All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test
-
-
@Duluth said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
@Crucial said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
I fully admit that I have no idea
Finally
should probably go under "The Silver Fern" header......
-
@Duluth said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
@Crucial said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
I fully admit that I have no idea
Finally
Nice edit.
Apt though and at least I admit it
-
@Kiwiwomble said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
@Machpants said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
@Derm-McCrum said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
Time for wild prediction of the week.
Ireland to win by 3.
Itâll be much closer for sure
im going the other way, under the roof, dry and fast track...AB's by 25
Me too but maybe not 25. Closer to 15.
-
-
@Tim said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
No way the ABs would do that, maybe the letter of the rules, but it is bloody stupid for a 36 year old who would have had many knocks over the years.
-
@Machpants It seems extremely irresponsible.
-
-
@Tim said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
@Machpants It seems extremely irresponsible.
and its not like its a RWC playoff or something...not that that would even be a good reason to risk someones health
-
@Tim said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
@Machpants It seems extremely irresponsible.
Actually I don't think it irresponsible if he didn't have concussion, which it seems he didn't, hell even as AB supporter I think Ireland would have appeared to done evryting to WR protocols, and can understand them as often a Dr can't make a definitive call on Concussion in 15 minutes! Take Sam W showed his symptoms next day. And here are how protocols are done ;
The HIA is World Rugbyâs three-step process to identifying a concussion.The in-game HIA 1 identifies a suspected concussion, which leads to a player being removed from a game.
But a failed HIA 1 is only officially recognised as a concussion if a player fails a more substantive HIA 2 after the match and the HIA 3, which takes place between 36-48 hours later.
-
@Dan54 Do you really think that one of those tests can demonstrate that a guy who had a head knock, was visibly shaken, and then failed the initial test, has avoided a brain injury because his team reported he was fine on tests later in the week? Better his brain than mine.
-
@Tim said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
@Dan54 Do you really think that one of those tests can demonstrate that a guy who had a head knock, was visibly shaken, and then failed the initial test, has avoided a brain injury because his team reported he was fine on tests later in the week? Better his brain than mine.
I would get it if we were talking a WC final, but they are taking a big risk with him just to try to win a test in NZ.
-
@Tim said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
@Dan54 Do you really think that one of those tests can demonstrate that a guy who had a head knock, was visibly shaken, and then failed the initial test, has avoided a brain injury because his team reported he was fine on tests later in the week? Better his brain than mine.
...a bloke with a history of head knocks...
-
@Dan54 said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
@Tim said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
@Machpants It seems extremely irresponsible.
Actually I don't think it irresponsible if he didn't have concussion, which it seems he didn't, hell even as AB supporter I think Ireland would have appeared to done evryting to WR protocols, and can understand them as often a Dr can't make a definitive call on Concussion in 15 minutes! Take Sam W showed his symptoms next day. And here are how protocols are done ;
The HIA is World Rugbyâs three-step process to identifying a concussion.The in-game HIA 1 identifies a suspected concussion, which leads to a player being removed from a game.
But a failed HIA 1 is only officially recognised as a concussion if a player fails a more substantive HIA 2 after the match and the HIA 3, which takes place between 36-48 hours later.
World Rugby issue statement on Johnny Sexton and HIA call
World Rugby has warned against âirresponsibleâ remote head-injury diagnosis in defending its Head Injury Assessment (HIA) protocols.
I thought this was an interesting point of view;
"Safety group Progressive Rugby insists, however, that any failure of HIA1 should lead medics to treat the playerâs future participation with âextreme cautionâ. âElite players who fail an in-game HIA1 have, by definition, displayed cognitive dysfunction requiring their removal,â said a Progressive Rugby spokesperson. âIn our view, this is sufficient evidence, regardless of subsequent testing, to exercise extreme caution for the good of both their short and long-term health.I think a history of head knocks, a failure of the HIA1 and his age should err on the side of caution. But since they rely on Sexton so much, they won't.
-
@Kirwan said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
@Dan54 said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
@Tim said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
@Machpants It seems extremely irresponsible.
Actually I don't think it irresponsible if he didn't have concussion, which it seems he didn't, hell even as AB supporter I think Ireland would have appeared to done evryting to WR protocols, and can understand them as often a Dr can't make a definitive call on Concussion in 15 minutes! Take Sam W showed his symptoms next day. And here are how protocols are done ;
The HIA is World Rugbyâs three-step process to identifying a concussion.The in-game HIA 1 identifies a suspected concussion, which leads to a player being removed from a game.
But a failed HIA 1 is only officially recognised as a concussion if a player fails a more substantive HIA 2 after the match and the HIA 3, which takes place between 36-48 hours later.
World Rugby issue statement on Johnny Sexton and HIA call
World Rugby has warned against âirresponsibleâ remote head-injury diagnosis in defending its Head Injury Assessment (HIA) protocols.
I thought this was an interesting point of view;
"Safety group Progressive Rugby insists, however, that any failure of HIA1 should lead medics to treat the playerâs future participation with âextreme cautionâ. âElite players who fail an in-game HIA1 have, by definition, displayed cognitive dysfunction requiring their removal,â said a Progressive Rugby spokesperson. âIn our view, this is sufficient evidence, regardless of subsequent testing, to exercise extreme caution for the good of both their short and long-term health.I think a history of head knocks, a failure of the HIA1 and his age should err on the side of caution. But since they rely on Sexton so much, they won't.
thats the whole thing isn't it, play it safe
-
Who else likes the look of our bench this week? Plenty of impact with the likes of Jordan, Fakatava, Taukeiâaho, Ross and PGS.
-
@Tim said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
@Dan54 Do you really think that one of those tests can demonstrate that a guy who had a head knock, was visibly shaken, and then failed the initial test, has avoided a brain injury because his team reported he was fine on tests later in the week? Better his brain than mine.
No what I am saying is protocols say Dr have 15 minutes to decide whether a player is concussed, and that perhaps is not enough ( I not a Dr so don't know) so if they suspect he is concussed he can't play until they know, which to me seems sensible otherwise Drs are under pressure to say, well I can't say he he concussed for sure so he can play. Do you think that is better? Same as Sam W having bo symptoms after game but testing positive next day. Don't get me wrong, I highly agree with the safety measures for HIA etc, but don't make it a final decision during game as it could work the other way.
I will add IF Sexton was concussed I think he should stand down. -
@TheMojoman said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
@Kiwiwomble said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
@Machpants said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
@Derm-McCrum said in All Blacks v Ireland - 2nd Test:
Time for wild prediction of the week.
Ireland to win by 3.
Itâll be much closer for sure
im going the other way, under the roof, dry and fast track...AB's by 25
Me too but maybe not 25. Closer to 15.
I'd be happy with a good, tight game where Ireland really step up the pressure, but we stay composed and with minimal mistakes like last week.
Being solid under pressure would be huge step forward.
-
I wish we had archives from years ago, as I'm sure it was posted here, but I recall listening to an interview with Dr Stephen Kara, the Blues Dr at the time (I'm thinking 7 or 8 years ago, maybe longer?) about HIA and the protocols back then, he talked of the initial cognitive test, and subsequent follow up testing...was interesting listening to it and sounded pretty thorough, but never 100% and you'd like to think they have made alot of progress in diagnosis since then too?
I always think about a super game where Sam Cane called an HIA on himself after a knock that wasnt picked up by anyone, even the cameras IIRC, cant recall if he passed/failed it though.
Stuff
