All Blacks vs Springboks II
-
So assuming ALB's fitness, if we slot him back to 13, it makes the 'dropping' of Bridge (out of 23) less of an issue, because is pushed out by the best 11 anyway.
As Jacobson was sickness, assume he is back, so Ardie goes to 7, Luke to 8 and Akira stays at 6.
I reckon Webber deserves a start, not sure there is a case for looking good v a tiring Bok defence, they never got out of 2nd gear and with all the breaks, how could they get tired
Which then goes to the bench: Paps in for Blackadder, Mounga will likely come in for Tupaea.
Otherwise same 23 I think...I cant see them resting anyone given it is the last game of TRC (unless they feel someone is farked)
-
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks vs Springboks II:
So assuming ALB's fitness, if we slot him back to 13, it makes the 'dropping' of Bridge (out of 23) less of an issue, because is pushed out by the best 11 anyway.
As Jacobson was sickness, assume he is back, so Ardie goes to 7, Luke to 8 and Akira stays at 6.
I reckon Webber deserves a start, not sure there is a case for looking good v a tiring Bok defence, they never got out of 2nd gear and with all the breaks, how could they get tired
Which then goes to the bench: Paps in for Blackadder, Mounga will likely come in for Tupaea.
Otherwise same 23 I think...I cant see them resting anyone given it is the last game of TRC (unless they feel someone is farked)
pretty much but i would have richie in for Dmac and either keep quinn or have reece on the bench
seems harsh to drop blackadder as if not for jordie i thought he was almost MotM...but not sure how else to make it work
-
@kiwiwomble i think with Reiko as the back up 13, ALB can go to 12, plus they loves them some Dmac so that's why Mounga comes in for Quinn for me.
I think Paps will be more suited to a tight forward battle, while Ethan played well, I think Paps plays with a shade more size, even though I don't think there is much between them.
-
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs Springboks II:
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks vs Springboks II:
So assuming ALB's fitness, if we slot him back to 13, it makes the 'dropping' of Bridge (out of 23) less of an issue, because is pushed out by the best 11 anyway.
As Jacobson was sickness, assume he is back, so Ardie goes to 7, Luke to 8 and Akira stays at 6.
I reckon Webber deserves a start, not sure there is a case for looking good v a tiring Bok defence, they never got out of 2nd gear and with all the breaks, how could they get tired
Which then goes to the bench: Paps in for Blackadder, Mounga will likely come in for Tupaea.
Otherwise same 23 I think...I cant see them resting anyone given it is the last game of TRC (unless they feel someone is farked)
pretty much but i would have richie in for Dmac and either keep quinn or have reece on the bench
seems harsh to drop blackadder as if not for jordie i thought he was almost MotM...but not sure how else to make it work
Wouldn't surprise me to see Havili given a rest. He has taken on a big workload this year not only in minutes but in learning a new position. I think his effectiveness was waning last week and he could do with a freshen up.
Start QT with Weber and ALB for guidance.
This assumes RI on the wing to shuffle in if it isn't working. -
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks vs Springboks II:
@kiwiwomble i think with Reiko as the back up 13, ALB can go to 12, plus they loves them some Dmac so that's why Mounga comes in for Quinn for me.
I think Paps will be more suited to a tight forward battle, while Ethan played well, I think Paps plays with a shade more size, even though I don't think there is much between them.
Why not both - Paps at 7 and Ethan at 6? One of Ardie or Akira start from the bench, probably Ardie at 8 due to the lack of leadership experience in this side, Akira from the bench.
Boks and very liklely England require a tighter game with higher workrate which both players offer in spades. If on top, bring on Akira at 6 at 50 minutes or even 40.
Worth trialling with the Rugby Championship in the bag.
-
@l_n_p i get what your saying and you might be right but i'd be worried about AI taking a knock in confidence if dropped, i think id still like to see him bounce back
-
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs Springboks II:
@l_n_p i get what your saying and you might be right but i'd be worried about AI taking a knock in confidence if dropped, i think id still like to see him bounce back
He's earned a chance to play his way out of it
-
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs Springboks II:
seems harsh to drop blackadder as if not for jordie i thought he was almost MotM...but not sure how else to make it work
Workload management for Blackadder. HE hasn't been around long, and there's another bunch o'games coming after this. Rotate, don't drop.
-
@nzzp how many games has he started in a row? is he really in the bracket of people needing a rest? savea and AI have played more surely so they must be next in line for a rest
-
@kiwiwomble but how many weeks until thier next game?
Unless the player data says they need a rest, I cant see them 'rotating' anyone for this weekend.
-
@taniwharugby to be clear, i wasn;t advocating rotating, i was just saying IF thats the reason for blackadder not playing there are others that have played more... i think
-
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks vs Springboks II:
@taniwharugby to be clear, i wasn;t advocating rotating, i was just say IF thats the reason to blackadder not playing there are other that have played more. i think
Yeah. You were both in agreement
-
I think that "Why not both?" meme is pretty global, I did have it in my mind!
I'm loathe to mess with Akira as well, as I have said on other threads.
Tbh if the AB's had Whitelock as skipper back and Aaron Smith too, it might not be a bad game to tactically try Blackadder (6), Papilli (7) and Akira (8) Savea (bench) But that's not reality ...
I can make a strong case for Akira being told to up his workrate and played again at 6 too, see if he adjusts. So much is about backrow balance and roles. I still think the AB's are absolutely spoiled for choice at backrow.
Can't comment on rotation and energy levels, Fozzie hasn't reached out to me (yet)
-
Pretty certain we will see Ardie, LJ and Akira start with either Blackadder or Paps on bench. Papas if fit would be my guess.
These games are about building squad experience and depth. That also means giving players like Akira a chance to prove he can learn. -
Savea didn't play in the first game against Arg (concussion in Perth) and Ioane was rested in the second Arg test. They have been managing player workload in these 5 tests. There will be a 3 week break until the USA test, when most of the B team will play. So what I am saying is that Foster and Plumtree can pick their best 23.
-
@bovidae said in All Blacks vs Springboks II:
Savea didn't play in the first game against Arg (concussion in Perth) and Ioane was rested in the second Arg test. They have been managing player workload in these 5 tests. There will be a 3 week break until the USA test, when most of the B team will play. So what I am saying is that Foster and Plumtree can pick their best 23.
Strongest team available.
It is the bigger, stronger, faster [cue the Olympics music] Boks we are playing after all.
-
@act-crusader are they more or less kicky this week...can they be more kicky?
-
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks vs Springboks II:
@act-crusader are they more or less kicky this week...can they be more kicky?
I'm not sure they can make a dramatic change? They played this way against the Wallabies too didn't they? If so I don't think they have the confidence or the required level of desperation to change
