Crusaders 2020
-
-
-
@mariner4life said in Crusaders 2020:
@Snowy said in Crusaders 2020:
penurious
he's a rugby player...
He’s a halfback
-
@Stargazer said in Crusaders 2020:
@Hooroo said in Crusaders 2020:
@Stargazer said in Crusaders 2020:
@jegga I doubt Hall is an anti-semite. He made a remark using the word "Jew" in a similarly foolish and inappropriate way many ferners - including in this thread - use the word "gay". Are all these Ferners homophobes?
Saying the word gay isn't homophobic nor is referencing phallic Crusaders symbols.
Saying the word Jew isn't antisemitic in itself either. It all depends on context.
And ? He clearly meant it as an insult
-
-
@Stargazer said in Crusaders 2020:
@jegga I doubt he intended to insult Jews. He was joking about Goodhue, who isn't Jewish. Just like Sopoaga didn't intend to insult homosexuals while he was joking about his team mates for kissing Fekitoa.
so why then was it an "incredibly stupid thing to say" if it wasn't really insulting anyone except his teammate?
-
@Stargazer said in Crusaders 2020:
@jegga I doubt he intended to insult Jews. He was joking about Goodhue, who isn't Jewish. Just like Sopoaga didn't intend to insult homosexuals while he was joking about his team mates for kissing Fekitoa.
You doubt he intended to insult Jews by calling his mate a Jew as an insult?
Er ok . This has been eye opening, I’m out though .
-
@mariner4life said in Crusaders 2020:
@Stargazer said in Crusaders 2020:
@jegga I doubt he intended to insult Jews. He was joking about Goodhue, who isn't Jewish. Just like Sopoaga didn't intend to insult homosexuals while he was joking about his team mates for kissing Fekitoa.
so why then was it an "incredibly stupid thing to say" if it wasn't really insulting anyone except his teammate?
I didn't say it wasn't insulting anyone except his team mate. I said he didn't intend to insult Jews (people other than his team mate). It was stupid of him not to realise that he said something that could unintentionally result in other people feeling insulted.
There's a big difference between intent and effect. If he intended to insult Jews, he could be accused of being anti-semitic. If he didn't intend to insult Jews, but it was an unintended result of what he said, that doesn't mean he's antisemitic. If he should have realised - but didn't - that what he said could have that the unintended result of insulting people, it was a stupid thing to say.
-
@jegga said in Crusaders 2020:
@Stargazer said in Crusaders 2020:
@jegga I doubt he intended to insult Jews. He was joking about Goodhue, who isn't Jewish. Just like Sopoaga didn't intend to insult homosexuals while he was joking about his team mates for kissing Fekitoa.
You doubt he intended to insult Jews by calling his mate a Jew as an insult?
Er ok . This has been eye opening, I’m out though .
Yep. Just like Lima Sopoaga didn't intend to insult gay people by calling what his team mates did gay. I can't remember the uproar on the Fern and lengthy discussions about that in the Highlanders' thread, by the way. Selective outrage?
Anyway, if people are so upset by what Hall said, maybe someone should start a thread in off-topic similar to the Folau thread.
-
-
@KiwiMurph said in Crusaders 2020:
So with Blackadder out I wonder if that means Scott Barrett will play time at 6?
With Douglas presumably at 8, Sanders is serviceable but probably nothing more and Roots is a rookie.
Are you in the right thread??
-
@KiwiMurph The Crusaders are definitely very "light" in the backrow, with most of the loosies being inexperienced. I assume they have someone training with them as injury cover. But who? Is there someone on the fringe of retirement who has missed out on a SR spot?
Hmmm, I wonder how a big lad like - for example - Leicester Fainga'anuku would go in the back row? (being only half-serious here).
-
@KiwiMurph said in Crusaders 2020:
So with Blackadder out I wonder if that means Scott Barrett will play time at 6?
With Douglas presumably at 8, Sanders is serviceable but probably nothing more and Roots is a rookie.
I can't really see it. With Whitelock unavailable, Barrett will be our number 1 lock.
Ethan didn't really have the 6 jersey nailed up - e.g. way fewer Super caps than Sanders.
Main impact, at least initially, is that it gives Sanders, Roots, and maybe even Dunshea, a chance to press for the spot ahead of him.
-
@Chris-B said in Crusaders 2020:
@KiwiMurph said in Crusaders 2020:
So with Blackadder out I wonder if that means Scott Barrett will play time at 6?
With Douglas presumably at 8, Sanders is serviceable but probably nothing more and Roots is a rookie.
I can't really see it. With Whitelock unavailable, Barrett will be our number 1 lock.
Ethan didn't really have the 6 jersey nailed up - e.g. way fewer Super caps than Sanders.
Main impact, at least initially, is that it gives Sanders, Roots, and maybe even Dunshea, a chance to press for the spot ahead of him.
We might also see a Harmon/Christie - Havalli scenario on the flanks. Douglas covers the 3rd line out jumping option.
-
-
I will laugh my tits off if he gets heaps of time and becomes a Super starter (or better).
-
@gt12 I assume it's only for preseason or injury cover (?), but if Cridge would get plenty of game time for the Saders, I'd curse the Canes for letting yet another one go. A 2m tall one, in his case.
I'll only laugh if he continues playing for the Magpies and doesn't sign with Canterbury.
