Highlanders 2023
-
Gilbert on the other hand has been talked about as being the quickest in the squad. He has the size and speed to be useful at centre. I suspect we will see Timu back at centre this weekend. If Bogado is fit we allow him to continue to develop on the wing. The team will never flourish with Hunt at 10. I would like to see more of CGB. He looked sharp before getting injured.
-
@friedrugby so keeping hunt who is universally considered a weak link...moving Gilbert and TUJ who have been solid and pretty awesome respectively...and then a FF Burns Timu front row in the second half....im not on board
-
@Kiwiwomble Only reason I say Hunt, is because Millar is injured, and I'm assuming Burns won't be ready to start straight away...
I don't rate Hunt, because his punting is pathetic.
-
@SouthernMann CGB can never stay fit, and is far too inconsistent. Not worth persisting with... if everyone was fit, I think this is probably our best side (or one I'd like to see at least)?
- de Groot
- Marshall
- Ainsley
- Parkinson
- Dickson
- Withy
- Harmon
- MMT
- Fakatava
- Burns
- Nareki
- Umaga-Jensen
- Gilbert
- Lowe
- Bogado
-
Tight Five (and Forwards in general) going well. Loosies is an interesting one, reckon Frizell has been off the boil, and though I think Renton has been good, I also think MMT is definitely an upgrade.
-
Fakatava isn't better than Smith, but I maintain having him start, adding spark whilst also focusing on his own game before unleashing Smith with 25 to go is the best combo... look back to 2021, our win rate doing that was noticeably higher (Remember the Crusaders game where he got injured?)
-
Burns is easily the best 10, once fit again, Millar is ideally in 22 to continue his development - Hunt's punting just isn't good enough
-
As I continue to say, pace required in the midfield. Gilbert has to be at 12 or 13.
-
I still would like to see Bogado in 15, because I think he has the attributes to break a game open, and has a massive punt. Gilbert barely ever slices open a defence from deep.
In terms of a bench, Holland/Hicks has to be the reserve lock, how Tucker is used I'll never know. I'd also go Dawai in 23, as he is someone who could impact a game at least.
-
@friedrugby 10 is once again where i disagree, would take Millar (or even Gilbert) over Burns, he looks all at sea in the game in Melbourne, i think it show 9/10 are probably where the NH and SH games differ the most, dont think you can just slot into those roles, he should have come and done a stint in NPC first
-
That team, yeah, nah.
Forwards are fine.
Backs are a mess.
All of our 10s are shit. It doesn't matter which of them is there from Banks through to Burns. All shit or not currently up to this level.
When has Bogado even played fullback? Except for one game for the Bravehearts, he isn't our great South American hope in the 15 jersey. Hopefully he sticks around for the NPC and plays for Southland? Could be a good opportunity to play some 15 then.
Fakatava, nahhhh. Let him stay on the bench for the rest of the season. What is the point in unleashing Smith with 25 to go when we are down by 20+. Let him keep us in the game, then get Fakatava on when we are close or winning.
All our players are much the same. Cornflakes. Ok, not horrible, but certainly not a full eggs bennie.
-
last year we had Gilbert at 10 for a few games, there was debate how much of his play was a traditional 10 or if we'd just given smith the playmaker role and so gilbert just had to run or pass...which he was quite good at, most often at least getting front foot ball for the next phase.
With TUJ now back and looking dangerous...could that actually be quite a good weapon? rather than TUJ having to basically start on the flay foot after being shovelled the ball from hunt, have gilbert actually attacking the line and either breaking and feeding TUJ or getting over the line and then having TUJ ready at first received for a fast ball to attack the retreating defence?
if we're short on players then Hunt back to 15 which is where he often is on defence anyway and the few times he's looked really dangerous with ball in hand is on the counter attack or coming into the line wider
-
Gilbert is probably the best of the options at 10. He can't be any worse than the other lads.
-
-
@Bones said in Highlanders 2023:
While we're at it, Hunt's kicking from hand. What the fuck is the story there? About 10% of the time he actually does a normal kick, so we know it's possible. Does he just not work on his kicking outside of games? Does he kick like this for Ta$man?
Doesn't need to kick for Ta$man. Just pass to the absolute weapons outside of him.
-
@SouthernMann said in Highlanders 2023:
@Bones said in Highlanders 2023:
While we're at it, Hunt's kicking from hand. What the fuck is the story there? About 10% of the time he actually does a normal kick, so we know it's possible. Does he just not work on his kicking outside of games? Does he kick like this for Ta$man?
Doesn't need to kick for Ta$man. Just pass to the absolute weapons outside of him.
Well it might be nice if he did that a bit more for the highlanders instead of practicing Irish dancing.
-
@Yeahtheboys said in Highlanders 2023:
@cgrant he is absolutely a reserve what r u on about.
The chiefs have ALB and Tupaea
Tupaea ? Are you kidding ? He hasn't played since the 2022 RC and won't figure in this year's SR.
-
To boil it down this is a very poor rugby team. The lack of skill/talent is similar to some of the worst Highlanders sides.
Irish Paul makes some really good points. The key thing the club needs to do is think, who is just not up to scratch and should be having their last years in Dunedin.
Makalio, Johnstone, DLB, Paea, Lentjes, Thwaites, Apisai, Bank, Dawai, Gregory and Koroi should all not be back. While there should be question marks over Hunt, Hicks and CGB.
The question is, if we get rid of these players, who will replace them. So far we know Oli Haig, Hayden Michael and Jake te Hiwi. We have a number of spots to be filled. The issue is, who fills them and will be be better than those who may or may not be leaving.
-
i would get rid of hunt before looking at Johnston, Lentjes and DLB, i think they all still great as off the bench options and i dont get people being down on CGB, he's hardly played but when he doesn he often scores, i have him in at 15 so gilbert can have a crack at qo and hunt to the bench
-
@Kiwiwomble said in Highlanders 2023:
i would get rid of hunt before looking at Johnston, Lentjes and DLB, i think they all still great as off the bench options and i dont get people being down on CGB, he's hardly played but when he doesn he often scores, i have him in at 15 so gilbert can have a crack at qo and hunt to the bench
I'm just not sure if there is room for Lentjes
Haig
Michaels
Withy
Tu'u
Broughton
RentonI think Rogan Wingham is the future back up loosie to de Groot. While I wish we could get Abraham Pole back from Moana Pasifikia. If we could do that, those three would be the three looseheads.
I would like to keep CGB, may be at fullback would be his best position. Probably lacks the top end speed for a winger.
Problem with the squad is there are a lot of ok players; guys like CGB, Gilbert, Lowe, Timu, Hunt, Gregory all just ok. Good at their best, but generally ok.
