Highlander’
Why does a rugby pundit find it necessary to write under a moniker?
Some good points but Foster seemed as pissed off as anyone that Mounga put the kicking game away.
The biggest failure is the latitude given to players to play what is in front of them when they have shown time and time again that that arent very astute. -
@His-Bobness said in Foster:
Excellent analysis in the Roar by ‘Highlander’
Why does a rugby pundit find it necessary to write under a moniker?
Some good points but Foster seemed as pissed off as anyone that Mounga put the kicking game away.
The biggest failure is the latitude given to players to play what is in front of them when they have shown time and time again that that arent very astute.Who is it? I just assumed a normal forum name
-
@Machpants said in Foster:
@His-Bobness said in Foster:
Excellent analysis in the Roar by ‘Highlander’
Why does a rugby pundit find it necessary to write under a moniker?
Some good points but Foster seemed as pissed off as anyone that Mounga put the kicking game away.
The biggest failure is the latitude given to players to play what is in front of them when they have shown time and time again that that arent very astute.Who is it? I just assumed a normal forum name
You may be correct. I don't know how the Roar works. Is it a combination of journalists and posters that think they are?
-
@Machpants said in Foster:
@His-Bobness said in Foster:
Excellent analysis in the Roar by ‘Highlander’
Why does a rugby pundit find it necessary to write under a moniker?
Some good points but Foster seemed as pissed off as anyone that Mounga put the kicking game away.
The biggest failure is the latitude given to players to play what is in front of them when they have shown time and time again that that arent very astute.Who is it? I just assumed a normal forum name
You may be correct. I don't know how the Roar works. Is it a combination of journalists and posters that think they are?
Yeah I'm a GURU cos I've written an article, you submit and it can get published
-
@His-Bobness said in Foster:
Excellent analysis in the Roar by ‘Highlander’ on Foster’s incomprehensible single-minded devotion to helter-skelter play that pays little heed to what the opposition will bring to the game. We have seen this so many times now, it raises questions about the man’s intelligence:
“The Foster iteration of the All Blacks has no identity, and even when they show periods of high-quality international rugby, it is not maintained and this reversion to helter-skelter nonsense just repeats ad nauseam from a side that simply does not have the skillset to play the way the way they are pursuing. For mine, this ill-directed game plan has an inbuilt negative multiplier of poor selection, both in personnel and positions.”
IMO that's a pretty ignorant analysis. In this interview Foster highlights that there were tactical options which ought to be adopted, the implication being that it was NOT the coaches' instruction to play 'helter-skelter'. All in all I think Foster makes cogent points and handled this presser well:
-
@His-Bobness said in Foster:
Excellent analysis in the Roar by ‘Highlander’
Why does a rugby pundit find it necessary to write under a moniker?
Some good points but Foster seemed as pissed off as anyone that Mounga put the kicking game away.
The biggest failure is the latitude given to players to play what is in front of them when they have shown time and time again that that arent very astute.Its not a moniker. He was born at the end of 1986, his parents having had fun times after watching Lambert and Connery in action.
As a side note, the totally unsubstantiated rumours about Razor and Ryan falling out should be let go until there is actual confirmation. Razor seems to be constantly subjected to unsubstantiated rumour these days.
-
@His-Bobness said in Foster:
Excellent analysis in the Roar by ‘Highlander’ on Foster’s incomprehensible single-minded devotion to helter-skelter play that pays little heed to what the opposition will bring to the game. We have seen this so many times now, it raises questions about the man’s intelligence:
“The Foster iteration of the All Blacks has no identity, and even when they show periods of high-quality international rugby, it is not maintained and this reversion to helter-skelter nonsense just repeats ad nauseam from a side that simply does not have the skillset to play the way the way they are pursuing. For mine, this ill-directed game plan has an inbuilt negative multiplier of poor selection, both in personnel and positions.”
IMO that's a pretty ignorant analysis. In this interview Foster highlights that there were tactical options which ought to be adopted, the implication being that it was NOT the coaches' instruction to play 'helter-skelter'. All in all I think Foster makes cogent points and handled this presser well:
The guy talks the talk but his results never match the dialogue.
-
@Billy-Tell said in Foster:
the totally unsubstantiated rumours about Razor and Ryan falling out should be let go until there is actual confirmation.
You are not going to get confirmation as its in house.
100% correct from the Horses mouth. -
@Billy-Tell said in Foster:
the totally unsubstantiated rumours about Razor and Ryan falling out should be let go until there is actual confirmation.
You are not going to get confirmation as its in house.
100% correct from the Horses mouth.Poll for which one is the horse?
-
@Billy-Tell said in Foster:
the totally unsubstantiated rumours about Razor and Ryan falling out should be let go until there is actual confirmation.
You are not going to get confirmation as its in house.
100% correct from the Horses mouth.Poll for which one is the horse?
Pretty easy to figure out .
-
@His-Bobness said in Foster:
Excellent analysis in the Roar by ‘Highlander’
Why does a rugby pundit find it necessary to write under a moniker?
Some good points but Foster seemed as pissed off as anyone that Mounga put the kicking game away.
The biggest failure is the latitude given to players to play what is in front of them when they have shown time and time again that that arent very astute.Maybe that's why Owen Farrell gets game time despite his obvious shortcomings.
-
@Billy-Tell said in Foster:
the totally unsubstantiated rumours about Razor and Ryan falling out should be let go until there is actual confirmation.
You are not going to get confirmation as its in house.
100% correct from the Horses mouth.Poll for which one is the horse?
Pretty easy to figure out .
Life’s too short for that sort of fluff.
-
-
Very clearly the leadership group is not functioning. For 40 mins it was doing all right then after a momentum swinger it appeared the leaders failed to grab the team by the scruff and change the plan to at least gain some dominance. Have the ABs even achieved a 50/22 yet since it's implementation?
-
@Billy-Tell said in Foster:
the totally unsubstantiated rumours about Razor and Ryan falling out should be let go until there is actual confirmation.
You are not going to get confirmation as its in house.
100% correct from the Horses mouth.Poll for which one is the horse?
Pretty easy to figure out .
Life’s too short for that sort of fluff.
Just think it’s not to hard or is it.
-
Think about who the leadership group are
Aaron Smith, Beaudy, Cane, Etc are involved
Quiet diminutive fellas .
Need some more McCaws, Reads , Carters that people will actually listen to.
Carter didn’t have to be hidden in the back field . He would put you on your arse and try and flog the ball .
We are hiding our tens in the back field and hooking our captain at 60 minutes.
It’s a shambles
-
I can't wait to see Ross Karl's reaction to this. He was proper steaming from the ears after SA1, calmed down a touch after SA2 but I fully expect him to go complete Red Ross.
-
@Billy-Tell said in Foster:
the totally unsubstantiated rumours about Razor and Ryan falling out should be let go until there is actual confirmation.
You are not going to get confirmation as its in house.
100% correct from the Horses mouth.Poll for which one is the horse?
Pretty easy to figure out .
Life’s too short for that sort of fluff.
Just think it’s not to hard or is it.
I believe I understand who you're fingering.
-
@Steve you’re right. We don’t have a good leader ship. We might have a leadership group but not based on their play on the park. The only leaders out there, from a playing perspective, in the pack are Ardie and ST and Cane to a lesser degree. Whitelock is great in the line outs but old around the park. SB might be close but I don’t remember his contribution last game. Maybe they need to invest in the future but Foster is adverse to change which part of his problem.
In the backs, if the goal was to get away from the healter skelter, Aaron Smith is not the guy. So he has a great pass. We need a halfback to play test footie and direct that that forward pack around the field. I can understand why he was pulled.
