Super Rugby 2024
-
@Duluth said in Super Rugby 2024:
I have dominant tackles for each match. Unfortunately I don't have season counts for that though
Could you share this? Shouldn't be too hard to total them up.
-
@delicatessen said in Super Rugby 2024:
@Duluth said in Super Rugby 2024:
I have dominant tackles for each match. Unfortunately I don't have season counts for that though
Could you share this? Shouldn't be too hard to total them up.
There's a couple of manual steps to get to the match stats.. unfortunately it would take a while to open them all
Dominant tackles is a weird stat too. I'm not sure what the exact definition is. I remember a couple of Cane hits during the RWC thhat didn't register. Then there's the tactical difference where some teams opt to hold up the ball carrier more often
-
Apparently Derpus writes for The Roar now:
-
@Tim where do these deluded clowns think money is going to come from to prop up the game in Oz? I've read stupid ideas that a national club championship can be funded from SR. Ding ding ding dickhead - the SR clubs are on the bones of their arses; there's no spare cash to fund another tier at the moment.
Then another comment suggesting a semi-pro competition could see the Wallabies rise to fifth in world rankings. It seems The Roar comments section is for people who've been touched in the head. Then one of them wins a prize and gets to write an article.
The inevitable sadness of being raised during a golden period and then the reality of middle age and return to the norm sets in.
-
@antipodean It is truly delusional. Half of them think that Shute Shield will prepare players for test rugby.
-
@Tim I have actually just replied to that column mate, and said basically I see he suggests pulling plug on super for Aus teams as they not making grand final, so to be consistent, I assume he wants Wallabies out of WC too?
And no more Bledisloe cup games, perhaps Wallabies should just play Island teams and Japan etc?
Just amazes me writers/etc from anywhere suggesting it's too hard, so lets just play ourselves. -
@Tim said in Super Rugby 2024:
Apparently Derpus writes for The Roar now:
Kiwis don't care. Well 30k already sold for other semi, more to the point kiwis don't want to watch a foregone conclusion (tho I do, as I get stressed about live games, I love a smashing!). Git gud Ozzie, ffs, we need it
-
@Dan54 said in Super Rugby 2024:
@Tim I have actually just replied to that column mate, and said basically I see he suggests pulling plug on super for Aus teams as they not making grand final, so to be consistent, I assume he wants Wallabies out of WC too?
And no more Bledisloe cup games, perhaps Wallabies should just play Island teams and Japan etc?
> Just amazes me writers/etc from anywhere suggesting it's too hard, so lets just play ourselves.Rugby equivalent of incels
-
I'm confused, isn't the Aussie mythos about being the underdog, the little guy, eking out an incredible win due to toughness and determination?
-
@nostrildamus yeah but thats the point...they have now lost the belief they can win....that part was kind of key
@Machpants said in Super Rugby 2024:
@Tim said in Super Rugby 2024:
Apparently Derpus writes for The Roar now:
Kiwis don't care. Well 30k already sold for other semi, more to the point kiwis don't want to watch a foregone conclusion (tho I do, as I get stressed about live games, I love a smashing!). Git gud Ozzie, ffs, we need it
thats kind of important though isn't it, would be good if we could get to the point that people still turned up or tuned in just to see their team play, even if its a hiding....thats should be fun to watch
-
We need to open up eligibility more. Will help even up the competition. Have top quality kiwis spending a year or two in Aussie. Have some Wallabies over here.
-
What top quality Kiwi wants his AB prospects ruined?
-
@antipodean i think he's meaning all ABs to be selected for Aussie teams
-
@Kiwiwomble said in Super Rugby 2024:
@antipodean i think he's meaning all ABs to be selected for Aussie teams
What top quality AB wants his chances ruined ?
And how will they get paid?
I’m in favor in principle, but those feel like two pretty big questions that would need answers. It also won’t help the Oz depth now they have a more appropriate number of teams.
-
@gt12 said in Super Rugby 2024:
@Kiwiwomble said in Super Rugby 2024:
@antipodean i think he's meaning all ABs to be selected for Aussie teams
What top quality AB wants his chances ruined ?
And how will they get paid?
I’m in favor in principle, but those feel like two pretty big questions that would need answers. It also won’t help the Oz depth now they have a more appropriate number of teams.
to start with...not my post, was just clarifying what i believe was being suggested
but, to play devils advocate, i dont think playing for an aussie team would inherently ruin a players chances, guys keep getting picked from the Highlanders even though we're shit more often than we're good
also, we're bound too see BB back and he hasnt even been playing in the same comp, so class can shine through
i assume they would get paid proportional to their representations in squads, work out what they would get paid if playing for a NZ team and subtract that from their AB's deal?, other countries seem to work it out so im sure it can be done
-
I get the Aussies just want to win, but letting the Aus sides buy kiwis to do it is a terrible idea for their rugby. They just axed 20% of their professional spots, but to tie up more with overseas players just narrows their potential pathways even more.
-
@mariner4life said in Super Rugby 2024:
I get the Aussies just want to win, but letting the Aus sides buy kiwis to do it is a terrible idea for their rugby. They just axed 20% of their professional spots, but to tie up more with overseas players just narrows their potential pathways even more.
it makes sense in some cases. Not often, but it can - if you can get a solid journeyman/standard setter with no equivalent locals. Dare I say a 'glue' player
That's not what happens though, you throw shedloads of cash at failed leaguies or 'flashy' players who may get bums on seats.
-
@Kiwiwomble said in Super Rugby 2024:
@nostrildamus yeah but thats the point...they have now lost the belief they can win....that part was kind of key
@Machpants said in Super Rugby 2024:
@Tim said in Super Rugby 2024:
Apparently Derpus writes for The Roar now:
Kiwis don't care. Well 30k already sold for other semi, more to the point kiwis don't want to watch a foregone conclusion (tho I do, as I get stressed about live games, I love a smashing!). Git gud Ozzie, ffs, we need it
thats kind of important though isn't it, would be good if we could get to the point that people still turned up or tuned in just to see their team play, even if its a hiding....thats should be fun to watch
yeah there's a different kind of self-delusion going on in Australia every so often. Or maybe it's just trying to have everything both ways..
-
@gt12 said in Super Rugby 2024:
@Kiwiwomble said in Super Rugby 2024:
@antipodean i think he's meaning all ABs to be selected for Aussie teams
What top quality AB wants his chances ruined ?
And how will they get paid?
I’m in favor in principle, but those feel like two pretty big questions that would need answers. It also won’t help the Oz depth now they have a more appropriate number of teams.
Players asked to play in positions that make them uncompetitive with peers, overworked and playing to look like a donkey. Our front rowers are taking a battering this year - would we have wanted the remaining fit ones over at the Tahs this season? Who thinks players like Proctor would be making a case for selection playing for the Rebels or Force?
And predictably someone will point to long term ABs who have taken sabbaticals, totally ignoring that they're a known quantity when they left and return to play in the same position having taken what we all know is a playing R&R.
-
@antipodean said in Super Rugby 2024:
@gt12 said in Super Rugby 2024:
@Kiwiwomble said in Super Rugby 2024:
@antipodean i think he's meaning all ABs to be selected for Aussie teams
What top quality AB wants his chances ruined ?
And how will they get paid?
I’m in favor in principle, but those feel like two pretty big questions that would need answers. It also won’t help the Oz depth now they have a more appropriate number of teams.
Players asked to play in positions that make them uncompetitive with peers, overworked and playing to look like a donkey. Our front rowers are taking a battering this year - would we have wanted the remaining fit ones over at the Tahs this season? Who thinks players like Proctor would be making a case for selection playing for the Rebels or Force?
And predictably someone will point to long term ABs who have taken sabbaticals, totally ignoring that they're a known quantity when they left and return to play in the same position having taken what we all know is a playing R&R.
My feeling is exactly that those risks would require much higher payments (i.e., to balance out the chance of losing an AB spot due to local pressure or shit coaching etc). I can't see the Oz sides having that money - or at least not spending it in that way.
If they had the money, they could have been recruiting guys like Patchell this year anyway.
One idea I think could be interesting would be if JVs could be set up between Super franchises and Japanese league teams or the JRFU. There might be some money there and access to one or two Japanese players with enough talent to contribute.
It's surprising how many people still support the Reds here after they had Goromaru, that sort of recruiting could be much more fruitful for the Oz teams.
