Hawkes Bay vs Tasman (RS)
-
Ta$man Mako line-up:
1 Isi Tu’ungafasi, 2 Andrew Makalio, 3 Sam Matenga, 4 Quinten Strange (co-captain), 5 Pari Pari Parkinson, 6 Te Ahiwaru Cirikidaveta, 7 Anton Segner, 8 Shannon Frizell; 9 Jack Grooby, 10 Mitch Hunt (co-captain), 11 Leicester Fainga’anuku, 12 Alex Nankivell, 13 Levi Aumua, 14 Timoci Tavatavanawai, 15 Willie Havili.
Reserves: 16 Quentin MacDonald, 17 Luca Inch, 18 Atu Moli, 19 Jacob Norris, 20 Hugh Renton, 21 Louie Chapman, 22 Regan Ware, 23 Macca Springer.
Experienced trio return for Ranfurly Shield challenge | Marlborough App
The return of a couple of key forwards and a seasoned midfield back are features of the Tasman squad...
-
Well, more seriously, probably better than I expected.
I thought we might be lacking Tu'ungafasi, Segner, and Nankivell for a start.
Nankivell will be a bit underdone, but I think he's particularly important.
Personally, I probably would have played Stupid Shannon at 6, Renton at 8, Big Leicester at 13 and Ware at 11 - but, hopefully they know what they are doing. Overall, it's close to the best 23 we can field this week, but - Jesus Christ - on the books we supposedly have Will Jordan, David Havili and Tom Marshall - and yet we're fielding Willy Havili at fullback?!
-
-
@donsteppa said in Hawkes Bay vs Ta$man (RS):
@chris-b said in Hawkes Bay vs Ta$man (RS):
@Tim Always read the fine print.
There was a split second where I wondered how the Mako$ had jammed a rapid MIQ trial...
They were too busy for that as all there jamming efforts are aimed at getting Jono Bredin appointed to referee the match.
-
-
@stockcar86 He had a game last week so hopefully he will be rested/droppped this weekend.
-
HAWKE'S BAY
15 Lolagi Visinia
14 Neria Fomai
13 Stacey Ili
12 Danny Toala
11 Jonah Lowe
10 Lincoln McClutchie
9 Ere Enari
8 Devan Flanders
7 Brendon O'Connor
6 Marino Mikaele-Tu'u
5 Tom Parsons
4 Geoff Cridge
3 Namatahi Waa
2 Ash Dixon (capt)
1 Pouri Rakete-Stones16 Jacob Devery
17 Jason Long
18 Joel Hintz/Joe Apikotoa*
19 Josh Kaifa
20 Gareth Evans
21 Tiaan Falcon
22 Ollie Sapsford
23 Solomone Funaki*Dependant on late fitness test
6-2 split again on bench including three loose forwards.
TAB: Ta$man $1.56, Hawke's Bay $2.30
-
@number-10 So we're two weeks later and again Flanders is covering lock because we have no healthy and good third lock. I guess Elijah Martin doesn't fall into either category, so why is he even in the squad if our best number 8 is also our best reserve lock? And McClutchie again covering 9, because we still have no 2nd halfback. In the mean time, Ta$man has just added a few All Blacks 7s players to their squad. Why don't we have some good, new additions?
-
Which "healthy and good" third lock and "second" halfback would be available to sign?
-
@number-10 Don't know about lock - I guess Boswell-Wakefield has been seen enough during club rugby that they don't consider him good enough anymore; my new player comment was more about halfback. I wonder why they haven't gone after Kahn Fotuali'i. Yes, he's old, but he still played premiers club rugby, this year. Must be better than no halfback at all. I also wonder whether Ngarohi McGarvey-Black can play halfback, considering he's a playmaker in sevens. He now plays for Ngati Porou East Coast.
-
-
@bovidae They're starting with a very big team.
Basically four locks (if you count Frizell, who Foster recently counted as lock cover) and three props (counting Aumua!).
Makalio is a big hooker, Segner is more a 6 than a 7, and Big Leicester on a wing.
Didn't really work against Waikato, which is why I think Nankivell is such an important addition - providing a bit more speed - and a bit more mobility to come off the bench in the second half.
A leaf out of Hansen's book in vs England? What could possibly go wrong!
-
@stargazer said in Hawkes Bay vs Ta$man (RS):
Just posted on the HBRU Facebook page:
I can see it's a 4:35 kick-off but is that Saturday or Sunday?
-
@stargazer said in Hawkes Bay vs Ta$man (RS):
@hooroo Saturday.
Cheers! Busy day! Golf, Racing and Rugby! Nice
-
@stargazer said in Hawkes Bay vs Ta$man (RS):
@number-10 Don't know about lock - I guess Boswell-Wakefield has been seen enough during club rugby that they don't consider him good enough anymore; my new player comment was more about halfback. I wonder why they haven't gone after Kahn Fotuali'i. Yes, he's old, but he still played premiers club rugby, this year. Must be better than no halfback at all. I also wonder whether Ngarohi McGarvey-Black can play halfback, considering he's a playmaker in sevens. He now plays for Ngati Porou East Coast.
Fotuali'i initially was in Horowhenua Kapiti's squad in July but hasn't been sighted since. Perhaps he's retired, not interested, since he hasn't followed through.
If you have a wish for a sevens player who can cover halfback (McGarvey Black) then you might as well stick with a first five-eighth (McClutchie) who can cover halfback.
I don't think the HB coaches have failed in their duty.
-
@number-10 I don't know why you're so defensive. You sound like you're employed by the HBRU. It was just a vague idea. Not sure whether you understand the meaning of the word "wonder", but it wasn't criticism and it also wasn't a straighforward proposal to sign anyone.
I have the right to feel frustrated, and so is every Magpies' supporter, by the fact that we have no second halfback (let alone a third). We are allowed to question things. If you don't like that, you're at the wrong place. If Enari goes down, we have no adequate replacement so I'm wondering if there isn't someone out ther who could fill the role and who that might be. I never said the HB coaches failed in their duty. Those are your words, not mine.
