All Blacks v BI Lions Test #3
-
@kiwiinmelb said in All Blacks v BI Lions Test #3:
@jegga I'm not so sure we had a great alternative to rangi anyway when tana went down , nonu was selected as the back up 13 but he was no where near the reliable player he became later .
Mils should've played 13 , rangi 15 though .Yep, one played most of a Super campaign at centre yet they put the guy who had barely played there at 13. Idiots.
-
-
@pakman Dagg or Smith go well at 14...
-
@KiwiPie said in All Blacks v BI Lions Test #3:
One of the reasons the ABs never got much continuity (and zero tries) was the ridiculous number of infringements by the Lions. It felt like every time the ABs had possession in the Lions half, then there would be a penalty. And a man down and in those conditions, you have to take your penalties. And they were all kickable yet BB missed a couple of sitters. 10 kickable penalties in all - when you see a number like that, you wonder how the Lions were never on a team warning for repeated offences - especially as the offside line seemed to disappear completely at times.
I want to upvote that several more times.
As this is a "next test" thread we probably need Hansen to stop being so magnanimous in defeat and have a good old whinge in the press. I was getting quite pissed (and pissed off) that the Lions had multiple penalties in the red zone and I can't even recall a warning? Poite will have to listen to his "help" more than Garces to eliminate some errors.
In the hope that the above doesn't come across as a ref whinge, Garces did award us the penalties, just not a repeat offending card (would have evened up the on field numbers) and Barrett missed a couple of course.
We really need a reliable goal kicker if the opposition can continually offend and we can't convert to points. With 15 on the field we would have had more options I suppose.
-
Although the injury concerns are in the backs I wonder if Romano might be an option on the bench. S Barrett has been OK but some extra bulk would be useful in what is expected to be a brutual test match.
Where is Squire with his injury? IIRC Hansen said he might be available for the 3rd test. With both locks able to put in an 80 min shift he might provide more impact along with Ardie.
-
@pakman said in All Blacks v BI Lions Test #3:
@Nepia Of all the times someone's had the smart idea of playing a player out of position I'm struggling to think of one which worked. Plenty have been disasters though!
Funny how it's "out of position" when we lose notable tests.
I didn't really rate Tana in the midfield TBH. Serviceable at best, and a default option at a time when we really struggled at centre (pre Conrad). Yet his time there is considered a success.
-
@shark said in All Blacks v BI Lions Test #3:
@pakman said in All Blacks v BI Lions Test #3:
@Nepia Of all the times someone's had the smart idea of playing a player out of position I'm struggling to think of one which worked. Plenty have been disasters though!
Funny how it's "out of position" when we lose notable tests.
I didn't really rate Tana in the midfield TBH. Serviceable at best, and a default option at a time when we really struggled at centre (pre Conrad). Yet his time there is considered a success.
WTF? Are you serious? He was up with the best in the world in his era as a 13.
-
My thoughts
-
Poite is a good ref, he is eccentric around the scrum, though. That is where NZ has actually had dominance, so I'm not worried, it might even work in our favour.
-
Pack unchanged. I would give some thought to Fafita ahead of Barrett on the bench, but that is not without risk. I suppose Romano ahead of Barrett is also an option. Would have been great to have Coles available.
-
Those suggesting a starting backline involving Laumape (cap 2), Ioane (cap 5), JB (cap 1), ALB (cap 13), I don't think so. Too much risk in a pressure cooker 3rd test. Crotty HAS to be involved if he is fit, we have looked like a sieve on defence at times. Ioane is a great finisher, but his work-rate is currently low, Savea would have been a better option yesterday. Also, those slating Cruden and opting for Sopoaga - he is just as prone to trying crossfield kicks and the like at crucial moments.
Starting pack - unchanged
Starting backs (9-15): Smith, Barrett, Savea, Crotty, ALB, Dagg, JBJust think Dagg is better at 14, can't believe I'm writing that after he was rubbish at 14 at the Crusaders under Blackadder, but has been an inspired move by Hansen.
-
-
If the ABs are going to make a tactical change to the way the backs play, they could go TJP for the start.
-
@Billy-Tell said in All Blacks v BI Lions Test #3:
If the ABs are going to make a tactical change to the way the backs play, they could go TJP for the start.
We already have an annoying halfback commentating the game for us in Justin Marshall
-
@Nepia said in All Blacks v BI Lions Test #3:
@shark said in All Blacks v BI Lions Test #3:
@pakman said in All Blacks v BI Lions Test #3:
@Nepia Of all the times someone's had the smart idea of playing a player out of position I'm struggling to think of one which worked. Plenty have been disasters though!
Funny how it's "out of position" when we lose notable tests.
I didn't really rate Tana in the midfield TBH. Serviceable at best, and a default option at a time when we really struggled at centre (pre Conrad). Yet his time there is considered a success.
WTF? Are you serious? He was up with the best in the world in his era as a 13.
@Nepia said in All Blacks v BI Lions Test #3:
@shark said in All Blacks v BI Lions Test #3:
@pakman said in All Blacks v BI Lions Test #3:
@Nepia Of all the times someone's had the smart idea of playing a player out of position I'm struggling to think of one which worked. Plenty have been disasters though!
Funny how it's "out of position" when we lose notable tests.
I didn't really rate Tana in the midfield TBH. Serviceable at best, and a default option at a time when we really struggled at centre (pre Conrad). Yet his time there is considered a success.
WTF? Are you serious? He was up with the best in the world in his era as a 13.
Yep 100% serious. Depth was so bad during his era at 13 that Mark Robinson played tests and we shifted Rangi to 13 in 2003. He was there by default and was no great shakes. Not hard to be "up there with the best in the world in his era" given there was Mortlock and then daylight.
-
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks v BI Lions Test #3:
@pakman Dagg or Smith go well at 14...
So did Jane who was mostly a FB previously for the Canes
-
@Nepia said in All Blacks v BI Lions Test #3:
@shark said in All Blacks v BI Lions Test #3:
@pakman said in All Blacks v BI Lions Test #3:
@Nepia Of all the times someone's had the smart idea of playing a player out of position I'm struggling to think of one which worked. Plenty have been disasters though!
Funny how it's "out of position" when we lose notable tests.
I didn't really rate Tana in the midfield TBH. Serviceable at best, and a default option at a time when we really struggled at centre (pre Conrad). Yet his time there is considered a success.
WTF? Are you serious? He was up with the best in the world in his era as a 13.
yeah i thought he was a warrior in the midfield ,and complimented Mauger very well IMO.
-
Can we please not let the 3rd test build up thread descend into a historical tana umaga thread. 3rd test people!
-
I'm not really getting all the suggestions we have to revamp the backline to bring in a kicker. BB didn't have the greatest of games but he kicked 21 points yesterday. If all the brilliant finishers in the team had done their jobs, and we weren't a man down we should have scored a couple of 5 pointers and 7 penalties would have been plenty. If we have to rely exclusively on penalties to get us home I'm not sure I can be arsed watching.
Anyway if we're that worried swap out Cruden for Sopoaga, who as well as a boot has the bonus of offering a degree of creativity ad decent pace. The fact he seems to have turned himself into something of a brick shithouse during the past year is kind of reassuring too.
I never thought I'd say this either, but I think we need Romano on the bench as well. S Barrett looks to have some skill but he's very green.
-
yeah if the so called kicker isnt in the best run on 15 , I wouldnt pick him either , who ever he is
-
