Convicts v Marxist Land Thieves - Crucket
-
-
@barbarian said in Convicts v Marxist Land Thieves - Crucket:
Well there is ball tampering and there is ball tampering.
I was going to say the same thing regarding throws to the keeper. Players know when they want to bounce the ball in to cause some scuffing or keep the ball off the deck to maximise the shine on the ball.
Using foreign objects is a completely different level.
-
@virgil must be big news to bump a random crocodile story off the front page of the NT News.
We loves the NT News.
-
@booboo said in Convicts v Marxist Land Thieves - Crucket:
@virgil must be big news to bump a random crocodile story off the front page of the NT News.
We loves the NT News.
Love a bit of thai castle too
-
@barbarian said in Convicts v Marxist Land Thieves - Crucket:
Well there is ball tampering and there is ball tampering.
The laws of the game permit you to tamper with the ball by shining it on your pants. That helps the ball to swing, giving your side an advantage. So it's not like this is a black and white issue.
What about deliberately scuffing the ball by bouncing the ball as you throw it to the keeper? Technically legal, but is it ethical? Certainly it's hard to police.
All the players you listed have certainly partaken in ball tampering of some description. But the line is very hard to define here, because some of it is legal.
Everyone knows this crosses the line, though.
Thanks for that, given how difficult it is to police should any amount of tampering be allowed? Or does the tampering simply make the game more interesting?
-
@chimoaus said in Convicts v Marxist Land Thieves - Crucket:
@barbarian said in Convicts v Marxist Land Thieves - Crucket:
Well there is ball tampering and there is ball tampering.
The laws of the game permit you to tamper with the ball by shining it on your pants. That helps the ball to swing, giving your side an advantage. So it's not like this is a black and white issue.
What about deliberately scuffing the ball by bouncing the ball as you throw it to the keeper? Technically legal, but is it ethical? Certainly it's hard to police.
All the players you listed have certainly partaken in ball tampering of some description. But the line is very hard to define here, because some of it is legal.
Everyone knows this crosses the line, though.
Thanks for that, given how difficult it is to police should any amount of tampering be allowed? Or does the tampering simply make the game more interesting?
Well yeah that in itself opens a bit of a cab of worms.....How much advantage does it give? I'm a bit of a burly left armed but I doubt tampering with the ball is gonna make me Mitchell Johnson overnight.
-
@barbarian said in Convicts v Marxist Land Thieves - Crucket:
They were too brazen, too stupid and they got caught.
Only reason this post got 7 likes so far
-
@chimoaus said in Convicts v Marxist Land Thieves - Crucket:
Thanks for that, given how difficult it is to police should any amount of tampering be allowed? Or does the tampering simply make the game more interesting?
Outlawing it completely isn't really an option, purely because the ball naturally picks up dirt/grass during the game and a bowler sometimes has to clean that off to deliver a ball. Policing that seems overly officious.
I think you could make a pretty strong case to legalise ball tampering, on the proviso that players can't use any implements or tools to physically aid them. So you can scuff it, scratch it with your nails, throw it into the turf, suck on mints and shine it etc etc
That's probably a better outcome than prohibition, and easier to police.
-
@bovidae said in Convicts v Marxist Land Thieves - Crucket:
@barbarian said in Convicts v Marxist Land Thieves - Crucket:
Well there is ball tampering and there is ball tampering.
I was going to say the same thing regarding throws to the keeper. Players know when they want to bounce the ball in to cause some scuffing or keep the ball off the deck to maximise the shine on the ball.
Using foreign objects is a completely different level.
That is already outlawed now though, tightened up on in the last few years - deliberately throwing it into the ground on the way back to the keeper. But this is only really applied to an infielder throwing it in deliberately on the bounce. Not boundary-riders.
Personally think that ruling is a bit stupid. If a team want to scuff it up by letting it bounce I don't care much. Surely this in itself takes some skill (and risk if it also scuffs the shiny side)?
It has to be pretty blatant for an ump to call on this.
-
so far my favourite bit of all this is reading an article where Michael Clarke hasn't completely ruled out a comeback as the Aussie captain.
Me either Michael, me either
-
@mariner4life said in Convicts v Marxist Land Thieves - Crucket:
so far my favourite bit of all this is reading an article where Michael Clarke hasn't completely ruled out a comeback as the Aussie captain.
Me either Michael, me either
I'm waiting for Smith to come out and say Clarke taught him everything he knows
-
@mariner4life said in Convicts v Marxist Land Thieves - Crucket:
so far my favourite bit of all this is reading an article where Michael Clarke hasn't completely ruled out a comeback as the Aussie captain.
Me either Michael, me either
To think I thought Clarke was the biggest dickhead Aussie captain of recent memory....consider me reeducated...
-
-
Yes Astle!! Lovely bowling. Getting some really nice drift, set the batsmen up for he wrong'un, and then executed beautifully.
-
@no-quarter said in Convicts v Marxist Land Thieves - Crucket:
Yes Astle!! Lovely bowling. Getting some really nice drift, set the batsmen up for he wrong'un, and then executed beautifully.
Umm wrong thread dude
-
@virgil said in Convicts v Marxist Land Thieves - Crucket:
@no-quarter said in Convicts v Marxist Land Thieves - Crucket:
Yes Astle!! Lovely bowling. Getting some really nice drift, set the batsmen up for he wrong'un, and then executed beautifully.
Umm wrong thread dude
Was just providing an example to the Aussies on how to take wickets with smart cricket instead of cheating...
-
I feel like we have been camped in this thread the past 24 hours or so
